AHC American Perrages

If it's an America that peacefully or as a result of a mostly failed Revolution, any peerages would likely be alike to the ones in Britain, although I seem to remember reading that most of the colonies had constitutions banning titles of nobility even before independence. If it's say, a monarchy established after independence, under Washington or Henry of Prussia or whoever, it would presumably be more enlightenment influenced, and there might not be peerages as such. Perhaps something of a cross between life peerages and an order of knighthood could form?

The original Province of Carolina was intended to have a sort of feudal nobility, and so may be of interest to you. This page talks about it.

Just my two cents. There are other people on the board who I'm sure know much more about this than me.
 
It really depends upon how this American kingdom comes into being and when. Here's a possibility from a TL in which America gains its sovereignty peacefully from Great Britain in the 1770s/80s and whos king is British royal:
For his service to the nation in organizing and leading the realm's army, the King has created and bestowed upon General George Washington the title Earl Washington of Mt. Vernon.
 
Probably modeled on British ones in most PODs.

If you do have different titles, they would probably be pseudo-Roman ones. Patrician, Senator, Optimate, stuff like that.

Or like someone said above, you could have new orders, like the Order of the Cincinnati, that have some kind of hereditary rights that come with them.
 
You could have the British decide to do the colonies that way in the first place. Handing out baronies, knight holdings, etc.
 
Top