A True October Surprise: The Added Surprises

Nelson Rockefeller
Nelson Rockefeller is one of the most influential politicians of the 20th century to have never been elected to the presidency, much less win the nomination of his party for the presidency. The grandson of both John Rockefeller Sr., founder of Standard Oil and conservative Republican Senator Nelson Aldrich, Rockefeller was born into a life of privilege and public service. After college, Rockefeller worked for the Venezuelan subsidiary of Standard Oil, learning Spanish and beginning a lifelong admiration of Latin America and its culture. Warning President Franklin Roosevelt of the threat of Nazi influence over Latin America during the early 1940s, Roosevelt created a position specifically for Rockefeller during the Office of Inter-American Affairs, where Rockefeller spent World War II.

Towards the end of the war, Rockefeller was promoted to Assistant Secretary of State for American Republic Affairs, and was vital in creating a regional alliance with the other countries in the Americas. Following Roosevelt's death, Rockefeller served in the United States' delegation to the creation of the United Nations (UN) in San Francisco and was the impetus for the placement of the UN's headquarters in New York, persuading his father, John D. Rockefeller Jr., to donate the land on which it was built.

Although he was shortly after fired by President Truman, Rockefeller returned to public service later under Truman and would remain there for the remainder of Truman's tenure and Dwight Eisenhower's first term, being appointed as the assistant secretary in the newly-created Department of Health, Education and Welfare (HEW). Following his time as the number two at HEW, Rockefeller served as Special Adviser to the President on Foreign Affairs, where he would meet future Secretary of State Henry Kissinger and begin to bring the German-born academic into Republican circles.

Rockefeller left the Eisenhower administration in 1956 to chair the committee that revised New York State's constitution. Following this, Rockefeller bucked nationwide trends and defeated incumbent W. Averell Harriman to become governor of New York, instantly becoming a potential presidential candidate. Rockefeller's first bid was run in a tepid manner, as Vice President Richard Nixon had effectively sewn up the Republican nomination to succeed Eisenhower. Following Nixon's narrow defeat, Rockefeller became the presumptive front-runner for 1964. In the mean time, he won re-election to a second term in 1962 and had begun to make his mark on New York, growing his state's budgets on massive infrastructure projects and large increases in funding for education, welfare, housing and the arts.

The Republican presidential nomination in 1964 was, in retrospect, Rockefeller's best hope to win the party nomination and thus the presidency. However, Rockefeller's liberal Republicanism was at odds with the post-Eisenhower Republican Party, which had begun to move towards conservatism in contrast to the increasing social liberalism of the Democratic Party. In addition, Rockefeller had divorced his wife of three decades in 1962 and remarried a younger woman, something that many in the period before the era of widespread divorce considered to have irreparably compromised his presidential ambitions. Rockefeller's campaign, like his later campaign in 1968, was undercut by his failure to court the delegates that would actually decide the party nominee, which allowed conservative forces loyal to Goldwater to make the Arizona senator the nominee.

The inability of Rockefeller and the "Eastern Establishment" to prevent Goldwater from winning the nomination (and subsequently losing in a landslide to President Johnson) foreshadowed the formerly-prominent liberal Republican wing of the party's slow slide to extinction. State issues, including large budget problems, bloated welfare rolls and an increasingly ungovernable New York City (whose mayor, John Lindsay, Rockefeller was on poor terms with) marked the turning point in Rockefeller's governorship, as the proactive governor was increasingly forced to scale back his ambitions to solve the state's growing list of problems.

Rockefeller initially backed Michigan Governor George Romney as the liberal Republican candidate in 1968, but following Romney's implosion after saying he had been "brainwashed" by the Johnson administration over Vietnam, Rockefeller threw his hat into the ring after Romney's withdrawal. However, former Vice President Nixon had carefully sewn up enough delegates to win the nomination on the first ballot. Rockefeller rejected the entreaties of President Johnson (to switch parties and run for the Democratic nomination) and Vice President Humphrey (to join him on a "national unity" ticket) and supported Nixon in the fall campaign. After Nixon's second defeat, Rockefeller rejected Humphrey's offer of the position of Secretary of Defense, with an eye on the nomination in 1972.

The intervening years would severely damper Rockefeller's chances. His push towards extremely strict drug laws, which were applauded by national conservatives, soon resulted in an explosion in the state's already-strained prison system. When the Attica prison in upstate New York subsequently exploded into a riot and hostage situation in 1971, Rockefeller controversially ordered the National Guard to retake the prison, which ended in the deaths of several hostages and dozens of prisoners. His fourth and final electoral victory, in 1970, was also much closer, with Democratic candidate Howard Samuels coming within 120,000 votes (of the 6 million cast) of defeating Rockefeller.

The 1972 campaign was also not one Rockefeller would fare well in. With California Governor Ronald Reagan copying Richard Nixon"s "Southern Strategy" and the moderate and liberal Republican vote split between Rockefeller, Washington Governor Daniel J. Evans and Illinois Senator Charles Percy (alongside favorite son bids from Ohio Governor Jim Rhodes and Massachusetts Governor John A. Volpe), Rockefeller could not translate his charisma and name-recognition into the position of anti-Reagan candidate until too late. Learning from the Goldwater debacle, Rockefeller campaigned strongly for Reagan, but again the Republicans failed to take the White House.

Having failed in his fourth bid for the presidency and having finally grown tired of the governor's office, Rockefeller waited until a politically advantageous time to resign and give his loyal long-time deputy, Malcolm Wilson, a leg-up heading in the 1974 campaign. Stepping down in 1973, Rockefeller spent two years laying the groundwork of his fifth and final presidential campaign and spent that time working to sort out family matters in the extended Rockefeller clan, including beginning a fractious battle with the next generation of Rockefellers over the generational transition.

Generational transition in the Republican Party was also apparent in the 1976 primary campaignCongressman George Bush, 16 years Rockefeller's junior and wholly in the new mainstream of the party, easily outpaced the older man who many felt would be more at home in the Democratic Party. Rockefeller, admitting when he was beat, dropped out, leaving Bush the presumptive nominee to face President Muskie, ending his time in electoral politics.

Passed over in the Bush Administration for the position of Secretary of State over inquiries about his conduct in the Attica debacle and potentially tricky questions about his complicated financial situation (the position instead going to Nixon), Rockefeller instead acted as the new president's unofficial envoy on to Latin America for the first year and a half of Bush's presidency. The strain of travel on the increasingly unhealthy Rockefeller resulted in Bush ending his services in mid-1978, fearing that the former governor would collapse, or die, in a meeting with a Latin American leader. It was a wise decision, as Rockefeller would suddenly drop dead during an art expo in New York in late 1979, suffering a massive heart attack.

rocky.png
 
I like the "This article is part series about..." boxes. Very underutilized and can convey/imply a lot of other stuff going around.

(Now how can I shamelessly steal this for NSS?)
 
I like the "This article is part series about..." boxes. Very underutilized and can convey/imply a lot of other stuff going around.

Indeed. I wanted to make a Rockefeller infobox, but his infobox ITTL looks pretty much the exact same as OTL (with the only changes being no vice presidency and with a slightly later date of death), so I finally hit upon this template as a way to bring him into TAS plus shake things up a bit.

(Now how can I shamelessly steal this for NSS?)

Just make sure that eventual British PM Peter Hitchens' personal sidebar includes an "Flight of scientists and physicians during tenure" entry and you'll be golden.
 
Joe Biden
Joe Biden was a political rising star for Democrats in the 1980s whose public service and life were tragically cut short by a series of brain aneurysms. A Delaware lawyer, Biden had been heavily recruited for political office by the Republican Party, but drifted away from them after their nomination of Richard Nixon and eventually registered as a Democrat. After a brief stint on the New Castle City Council, Biden mounted an improbable Senate campaign at the age of 30 that unseated long-time Republican Caleb Boggs, helped in part by Boggs' sluggish campaign (the senator having only been persuaded to seek a third term to avoid a divisive Republican primary) contrasting with Biden’s youth and vigor.

One of the youngest senators in history, Biden quickly carved out a comfortable niche in the Senate as a consumer and environmental advocate while supporting an establishment foreign policy stance regardless of the president's party. Ambitious, Biden declared his candidacy for the Democratic nomination in 1988 shortly after becoming the chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee following the 1986 midterms. Joining a crowded field, Biden was, like everyone else, surprised by his Kentucky colleague Walter D. Huddleston's success in the first month of primaries and shrugged off reoccurring bouts of severe neck pain as he campaigned in the furious lead-up to the primaries.

While recuperating after a speech in Raleigh, North Carolina, Biden collapsed after suffering an aneurysm. Emergency surgery prevented Biden from dying that night, but Biden had suffered damage to the speech center of his brain and partial loss of control of some of his extremities on his left side. Writing a statement read by his wife Neilia, Biden withdrew from the campaign, instead planning on returning to the Senate. A second aneurysm in July 1988 left him in a week-long coma, after which he opted to resign, fearing that another coma could leave his beloved state without two full-time senators.

Biden never recovered from his aneurysms, and died in January 1990 at the age of 47. Biden’s eldest son Beau later was elected to a term for the same Senate seat his father held and like his father, opted to retire facing illness that eventually caused his death at a young age.

biden.png
 
Last edited:
Well, shit, now I'm depressed. At least Beau got a longer career...
caedus knows real life is brutal and won't sugar coat it, but he doesn't turn in to an apocalyptic world either. There are great things and tragic things in real life, and he emulates that in all his TLs. That's why I have a great respect for his craft.
 
I suppose Biden was happier ITTL compared to OTL, even if he died far sooner than OTL.

Wouldn't he have been a Republican ITTL, surely it was the fact Nixon won which made him go to the Democrats?
 
Well that's depressing.

Just one thing caedus - wasn't Biden's predecessor and the man he defeated named J. Caleb Boggs?
 
Well, shit, now I'm depressed. At least Beau got a longer career...
Well that's depressing.

Well, think of it this way: Biden's daughter (not OTL Naomi, since she was born post-POD) ITTL gets to grow up and have a family of her own, something that she was never given the chance to IOTL.

caedus knows real life is brutal and won't sugar coat it, but he doesn't turn in to an apocalyptic world either. There are great things and tragic things in real life, and he emulates that in all his TLs. That's why I have a great respect for his craft.

Wow. Thanks for the praise! It's always great to hear that a fictional universe that you've created feels "real".

I suppose Biden was happier ITTL compared to OTL, even if he died far sooner than OTL.

Well, until his aneurysm, he was for sure. Probably still afterwords as well, considering he never lost a wife or child ITTL.

Wouldn't he have been a Republican ITTL, surely it was the fact Nixon won which made him go to the Democrats?

No, Biden registered as an independent rather than a Republican because of then-candidate Nixon in both OTL & TTL. Plus, with Humphrey in the White House ITTL, he'd more easily identify his liberal politics with the Democratic Party rather than the Republicans.

Just one thing caedus - wasn't Biden's predecessor and the man he defeated named J. Caleb Boggs?

Er, yes. Edited.
 
Now I'm imagining a Nelson Rockefeller vs. Joe Biden Presidential election. Considering one man's career was in its tail end while the others began, it would be a tough scenario to plausibility write.
 
Joe Biden was a political rising star for Democrats in the 1980s whose public service and life were tragically cut short by a series of brain aneurysms. A Delaware lawyer, Biden had been heavily recruited for political office by the Republican Party, but drifted away from them after their nomination of Richard Nixon and eventually registered as a Democrat. After a brief stint on the New Castle City Council, Biden mounted an improbable Senate campaign at the age of 30 that unseated long-time Republican Caleb Boggs, helped in part by Briggs' sluggish campaign (the senator having only been persuaded to seek a third term to avoid a divisive Republican primary) contrasting with Biden’s youth and vigor.

One of the youngest senators in history, Biden quickly carved out a comfortable niche in the Senate as a consumer and environmental advocate while supporting an establishment foreign policy stance regardless of the president's party. Ambitious, Biden declared his candidacy for the Democratic nomination in 1988 shortly after becoming the chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee following the 1986 midterms. Joining a crowded field, Biden was, like everyone else, surprised by his Kentucky colleague Walter D. Huddleston's success in the first month of primaries and shrugged off reoccurring bouts of severe neck pain as he campaigned in the furious lead-up to the primaries.

While recuperating after a speech in Raleigh, North Carolina, Biden collapsed after suffering an aneurysm. Emergency surgery prevented Biden from dying that night, but Biden had suffered damage to the speech center of his brain and partial loss of control of some of his extremities on his left side. Writing a statement read by his wife Neilia, Biden withdrew from the campaign, instead planning on returning to the Senate. A second aneurysm in July 1988 left him in a week-long coma, after which he opted to resign, fearing that another coma could leave his beloved state without two full-time senators.

Biden never recovered from his aneurysms, and died in January 1990 at the age of 47. Biden’s eldest son Beau later was elected to a term for the same Senate seat his father held and like his father, opted to retire facing illness that eventually caused his death at a young age.

View attachment 292440

:'(:'(:'(:'(:'(
 
No, Biden registered as an independent rather than a Republican because of then-candidate Nixon in both OTL & TTL. Plus, with Humphrey in the White House ITTL, he'd more easily identify his liberal politics with the Democratic Party rather than the Republicans.
Agreed. Biden came from a working class union family. No way he'd support Republicans over Humphrey.
 
Now I'm imagining a Nelson Rockefeller vs. Joe Biden Presidential election. Considering one man's career was in its tail end while the others began, it would be a tough scenario to plausibility write.

It would also require some POD that could extend Rockefeller's life span. He was pretty sickly in his post-VP years IOTL and dead by the time of the 1980 election, the first one where Biden was eligible to run for president.
 
Last edited:
Speaker(s) of the United States House of Representatives
There have been 55 different men who have served as Speaker of the United States House of Representatives for a total of 64 speakerships since the 1st Congress began its first session in 1789. Unlike in Westminister systems, the Speaker is a partisan figure who is, by convention, the leader of the majority party in the chamber and works to implement his party's agenda. In contrast to the office’s title, the speaker rarely presides over the House (usually giving the job to a freshman legislator) and rarely votes or speaks on the House floor. Instead, the Speaker performs procedural and administrative duties as well as representing his district (although not a requirement that the speaker be elected from House members, every speaker thus far has been a sitting representative). In addition, the Speaker is second in line to the presidency behind the vice president, and when the president is of the opposite party, typically serves as the face of opposition to the president’s agenda.

In the past half-century, the role of the Speaker has changed. The legendary Sam Rayburn (the longest-serving speaker who served a total of 17 years between 1940 and 1961) acted as a mediator between powerful committee chairs who, owing to the seniority system and their seats being safe for the Democratic Party, essentially ran their committees as fiefdoms. The shift of the party, especially on the issue of civil rights and Vietnam, outpaced the older committee chairs and by the 1960s, new congressmen (and women) were increasingly frustrated with the largely southern committee chairs who effectively controlled what legislation could make it to the House floor. In 1973, young liberal members combined with disgruntled veteran lawmakers to abolish the seniority system—instead, committee chairs would be elected by the party's house caucus in a secret ballot and the Speaker would be allowed to appoint all party members on the powerful Rules Committee, as well as the ability to assign a bill to multiple committees.

Despite the 1970s reforms, Democratic speakers from Carl Albert (1971-1977) to Tom Foley (1991-1995) only slowly began to use the office's new powers in a way that made the speaker the predominant figure in the House. It was only with the election of the first Republican speaker in four decades, Dick Cheney (1995-1999) that the modern speakership emerged. Cheney began the centralized, top-down style leadership that has characterized all subsequent speakers, regardless of whether they were Democrats or Republicans, although his successors for the most part have been more transparent both with the media and other members of the party leadership.

skaDwu6.png
 
Last edited:
Couple of notes on this one:

  • I started on Rayburn instead of McCormack (who was speaker during the POD) because it looks a lot better than having McCormack's entry begin the box while cutting off the top half of the entry for the 87th Congress.
  • Because I established Cheney as the 58th Speaker during his infobox without realizing that the main system used on Wikipedia was numbering by each different individual to be speaker instead of by term, ITTL the numbering for Speakers follows the same system as the numbering for presidencies (i.e.- why Dan Coats is both the 60th & 62nd speaker instead of the 52nd similar to how Grover Cleveland was both 22nd & 24th presidents instead of just the 22nd).
  • Again, this one was too big to upload directly even with limiting the box's size to only speakers within the last 60 years ITTL.
  • This box was made because @Nofix behaved himself (more or less). Also because his joking demand for a list reminded me that I'd kicked around making a speakers list before. Only this time, I figured it would be an actual wikibox-style list because those are pretty neat.
 
Yay Speakers!

Couple of notes on this one:

  • I started on Rayburn instead of McCormack (who was speaker during the POD) because it looks a lot better than having McCormack's entry begin the box while cutting off the top half of the entry for the 87th Congress.
  • Because I established Cheney as the 58th Speaker during his infobox without realizing that the main system used on Wikipedia was numbering by each different individual to be speaker instead of by term, ITTL the numbering for Speakers follows the same system as the numbering for presidencies (i.e.- why Dan Coats is both the 60th & 62nd speaker instead of the 52nd similar to how Grover Cleveland was both 22nd & 24th presidents instead of just the 22nd).
  • Again, this one was too big to upload directly even with limiting the box's size to only speakers within the last 60 years ITTL.
  • This box was made because @Nofix behaved himself (more or less). Also because his joking demand for a list reminded me that I'd kicked around making a speakers list before. Only this time, I figured it would be an actual wikibox-style list because those are pretty neat.

I hate the inconsistent numbering done on wikipedia, especially when it's inconsistent between state offices like Governor and Secretary of State (for one). It makes arranging stuff obnoxious.
BFHzCuL.png


I want to applaud the inspired picks of Bonior and Frost, neither of whom I've heard of before

You have no idea how difficult it is for me not to throw out stupid quips, jokes, and crazy requests every update. Y'all better be thankful to me and ME ALONE!
JbJ97y7.png


Fun fact: Dan Coat's is the 7th Speaker of the US House (ITTL) to serve non-consecutive tenures in that office.
 
I hate the inconsistent numbering done on wikipedia, especially when it's inconsistent between state offices like Governor and Secretary of State (for one). It makes arranging stuff obnoxious.
BFHzCuL.png

Agreed.

I want to applaud the inspired picks of Bonior and Frost, neither of whom I've heard of before

I'm kind of surprised, especially since I mentioned Bonior as Cheney's successor in ATOS.

You have no idea how difficult it is for me not to throw out stupid quips, jokes, and crazy requests every update. Y'all better be thankful to me and ME ALONE!
JbJ97y7.png

Expecting praise for basic self-control? What is this, some kind of TL where the author is willing to indulge in silly jokes, memes and other tomfoolery during replies to people?

Fun fact: Dan Coat's is the 7th Speaker of the US House (ITTL) to serve non-consecutive tenures in that office.

John Kasich could be the 8th if 2018 sees a change from his "eat copious amounts of food during campaign stops" strategy that he tried out in 2016.
 
Top