AH Fixations of Yours

I am wary to say the term "AH Fetishes" because clearly that has certain connotations that could make Google traffic fairly awkward. However, that is the topic. We all may pick up things in our alternate history interests that are rather niche or specific, but which we keep somewhere in our minds as a subject we are interested in. Even if we do not do anything with them in terms of writing, we revisit them and discuss them. For whatever reason, they appeal to us. Despite the title, I am more interested in those niches and oddly specifics that are personal to you, more so than if you are obsessed with Lincoln surviving or something. I'm interested in what you have interest in that is off the beaten path, which most other people do not have that interest in.

One of my own is a massively populated Alaska. I am fascinated by the idea of vast American metropolises in the snow. If you can make it cyberpunk, all the better. And I know that this comes from Mega Man 8. Another is the Beatles breaking up in 1966. I was interested in that to the point where I made a thread, forgot about it, posted another thread a few months later, ended up bumping the prior thread thinking it was the latter, and has two discussions going on simultaneously, confusing both myself and those posting. Another is the idea of humans evolving blue skin. I have no idea where that comes from. It may have been planted by Disney genies, smurfs and a love of blue foodstuffs. I have done threads on those and I reference those every now and then. It isn't an obsessive thing, but it is something subconscious which seems to pop up now and then.

It could even be something like the types of topics you seem to post. I know that for myself, when I think about it, I do a lot of collaborative topics that have some mechanism built in to induce response and have posters keeping the topic going. A lot of those have been things like AH story threads, where someone will post a bit, another person will post a bit, and the narrative unfolds into an AH story no one is controlling and everyone is watching. I seem to like community building exercises.

So what are any of your own AH fixations?
 
I grew up in Northern Nevada and have always been curious about the Washo. By the time of European contact they were a language and cultural isolate trapped between the Paiute and the Sierra Nevada range. Evidence indicates that when the Plains tribes got access to horses they pushed the Uto-Aztecan tribes west, which in turn pushed the Washo in to the hills. I have always wondered what the Washo-Paiute dynamic was like pre-columbian exchange and whether some POD (probably around European contact... maybe before) would have seen a different (better) outcome for the Washo. I have this fantasy about doing a ton of research and writing a TL where Pinyon Pine domestication leads to a Washo empire that survives contact, but I'll never realistically have the time or initiative for it.
 
I grew up in Northern Nevada and have always been curious about the Washo. By the time of European contact they were a language and cultural isolate trapped between the Paiute and the Sierra Nevada range. Evidence indicates that when the Plains tribes got access to horses they pushed the Uto-Aztecan tribes west, which in turn pushed the Washo in to the hills. I have always wondered what the Washo-Paiute dynamic was like pre-columbian exchange and whether some POD (probably around European contact... maybe before) would have seen a different (better) outcome for the Washo. I have this fantasy about doing a ton of research and writing a TL where Pinyon Pine domestication leads to a Washo empire that survives contact, but I'll never realistically have the time or initiative for it.
I lived for many years on the other side of the Sierra, an area inihabited by Maidu peoples. My memory on this is a bit fuzzy but I believe that a member of the local Nisenan people said that their grandfather always told them that they were not at all friendly with the Washo, considering them violent and untrustworthy foes. This became a problem when they sometimes interacted with one another in higher elevations of the Sierra.
 
Last edited:
Alongside some pre-1900 and ASB (mostly geographical) stuff, I am currently tempted to write some media-related AH vignettes:
  • An expanded version of my short scenario of Welsh-language television service.
  • A post-1968 Rede Tupi scenario, where the network ended up being fully nationalized in 1980.
  • A different history of Philippine television.
The only problem that I have beside time constraints is the need of constant research for the material.
 
I have a few of those, such as:
  • Brazil becoming one of the Great Powers and competing with the USA for influence in Latin America.
  • Different nations colonizing the Americas, particularly East-Asian nations, like China.
  • The existence of a Franco-British Union.
I've given some thought to the idea of writing one of these, but I don't really have the time.
 

Archibald

Banned
15 000 tons combat ships across the ages: Armored Cruisers, Light cruisers, Heavy cruisers, Large cruisers, Battlecruisers, Battleships, and Kirovs. That and all those varied gun calibers: 6 inch, 8 inch, 12 inch, 16 inch, 18 inch.
My favorite pet peeve is "the ideal 1947 USN" complete with
- 32 Essex class carriers
- 6 Midways
- 6 Iowas
- 5 Montanas
- 6 treaty battleships (South Carolina / North Dakotas)
- 6 of Calbear beloved Alaska large cruisers, all six of them (heresy !!!)
- a crapload of Oregon / Baltimore / Des Moines heavy cruisers (total 36)
- 10 Worcester-class "light" cruisers (actually heavier than Baltimore / Oregon !)

I once calculated the complete thing had 38 carriers, 23 battleships / battlecruisers and 46 cruisers (let say, 69 escorts, plus 38 carriers = 107 ships).

I like to spent time reading their wikipedia pages and mourning all those ships cancelled by 1945. It would have made one hell of USN by 1948.
 
Last edited:

samcster94

Banned
For me, my main one is pre 1900: a semi-successful Reconstruction that averts the Lost Cause and lessens whatever Jim Crow(other Western countries except South Africa{which is rarely considered such today} never went anywhere that far except under brutal dictatorships) is.
 
Last edited:

Archibald

Banned
somewhere in the corner of my head I want to make a complete list of wanabee american presidents by election, from 1948 to 2000, including primary loosers, VPs and on. People like Walace (henry and george) :p Dewey, Adlai Stevenson, Mo Udall, Llloyd Betsen... and then browse this forum and linked to every TL ever atempted, by election year and by candidate, plus OTL life through Wikipedia. A wiki about it. The total list would be more than a hundred of names.
 

Archibald

Banned
I'm a die hard fan of the space program but by ricochet I've because fascinated by atompunk: the atomic and space ages overlapped in many ways (ICBMs, the roaring 50's, nuclear rockets like NERVA or Orion...)

I wish I could expand my pet TL Explorers into an atompunk, unfortunately I can't really understand how a nuclear power plant work, particularly all those different reactors types (gas cooled, molten salt, sodium-cooled fast breeders, and the likes).

Plus by the time of my POD (1972) the atompunk age was mostly over - the AEC was disbanded in 1974, and TMI loomed in the horizon, 1979... plus Chernobyl soon thereafter.

Still I'm playing with atompunk on a limited basis- mostly through nuclear-powered space stations like the Soviet MKBS.

there is a formidable late atompunk TL to be written, centered on the Army Nuclear Energy Depot, a mind-boggling concept.
The Army wanted to get ride of gasoline and kerosene and feeds its combat vehicles with liquid hydrogen, methanol and ammonia split from air (nitrogen) and water (hydrogen) from mobile nuclear reactors carried on trucks near the frontline !
The program was dead by 1966, but imagine if it had gone through and then the technology been handled to civilians in the wake of the 1973 oil shock.
then again, I don't really understand how can hydrogen, methanol or ammonia can be split from air and water - if it is worth the expense, the devil is in the details.
 
Last edited:

Archibald

Banned
Also, Atomic aircraft: over the last month I've dug deep into the ANP program of the 50's. Molten salt reactors, indirect cycle, and the promise of aircraft running on hot air, not kerosene, hence unlimited endurance and range.
 
Like ramones1986 i'm fascinated by alternative television history. ITV in the UK has had a very varied history and it would be interesting to write a what if. I have tried in the past but its gained little attention.
 
I keep having dominant-party systems, or systems where the main division is "establishment vs. outsiders" rather than anything else, in my timelines. Perhaps relatedly, most of my stuff involves Texas and Texans.
 

Germaniac

Donor
The Ottoman Empire going into the Balkan War with a defensive strategy. Deciding to attack on all fronts against superior numbers nearly cost them their country and arguably led to boosting the ego of Serbia far enough to challenge the Austo Hungarian empire
 
For a while, I had a thing for Objectivist success in the aftermath of a New Deal Liberal dystopia coming true: massive, pervasive government, labor unions growing out of control and strangling industry, psychotic over regulation, and all that sort of thing.
 
Mine are largely small changes that get slightly altered versions of the Spitfire into service. Also RAF use of the Spiteful and Attacker, plus FAA get the Seafang. I've yet to do a Dutch one.

The main one for some time was getting the BAC TSR2 into service - the Tories winning the 1964 election would have done it.

TBH, I'm just a modeller, who does exclusively what ifs, so I'm more interested in the result than cause but a well written and informed backstory is sometimes essential.

It's a genre in modelling that's becoming more and more popular - which can only be good as when I started modelling whifs the tide was very against it and modellers who displayed their whifs at shows faced a great deal of hostility.

It's a broad church, ranging from the almost real to the downright stupid and fantastical. These days I lend myself more towards subtlety and second line stuff. Here's one of my favourites that has most claiming it's real, until I tell them to look a little more closely.

10258854_1646335875582542_1254011452948243193_o.jpg
 
Last edited:
My favorite pet peeve is "the ideal 1947 USN" complete with
- 32 Essex class carriers
- 6 Midways
- 6 Iowas
- 5 Montanas
- 6 treaty battleships (South Carolina / North Dakotas)
- 6 of Calbear beloved Alaska large cruisers, all six of them (heresy !!!)
- a crapload of Oregon / Baltimore / Des Moines heavy cruisers (total 36)
- 10 Worcester-class "light" cruisers (actually heavier than Baltimore / Oregon !)
I Think the Ideal USN was the one built, its all good talking about super 16" or 18" ships but the 6 North Carolina (and KVG) class with the often derided 14" guns won the war anything else would simply have meant more delay. Even the one real test such as the battle of Palawan in 42 against the IJN monster Yamato with its super 18" in the relief of Bataan resulted in a win for the NCs. I know the big gun experts keep dismissing it due to Yamato taking 6 air dropped torpedo hits in the hours before including two golden hits to the screws and rudder but that's why you should not put all your eggs in one supper basket.

The WPA fleet of 1937 might not be as cool as the stuff on later drawing boards but the 6 NCs and 8 Yorks did the job.
 
Last edited:
Top