AHC: Eradication of Literacy in Europe after Antiquity?

A tall order, I know, but I wonder if it's possible that a multitude of factors could have eradicated literacy of Europe outside of perhaps the Eastern Roman Empire and Scandinavia by the time the alt-Middle Ages roll around. Some ideas I had were:

- No Christianity: Having the Church butterflied means that there won't be an organized clergy recording information and technology, and if no other messianic religion takes hold then most of Europe will stick to its local cults without any organized framework. Additionally, Islam being butterflied as well means that there will be perhaps less trade in Europe, and therefore less record-keeping.

- Colder Europe: While Europe's population increased especially in the north during the Medieval Warm Period, have instead an earlier and longer Little Ice Age would cause a dramatic shrinkage in population even greater than OTL, and would mean that there would be even more of a focus on sustenance agriculture. With even less people and even more farmers, illiteracy would be even more common. It would also lead to more...

- More Migratory Invasions: With a colder and less fertile Europe, the Germanic Peoples are going to invade beyond the Rhine and Danube even more then OTL, and if some Huns or other Central Asians reach Gaul, then they're going to ransack everywhere in their path, and the Germanics will as well simply trying to get their distance from them. This would also be prime time to introduce...

- Even More Plagues! As if there wasn't enough screwing, even more deaths from disease would certainly help contribute to the death of literate people. It doesn't have to be Black Death level, but it would certainly do a lot of damage.

Could a combination of all of these factors lead to most of Europe losing the art of writing? Is it ASB? I acknowledge that erasing literacy in the Balkans and Italy would be *extremely* difficult, but I wondered if perhaps no Christianity and more successful invasions would lead to the collapse of the ERE as well.
 
Probably impossible. Even sparsely populated Scandinavia had runic writing. Something like the Greek Dark Ages couldn't happen after Antiquity, because some degree of writing was present across a much wider area, almost the entire European continent.

The peripheral Ireland became a center of literacy and monasticism despite its distance from Rome.
 
Last edited:
Top