alternatehistory.com

The Poles often seem to get overlooked somewhat in WWII even though they made a rather sizeable contribution, possibly in part because their largest formation operated in Italy itself an often overlooked campaign. The challenge here is to get the largest number of Poles fighting in the West rather than as part of the Polish Forces in the East and to make them have the largest impact possible. Now the Polish government was able to evacuate enough men to form four infantry divisions and an armoured brigade in France, Sikorski's Army, after Poland fell, and after France collapsed 20,000 or so of them escaped to the UK. In the USSR after he ordered the invasion of the eastern half of the country Stalin apparently had something like 1.5 million Poles including 200,000 prisoners of war arrested and forcibly removed. Some of them would be later evacuated to the west to help form the Polish I and II Corps whilst others would volunteer or be conscripted to become part of the Soviet Polish Forces in the East.

The Soviet evacuation of Poles to the west via Persia after the Sikorski–Mayski agreement was somewhat haphazard with no food or transport seeming to be provided to that people had to make their own way on foot. Could Churchill perhaps have been able to play a bit more hardball by pointing out the awkward fact of Britain having entered the war to help protect Poland and linking shipments of British supplies to a properly organised evacuation of Polish prisoners of war so that the full 200,000 or so troops were moved to the Soviet-Persian border? Whilst it deprives them of a large number of meat-shields he could reasonably point out that after their recent experiences few of them would likely be 'politically reliable' as it were. For France the best I can think of is considering that due to logistical problems many units were short of equipment the French government concentrates on arming French units so that other than the armoured 10th Brigade the four infantry divisions are too understrength to see action and still forming up in the west of the country allowing most of them to evacuate to the UK. That would give the Polish government-in-exile 230,000 odd troops, not to be sneezed at.

Using late-war British organisation that's the equivalent of roughly four corps each made up of an armoured division, two infantry divisions and an armoured brigade, not counting attached division, corps or army troops. You have to expect that not all of the manpower evacuated will be able/suitable to serve however, leave spares for combat replacements and independent units like the Parachute Brigade so knock that down to three fully formed corps. Not much change for II Corps down in Italy but in North West Europe that could potentially see a Polish III Corps joining I Corps to form a small two-corps First Polish Army. The first thing that springs to mind is closing the gap at Falaise, but ignoring that would extra troops make any major changes? You've also got the problem of supply considering the strained logistics system they already had in our timeline. Anyway this was just a random idle idea I had.
Top