AHC: European Israel

The only place there's a large amount of Jews in Europe is in Poland and the USSR, and I just can't see the Jewish people massivly supporting communistic views.The only other place I could see them settling is where Israel is now.

Many of the initial settlers in Israel were in many respects living a much truer form of communism on the kibbutz than anything you could find in the USSR.
 
If safety is an issue, how is that any different than OTL?

Because going up against Arabs is one thing, going up against the Germans and the Russians are something else. With the former they could count on being better trained and equipped even in the mid to long run than their opponents with the latter they could not. Neither the Germans nor the Russians would need to use guerilla warfare as they would squash Israel quite easily in a straight up fight.
 
I always wanted to bring that up:

http://medinatweimar.org/

;) Relax, its just an satire.

flyer-MW-e1401562561644-300x171.jpg


"Retro-Avant garde".

Awesome. Thanks for posting this link - love Retro-Avant grade.
 
Last edited:
If Israel was located in Europe, would there still be trouble with Israel and her neighbours?

Yes, certainly if it were carved out of Poland or Russia. Both have been historically VERY Anti-sematic and you could expect either or both to start a war with it ASAP. The Germans might not as they MIGHT see it as just compensation for the Holocaust but even that is far from a sure thing.
 
That would mean that Israel could take part in the Eurovision Song Contest and UEFA soccer championships.

Cheers,
Nigel.

Israel does participate in the Eurovision Song Contest quite regularly and a lot of other non-European Mediterranean states like Morocco (participated in 1980), Algeria, Tunisia, Lybia, Egypt, Jordan and Lebanon are all members of the European Broadcasting Union, which is the sole requirement for participation in the contest.
 
Israel does participate in the Eurovision Song Contest quite regularly and a lot of other non-European Mediterranean states like Morocco (participated in 1980), Algeria, Tunisia, Lybia, Egypt, Jordan and Lebanon are all members of the European Broadcasting Union, which is the sole requirement for participation in the contest.

Sorry, I forgot to insert a smiley in my text.

Israel is also a member of UEFA.

Cheers,
Nigel.
 
This was never a realistic possibility IMO. It was proposed by some members of the Jewish Antifascist Committee. It is even possible that the original proposal was a deliberate provocation, so that members of the Committee could later be accused of treasonable "Jewish nationalist" designs to separate Crimea form the USSR. See footnote 35 at http://books.google.com/books?id=BuId8fhsFLQC&pg=PA419
If this article is to be believed, the idea 1st surfaced in 1923 and Molotov was supportive of its later version. So the pod of Stalin dying early leading to a Jewish Crimea seems to have merit.
Personally, I'd like to go on a cruise to Isralie Crimea
Seconded.
 

Vexacus

Banned
No idea that communist East Germany was the Soviet occupation zone in Germany?

I realise that now, but when I posted the map, I did not notice it due to lack of sleep & coffee. I might post an updated map later though I may just let this thread die
 
Top