A Jewish Immigrant Takes on America

Intro.
479px-Trotsky1919a.jpg


"In our eyes, individual terror is inadmissible precisely because it belittles the role of the masses in their own consciousness, reconciles them to their own powerlessness, and turns their eyes and hopes toward a great avenger and liberator who someday will come and accomplish his mission."


- U.S. politician Leon Bronstein
-------------------------------------------------

Sometimes, working on TSK gets tough for me, especially during wartime, and writer's block ensues. This timeline is here precisely because of my need to unwind and write something less demanding on research and other things.

Will this be a long running TL, or will it fade into obscurity like my other TSK unwinds? Well, you'll have to stay here and find out. I do hope to continue this TL for at least a while, if that's any solace to you.

Don't expect the same level of 2000 word long posts that you can see in TSK, though.

 
1: Bad Air
220px-Leon_Trotsky_parents_house_in_Kherson_city%2C_Ukraine02.jpg

Maybe there just was something bad in the air that year. Maybe someone pinched someone too hard, creating a butterfly chain reaction that resulted in what we got. Nobody has a clue, but whoever set off that butterfly effect changed history as we know it.

In late July of the year 1879, the Russian and Ukrainian villagers in the town of Yanivka took their scythes and their torches to initiate a pogrom against their Jewish neighbours. It is a sad reality of the Tsarist Russian Empire that in the Pale of Settlement, anti-Semitic actions such as these were frequent, and the causes for each one of the pogroms was just as varied. The most common one, of course, was just lashing out out of sheer hatred. One of the targets of this hatred was the house and lands of the wealthy Jewish farmer family headed by David Leontyevich Bronstein and his pregnant wife Anna Lvovna. Sure, they were non-religious, non-practicing and reportedly couldn't even speak Yiddish, but if there's one thing that can't stop anti-semitism, it's logic and facts.

Bronstein and his family, luckily for them, were informed some time earlier by a villager friend that they had caught the ire of their neighbours, and decided to respond appropriately. That is, by dusting off their boots and getting the hell away.

The vast Russian Empire was well known to the family and was the most obvious choice of their new settlement - maybe moving to Moscow or St. Petersburg, putting their reasonably large money reserves into opening a some sort of shop like many of their brethren? But no, with the pogrom drawing even closer, David Bronstein couldn't feel anything but resentment for the oppressive, tyrannical, bigoted empire he once called home. Other nations sprawling across Europe were no better, and who would accept a Jewish Immigrant there anyway? No, what the Bronstein family had set their eyes on was none other than the prime land of opportunity on the planet, the United States of America. Success stories of impoverished Russian farmers moving to New York or Chicago and becoming millionaires were growing more and more present in debates and pub chats - who cares that many of them are probably made up, or even if they aren't, those successes are only ones in millions? It's America, baby!

The voyage Odessa-New York awaited the Bronsteins in late June of the same year, in the scorching heat of the Russian summer, days before the villagers of Yanivka lashed out against their Jewish neighbours in what was one of many unrecorded acts of anti-semitic violence in Russia in the late 19th century. The few week long trip on the steamer might not have been great for Bronstein's pregnant wife, but they endured the trip, departing in Castle Clinton in New York, known as America's first immigrant registration center. With a few brief checks and a passport grant - thankfully to them, their name and surname was not twisted around at all - the Bronsteins were now citizens of the United States of America!

Much like many of their fellow fresh Jewish immigrants to New York City, the family settled in South Brooklyn - it was only logical for them, Russian-speaking Ashkenazim, to settle down close to the people they would most likely be able to understand. All they could afford was a small home - the family may have been wealthy, in Yanivka, but that's all that the wealth they managed to bring to America could lend them. It makes sense that America has a higher cost of living than poor Ukrainian villages...

It was in this brave New World that the family's first child was born and given the name Leon.
 
Wilson put up with Bernard Baruch's position in wartime administration only because his skills and position simply could not be ignored. Wilson was a particularly vicious racist, and it did not stop with African-Americans...
 
2: Newyorkian Desert
Leo_Trotzki_1888.jpg

New York - the Big Apple, the crown of the United States of America, the gateway to the New World, and a million other titles fit for this giant of a city. The same could be applied for it in the 1880s, when Leon Bronstein went through his childhood, even though the city was much smaller than it would later become and it had not yet been consolidated into one overarching megalopolis. It was a city of wonder and a melting pot unlike ever seen before - if you took a long walk through it, you'd definitely hear at least a dozen languages casually spoken on your trip. New York was beloved by immigrants, after all - as one of the fastest growing and largest cities in America, it was the place where dreams become reality and poor farmers become millionaires, so much so that in old poor Russia, the city and a general sense of wealth had turned synonymous.

But at the same time, under those few rising stars lived millions of impoverished workers, running to make three jobs at once to maintain the well-being of their family. Those were the runt of the litter, many of them immigrants unable to speak English and thus likely never able to ascend past their current state. Hell, in the past, they wouldn't have even be able to vote... And then there are those who fall in neither category. Not necessarily starving and overworked, but not achieving the overblown success stories they likely heard back in their motherland. This was the case with the Bronstein family. David Bronstein was industrious enough to keep his family firmly in the lower-middle class while working in a fellow Jewish-American's clothing factory, yet at the same time not ambitious enough to consider starting his own business or moving further west for more solid opportunities. This was where Leon started his Newyorkian life.

Unlike his more religious Jewish counterparts, the 8-year old Leon did not attend a yeshiva, a Jewish primary school. His parents were not religious and their religious heritage had largely been a burden back in Russia - why do you think they ended up fleeing in the first place? - and as such, their child ended up enrolled in a normal, local primary school. Sure, the teachers and students both had a few problems with a Jew in the same class as them, but nothing too disastrous. Information on Bronstein's early life and education is scarce, and the primary source of information on how the future public figure acted and was perceived during that time stem mostly from the few tidbits of information he himself has released in diaries or official statement, as well as, most importantly, the later writings of Stephen B. Magee, one of his former classmates.

"Leon was the type of person on whom everyone had a some sort of opinion, either you liked him or hated him. For some people he was insufferable, often arrogant, while for others, he was charismatic and amiable. It really depended on what you were in general - but there is no denying that even as a child, he had plenty of charisma. By the fourth grade, he commanded a whole group of students of various ages."

New York's other gift to Bronstein came from the setting in general. Despite its wide and widening social gap, it was a cosmopolitan town, completely opposite from anything you could find in Russia. This experience and environment contributed a lot to the development of the man's international and pluralistic outlook.
 
I wonder how his ideology might change. In the US you don't have nobles or the traditional class systems in play. You also don't have the traditional blockers to change due to the US electoral system.

Trostsky could go on to become President.

One thing I think is interesting is the time period. Mass labor movements are starting to come out in force across the US. We are either mid way through or drawing to end of an era of massive corruption with tycoons and politicians working together to enrich themselves.
 
3: Fair and Square
170px-LeonTrotsky1897.jpg

Leon Bronstein came of age in the year 1897, which was also the year when he advanced from ordinary schooling in Brooklyn and moved on to study mathematics in New York University, at least initially. Although his family certainly wasn't the poorest it could have possibly boon, it wasn't wealthy enough to pay for expensive studies either, especially not for a field they did not see as all that promising. Disregarding his family's opinion, Leon continued, earning the dough in a manner of ways - working as a private English language tutor for fellow Jewish immigrant kids, as well as working part-time in an industrial sawmill. Although both of these jobs were important to shaping Bronstein into the person that he later became, the latter ended up more important, as through the acquaintances and connections he acquired during his work as an industrial laborer, he was introduced to American socialist ideology.

The late 19th century saw a slow, but steady rise of the socialist movement in the United States, similar to the rest of the world at the time. Starting in the 1860s and 1870s, labor movements, trade unions and small, fractured, but rising socialist political movements would crop up across the American scene, their rise marked by strikes, clashes with the police, bombings and suppression. It was around this time that the first outspoken socialist politicians were being elected to public office, like Mayors or Representatives. The ideals of equality, internationalism and progressive legislation which this movement exhibited well resonated with the young Bronstein, filling up the primary slot in his developing political spectrum. After barely passive the final exams and acquiring a bachelor's degree in mathematics (not out of lack of trying of course - more like attempting to hold three jobs at once), Bronstein declared it a job well done and moved on to begin work with New York's labor organizations and trade unions. At a relatively young age, in 1901, Bronstein became a journalist working for The Jewish Daily Forward, a young Yiddish-language daily left-leaning newspaper in New York, working here for the following decade. His Yiddish skills might not have been the greatest, but his colleagues and even the editor, Abraham Cathan, noted his dedication and writing skills. Alongside that, he sometimes submitted publications to the International Socialist Review (at least before it took a turn to hardline Marxism) and the Appeal to Reason, he participated in trade union activities in New York, helping organize meetings and strikes, and even attended as an observer in a few meetings of the Industrial Workers of the World, although did not condone the radicalism of some of the organization's leaders.

It should be noted that while Bronstein was firmly in the left-wing of American politics, his ideology was far from being as radical as some of his compatriots. For example, although affiliated with the Socialist Party of America for the first years of his political career, Bronstein was more of a proponent of slower, democratic reforms to the capitalist system, fearing that an outright revolution could not only end up in a collapse of the system, but also result in a tyranny rising from the shadows. In that regard, Bronstein could definitely be described as a democratic socialist, although calling him a social democrat wouldn't offend everyone, either. Perhaps this is the reason why, both according to him and to various secondary sources, one of his first true political admirations was Theodore Roosevelt, President of the United States from 1901 to 1909. As one of the first heads of state in American history to pay attention to the growing class struggle in the United States and stand for progressive reforms in the form of his Square Deal, Roosevelt caught Bronstein's attention as a potential example of progressive social reforms being possible and achievable in the American political landscape. The President's internationalist stance and successful work in resolving wars and disputes across the globe played into the journalist's innate internationalism, too.

Bronstein enthusiastically voted for Roosevelt in the election of 1904 (thus catching the ire of some of his more radical socialist colleagues, who believed that the Square Deal was too little too late), as well as for his designated successor William Howard Taft in 1908 - although he later regretted the latter vote, much like Roosevelt himself. The Taft administration coincided with Bronstein solidifying his share of influence over the politics of New York - the charismatic, assertive, though also considerably arrogant journalist had become an enduring sight among New York's labor unions and the media, serving as an important anchor for the influence of labor unions over the town and the state, so much so that the political establishment had to recognize that this newcomer could end up going far if left unchecked. Especially with a new, and very contentious election coming up.
 
Lenin without Trotsky will definitely be pretty interesting though it looked Bronstein is doing nicely in his chosen work so far.
 
Lenin without Trotsky will definitely be pretty interesting though it looked Bronstein is doing nicely in his chosen work so far.
The fate of Russia in this TL is definitely going to be interesting, probably just as interesting as Bronstein's career in America, indeed. I've had some thoughts on it, but I have not yet fully decided on which path I want to take, so I'm just as hyped as you are
 
Top