A House of Lamps: A Moorish America

Has arab trade and disease reached the andes yet? i wonder if an earlier arrival and more trading will strengthen the incan empire against future conquests through immunisation and earlier technological progress

The furthest extent of old world disease is probably within the northern end of the Inca territories right now. Certainly Colombia is being ravaged by it already.

There is going to be a much wider gap between when there is significant arab interaction with the Inca and when Old World diseases first arrive, giving them much more time to recover than in OTL, you are right. Of course, there isn't a empire on earth that can withstand 90%+ mortality rates without a little bit of turmoil.
 
15th century Culture and Society in the New World; Part 1
15th century Culture and Society in the New World; Part 1:

Islam among the Yucatec Maya of the 15th century

A Brief History

--------------------------------------------------------
The first Maya converts to Islam were local nobility at Tulum, willing to shed the authority of the batab for the new conquerors of the territory. These first Maya converts were treated very similarly to converted Taino: being given the offer of conversion and taught the shahada through which they repeated it and became Muslim. Also like the Taino, these first conversions took place in private between influential locals with imams and Muslim dignitaries, and were accompanied by the shedding of pre-Islamic religious artifacts. These Maya lords would remove their customary blood-letting belts and sheaths as well as their jewelry and would take in its place a Muslim name to mark their new identity in the ummah. These symbols of status were later used to convince other members of the aristocracy to convert, or even to simply engage Arabs in negotiation over secular matters. Abu Bakr, who personally encouraged many of these conversions as a way to gain control over the local nobility, took great pains to educate himself on the customs of the Yucatecan nobility, and how to wield the symbols of that complex social system to his advantage.

Unlike the Mishiki, the Islamization of the Yucatan was top-down, from the nobility towards the peasantry. Even by the late 15th century most peasants as far north as Mayapan were still pagan or practicing highly syncretic versions of Islam. In contrast, by the same time every lord in the north was fully Islamized. Maya lords were attracted to Islam as a way of gaining favor with the invaders. Unconverted lords often found themselves attacked by combined forces of converted lords and Arabs, and the considerable prestige Abu Bakr acquired after defeated Mayapan in battle repeatedly was a significant factor persuading the aristocracy of the invaders power. Abu Bakrs skill in playing within the established rules of Maya dynastic warfare also ensured that they did not feel significantly alienated by the Arabs.

For example, during the fall of the city of Tecoh, north of Mayapan and the center of one of the smaller kuchkabal client kingdoms, Abu Bakr did everything a Maya lord would have done in taking a captured city. He destroyed the cities stele, burnt the dynastic shrine, captured the local lords and assumed the vacant position at the head of the regional web of authority, demanding the client lords of Tecoh to aknowledge his authority, and that the captured lords forcibly pay tribute. Instead of demanding fealty, like might be done in Iberia, he demanded only tribute at the same time pressing upon them Islam. Abu Bakr betted that if he could culturally and religiously conquer the lords, when given the chance to rebel (as was their right in Maya politics) they would not but redirect themselves to pagan lords nearby. This act of voluntary fealty would be far more convincing than the forced fealty the Maya were accustomed to seeing. This strategy encouraged rapid conversion of the aristocracy within a conquered area but did not require the conversion of the peasantry (who would not notice any real change in their political situation whatsoever). It paid off extremely well, allowing Abu Bakr to quickly conquer the Yucatan and yet face few significant rebellions once he had built up an initial base of converted allies. He recruited an army of sufi clerics to fulfill this task, who themselves developed a robust knowledge of both the Maya language and Maya culture, compacting Islamic theology into a doctrine that was easily understood by the aristocrats they would encounter. Many Sufis could even read and write some Maya glyphs, though only as a medium through which to explain Islamic concepts. By the end of the 15th century, there was a significant Islamized Maya community in the Yucatan, and all the northern nobles were Muslim, if some by name only.

The Islam of the Aristocracy
--------------------------------------------------------

This form of Mayanized Islam, designed to convert quickly, and then create a divide between the convert and their pagan neighbors (and often former allies) and heal one between them and the Arabs, modified Islamic tenets in many ways. Firstly, the theoretical egalitarianism of Islam was minimized, since it was inconsistent with the rigid ponderous hierarchy of Maya society. Second, the tawhid, the oneness of God, was reinterpreted to be about the centrality of God, not necessarily His separation from anthropomorphic characteristics, as the Almohads had seen it as. Third, the first Caliphs and Muhammad were explained as analogues to Maya cultural heroes, paralleling the birth of the Maya in their own cosmogony with the rise of Islam. A sufi cleric, in explaining Muhammad, would describe him as jun camzahob¸ One Teacher, who acted as the messenger between God Ch’an Chaak (some would simply teach the word Alah, in Yucatecan to represent the Arabic name) and taught the people the proper rules of society. To attempt to break the Maya conception of a divided pantheon, many would use the term Chak Na, Great House, or Ch’an Chak Na, Great Sky House to describe the idea of a unified, One (aḥad ) God that exceeded the material world. This allowed God to carry the sort of anthropomorphic traits the Maya could easily comprehend, while still avoiding giving God human or animal form. The Sky was chosen deliberately to represent God as it was formless, omnipresent, and was already a central part of Maya mythology. In some areas, God was associated primarily with the Maize God, or a conflation of the Maize God and Sky.

Old Maya gods were demonized alongside this. Caves, seen as sources of creation in Mesoamerica but as dark, fearful places in Old World cultures, were weaponized as part of this transition. The Maya idea of a temple as a Ch’an Ch’en na , Sky Cave, was turned negative, as a passageway to the underworld, though in the Arabic sense of hell instead of Xibalba. Priests stepping forth from the maw of the earth monster that framed the entrance of these temples were framed as agents of Shaytan, moving from hell to the world to capture man. In contrast, going alongside the Islamization of the Maya conception of the sky, a mosque was described as a Ch’an b’i “Sky Road”, that could ferry believers to Gods side towards paradise (simply Ch’an, “heavens”). The Maya had a far more detailed conception of a ‘hell’ than a heaven, with many groups believing in reincarnation that, through the cycle of corn growing from the earth, so shall humanity rejuvenate. Sufi clerics took this concept and described paradise often in agricultural terms, as a great garden with maize and the crops of the Maya world. Hell was left largely similar to the Maya underworld, though the Gods of Death were conflated with Shaytan (who was labeled jun cichin, First Evil).

The Five Pillars were all given Maya equivalents. The Shahada was an exception, taught only phonetically in Arabic (or often using crude existing Maya syllables to approximate it). Salat was easy for the lords to grasp, being similar enough to the bloodletting rituals that defined royal religious ceremonies with similar acts of purification and prostration (though bloodletting itself was quickly and vehemently stamped out.) Sawn was equally simple to grasp, being comparable to existing Maya beliefs about self-discipline and self-torture as a form of religious devotion. Hajj was equated to travel to sites of spiritual power, an existing and popular activity in the Yucatan. Zakat was more difficult, as the Maya aristocracy was unaccustomed to any sort of all-encompassing social equity like Zakat represented. Many lords would equate this with the existing system of feudal lordship (giving alms through being a good ruler), though that was officially frowned upon.

Certain aspects of Maya religion were stamped out. Human sacrifice, while much rarer compared to the Mishiki, was prohibited in all circumstances, and those priests who administered the ceremonies were often harshly punished. Bloodletting and self-mutilation were equally forbidden, being replaced with purely spiritual renewal. Salat was offered as an alternative to the ritual, through prayer alone the universe would be renewed – ones faith being described in similar terms to blood in pre-contact Maya mythology. Bloodletting needles were often burned in large fires along with ritual regalia and garb after the Islamization of a town.

Maya glyphs were either suppressed, or heavily modified. Glyphic texts served several key functions: to describe dynastic history or ritual history, religious events, or to mark significant calendrical dates (and often all three). Many glyphs were loaded with pre-contact religious symbolism that made the writing system inexorably associated with pre-contact religion. Some early Sufis went through great pains to learn the language, and some even attempted to promulgate an Islamized version that relied on syllabic glyphs primarily, but the easier and quicker Arabic abjad rocketed past it in popularity once there was no religious need to write in glyphs. Glyphic texts survived in the north until the mid 16th century, but even 50 years past contact they were in steep decline.

Once a ruler was no longer beholden to pre-contact routines of ritual that demanded such elaborate, labor-intensive specific texts, they had no use for them in any significant fashion. Arabic was also much easier for non-aristocrats to learn and write, so even those who retained the old system of scribes found themselves drowning in a sea of newly literature Maya middle-class who wrote only in Arabic letters. Despite this, even when Maya did write in Arabic, they would write with many of the same political themes, but from an Islamized point of view. Key events in Islamic history would be associated with mathematically significant Maya dates, and rulers would them tie themselves to these dates, as was custom pre-contact. The Maya obsession with calendars continued, creating a labyrinthian network of Maya calendars paired with the Islamic lunar calendar, which were used for folk-medicine and divination among the peasantry. Many logographic glyphs survived only in this sense, their actual use as a full writing system superseded by Arabic. It would not be uncommon to find divinatory texts that paired archaic Maya day signs with Yucatecan annotations written in Arabic.

The Islam of the Peasantry
--------------------------------------------------------

Aristocratic Maya Islam was radically different from the popular Islam that came to the countryside more gradually. This Islam was vastly more syncretized and more Mayanized, in many ways radical heresy in the eyes of strict theologians but far more compatible with Maya cultural beliefs. Crucially, this syncretic Islam allowed for both greater anthropomorphism of God, and doctrinally acceptable companion Gods. For Instance, alongside Alah or Alaj, there was also Itzammaj, Hun Ixim (the prime aspect of the Maize God), Ixchel, and others. These gods were described as separate names of Alah, just as each of them in pre-contact religion had a wide variety of separate titles to describe them. These kunabob would over time, be reduced to the category of spirits, local dieties that suited the local environment of the Yucatan. A Maya peasant for instance, might leave a sheaf of maize and few black stones in the corner of his new field as an offering to Hun Ah Mun Alaj, One Tender-Shoot God, before planting the field, or a midwife would give an offering of beans and squash to Ix Batimaah [Lady Fatimah] before delivering a child. Rural Maya preserved many customs that fell out of favor in urban areas, with many even offering sacrifices to these kunabob, though human sacrifice was quickly relegated to the domain of sorcery. Maya villages would have a central mosque overseen by an Ah Iman, also called an Ah B’i who managed the mosque grounds, kept the town records and administered the khutbah. He also oversaw the ritual calendar of the town and was expected to act as an herbalist as well. Maya folk magic, called K’intz’ib’, lit. “Sun Writing” blended Islam into existing beliefs about bodily and spiritual health (ones ch'ulel or soul), and the Iman was expected to be well-versed in the practices of the area he was serving. These countryside Imanob were seen as little more than rustic shamans by those Arabs and upper-class Maya in the cities. This stereotype hides the complexity of the new religious systems derived in the post-contact period. K’intz’ib’ was a vital component of rural life, and promoted social cohesion.

To speak briefly on the topic, it being vital to understanding how rural Maya adapted Islam to their beliefs, K’intz’ib’ was broadly, a collection of folk-spirits and folk-remedies to bodily and spiritual harms.​
The goal of K’intz’ib’ was to promote spiritual goodness (chul’el) through acts of faith (iman), self discipline (chokij), and the observance of ritual cycles (xahaab). The Maya practitioner of it recognized a similar universe to that of his ancestors, with a great world ceiba tree that spanned the underworld through to paradise. This tree was divided into five cardinal realms (north, south, west, east and center), associated with a color, ritual numbers, spirits and revered Islamic saints. For example, North, xaman was white, it was the direction of the moon, Ixchel and Ix Batimaah (conflated into the same diety), the sky above and paradise, the seat of Alaj, and the domain of the angel Kabiral [Gabriel]. North could also be read as the sky-turtle shell through which Ixim Alaj emerges to give food to man, the milky way, and the number 7. A Imanob might prepare a remedy with a turtle and corn to give to a sufferer with a migraine and recite the surahs that deal with Muhammad’s revelations from Gabriel.

There was also evil in K’intz’ib’. Iblis was associated with One Death as mentioned before, being called Jun Cichin. Other names include Chaytan, Ik’ Cichin, Sak Yibaj, and Ox Jol. He was seen as a triad of demons, each that went through the land to catch souls for the underworld. He was associated with the south, the color yellow, the bowls of the earth, and the earths heat. The dualism of Iblis’s nature in Islam is reflected here, as without the heat of the earth the crops could not grow, nor could life flourish. In K’intz’ib’, it is believed that Iblis is only useful when relegated to the underworld. When he is on the mortal plain is when he must be fought against. Iblis had a host of minor demons, called the Shayateen. In K’intz’ib’, these are called Babacob, a demonization of a former term for creator earth dieties in pre-contact mythology. There was one for each cardinal direction, though in many cases the line between Iblis himself and an associate demon is hard to define. Particularly religious Maya often buried a bundle of quranic quotations under the southern corner of their house to ward off Iblis and his demons and would leave a similar offering under the northern corner to court Alaj’s goodwill.

Followers of Iblis were called Kiharob, sing. Kihar, a portmanteau of the Arabic sihr, “magic” and the Yucatec ah kinob, “priest”. They were believed to hex villagers with charms and practice human sacrifice, dumping bodies into cenotes to worship the Babacob and gain their powers. Suspicion of being a Kiharob was often cause for imprisonment and torture in rural Maya areas. A host of other demons existed, drawn from both Arabic and Maya mythology. Minor demons include Sak Ik Jin, the Resplendent Wind Demon, who blew diseases with his breath, Ajaw Xujim, Lord Bloodletter, who pierced peoples bellies as they slept, or Ox K’an, Three Yellow, who caused miscarriages.​
 
Last edited:
Hmm I'd expect a Padri-style civil war will come to the Maya by the late 17th century at the latest as Mayan Islamic scholars return from Middle East schools and denounce all the syncreticism.
...
Well, that is still far in the future.
 
Hmm with the lack of Portuguese ships east of Africa, we might actually see Mamluk Egypt strong enough (or rich enough) to stave off Ottoman conquest (IIRC the Ottomans chose to invade Syria since Mamluk economy was destroyed by Vasco de Gama and other Portuguese raiding spice fleets that should've gone through Red Sea and Alexandria), and of course no Malaccan catastrophe.

I fully expect a general Java-Malay war to begin again around 1600s after the Malays regrouped back under the High King/Sultan of Malacca here (IOTL, Malacca got conquered by Portuguese in 1511 and Malays got scattered to Johor and assorted Malayan petty kingdoms and Aceh)

Also the longer an expedition from the New World reaches South East Asia, the norther will Islamic border in the Philippines - when Magellan reached Manila IOTL it was in the prelude of Islamicisation after all. Still can't wait for that to happen here tbh :D

With no Vasco de Gama, how long will Cape of Good Hope be empty? Would be quite ironic if Eastern Arabs - that is, Omani or Yemeni or Zanzibari colonised South Africa to go to Europe/America. I don't know if this is plausible though.
 
Hmm with the lack of Portuguese ships east of Africa, we might actually see Mamluk Egypt strong enough (or rich enough) to stave off Ottoman conquest (IIRC the Ottomans chose to invade Syria since Mamluk economy was destroyed by Vasco de Gama and other Portuguese raiding spice fleets that should've gone through Red Sea and Alexandria), and of course no Malaccan catastrophe.

I fully expect a general Java-Malay war to begin again around 1600s after the Malays regrouped back under the High King/Sultan of Malacca here (IOTL, Malacca got conquered by Portuguese in 1511 and Malays got scattered to Johor and assorted Malayan petty kingdoms and Aceh)

Also the longer an expedition from the New World reaches South East Asia, the norther will Islamic border in the Philippines - when Magellan reached Manila IOTL it was in the prelude of Islamicisation after all. Still can't wait for that to happen here tbh :D

With no Vasco de Gama, how long will Cape of Good Hope be empty? Would be quite ironic if Eastern Arabs - that is, Omani or Yemeni or Zanzibari colonised South Africa to go to Europe/America. I don't know if this is plausible though.

The Mamluks are definitely going to be serious power-players in the east, you are right. East Africa and Indonesia will also be spared Portuguese fuckery as well. The Philippines will likely be completely, or near completely islamized in this timeline. [maybe even taiwan...].

The Ayshunids are a exception among all islamic states in their maritime exploits right now. Eastern Arabs are not interested at all in rounding the tip of Africa. Expect Ayshunids to push the african coast farther south but thats about it.
 
15th century Culture and Society in the New World; Part 2
15th century Culture and Society in the New World; Part 1:

Islam among the peoples of Mexico in the 15th century

A Brief History

--------------------------------------------------------

Islam among the natives of Al-Mishik was a social movement of wild, and destructive power. While a much more recent entrant into the native social scene compared to among the Maya, it was far more destructive to the native order than anything seen in the Yucatan. This was for a simple reason. Compared to the engineered, top-down and carefully strategized conversion of the Maya elite, Islam in Mishikah was at best, an unintended, viral sort of conversion that spread among the peasantry first, wreaking havoc on the local aristocracy.

Arabs first appeared in Mishikah along the western coast, Al-Kutash. Establishing trade settlements outside port cities, they moved quickly to appease local lords and arrange trade agreements favorable to exporting raw materials out of Mishikah and towards the Riysh and further to Iberia. The Aztec empire, itself a recent entrant to the region, was easily swayed by the placations of silver-tongued Arab merchants like Al-Kindi, one of the first Arabs to learn nahuatl fluently. Its rigid, imperialistic, and mercantilist governmental structure was much more suited to apolitical trade arrangements than the loose and volatile League of Mayapan. The Aztecs were also fiercely attached to their native religion, and rightfully saw attempts at Islamization as direct assaults on the empires political structure. Those Arabs interested in conversion then, concentrated on local, non-Mexica elites that were themselves under the heel of imperial occupation.

The vast majority of early converts to Islam in Mishikah were Totonacs, recently made unwilling subjects of the empire and facing many of its draconian demands for tribute. Soon after the arrival of the Arabs was also the first series of Aztec purges, instituted by the Tlacochcalcatl (General) Tlacaelel, intent on culturally subjugating conquered peoples. Totonac books were destroyed, as were their priests and indigenous nobility persecuted. Crops of captives were sent to Tenochtitlan for sacrifice, despite the Totonacs total capitulation several years earlier. At the same time, the outbreak of smallpox (another Old World migrant) ravaged Al-Kutash, causing local peoples to vent their rage at the Arabs (who they perceived as foreign allies of the Mexica), with violent riots in several occasions. Despite this, because of general proximity and the social appeal of Islam as a social leveler caused many down beaten Totonac middle-class to flirt with Islam quite soon after the establishment of Arabs in an area. Totonac merchants, interested in gaining better access to the flourishing trade network in the Riysh were willing to convert quickly to endear themselves to Arab traders, and this rippled downwards to townspeople eager to gain favor with a foreign party that appeared powerful and with the respect of the Mexica, but without their totalitarian attitude. The very alliances the Arabs negotiated with Aztec governors resulted in their common enemy converting to Islam with much more fervor than the elite Nahua themselves ever did. The Arabs for their part, were entirely happy to encourage conversion among the Totonacs while still playing innocent to the Mexica authorities, willing to play both ends of the equation to maximize their own returns. This was helped by the fact that the Arabs were more tolerant to Totonac culture than the Mexica were at the time (though the Totonacan reverence to worshipping fire led some to draw negative comparisons to Zoroastrianism, the longtime scapegoat of Islam).

Islam among the Totonacs
--------------------------------------------------------

Totonacan Islam was centered around ritual purification and social cohesion. Indigenous Totonac religion held ritual cleanliness in high regard, used to encourage the fertility of the land and purify the worshipper. Purification could be as distinct as cleansing an infant over a matate to ward off evil spirits to washing corn kernels to aid the growth of the field. Arabs associated this concept with tahara, and proselytized accordingly. The Abrahamic God was linked with the indigenous sun and maize God Chichini, though the Arabs misinterpreted the Totonacan god as a true ‘high’ God, rather than a quasi culture-hero, closer to Quetzalcoatl than Itzamaaj or the various Chaaks of the Maya. This led to a conflation of Muhammad and God both within the figure of Chinini, though Muhammad eventually became seen as Xolotl, the traditional accompaniment of the central creator culture-hero in Mexican mythology. This Xolotl-Muhammad and Chichini-Allah pairing set a precedence for a unique motif that would become pervasive in Mishikah, defining both God (or sometimes Gabriel) and Muhammad as equalized culture-hero / creator Gods.

The origin of Totonacan Islam as a tool of social advancement resulted in it becoming a distinctly socially organized, and anti-Mexica religion. Zakat was especially emphasized, merging with the giving of corn from the community harvests that became common during the famines that struck the empire in the mid-15th century. Communities of Islamized Totonacs would turn the pillars of Zakat and Sawm into powerful social forces, both to spread the harvest of the community around and to encourage modesty in times of hardship. The reverence surrounding corn and the traditional gods of maize, sun, thunder, earth and water continued unabated. The anti-idolatrous attitude of Islam landed with a decisive thud in the north, and the Arabs were unwilling to force further retribution by local peoples by doing what they felt was doctrinally proper. Those few who did, saw themselves cut out of the wildly profitable northern trade routes and ostracized by other Arabs, should local Totonacan middlemen frown on them for it. The place of Arabs both as a third-party dependent on the leniency of the Aztec government and as a middle-partner reliant on native trade partners for goods from the interior severely undercut their ability to control the religious conversation like they could in the Yucatan. The sultans themselves, at least for the majority of the 15th century, were equally unwilling to shatter this delicate trade network purely to enforce doctrinal purity among the natives, happy enough that Islam was appearing in any form at all in the region. Punishing heresy was far more expensive than was tolerating it. Even sacrifice, quickly stamped out among all but the most remote territories of the Yucatan, carried on the north. Islamized Totonacs commonly sacrificed a fowl before breaking ground on a new field, and the industrial-scale human sacrificial rituals of the Mexica carried on unabated for the majority of the 15th century. The willingness of the Arabs to remain entirely separate from attempts to control native strains of the Islam aided its spread, as communities were free to accept as much of the religion as they felt useful and ignore anything incompatible with local beliefs.

This same human sacrifice carried a heavy toll on the Totonacs, who hated the Mexica and used Islam to unify against them. Those captured Totonacs offered up in sacrificial ceremonies throughout the empire were immortalized as martyrs, but this rebelliousness carried a heavy toll later on. It was not lost on Aztec officials that regions with influential figures who fraternized with the Arabs were more likely to resist paying tribute than those deeper inland. Over the course of the 15th century, their patience started to wear thin. Mexica who flirted with Islam could face serious punishment and the loss of their office. Moctezuma I, who had almost allowed Al-Kindi (the only Arab to visit Tenochtitlan for the first 30 years of Arab presence in the north) to send a retinue of Arab scholars to his court, hardened his opinion towards Islam quickly after it became clear that the religion posed a political threat to the empires stability. The spread of the religion among the Totonacs and their subsequent rebelliousness was taken as a violation of the informal arrangement brokered by him and Al-Kindi, agreeing that the Arabs would not interfere in the empires politics. Islam never would enjoy the sort of openness it could enjoy in the Yucatan. Any expansion of the religion past c. 1460 was entirely underground, and concentrated among the subject peoples of the empire, not the Mexica themselves. In this scenario, Islam did not travel from court to court, but from town to town, along trade routes through the endless warren of farming villages the characterized the interior of Mishikah. This also had the side-effect of greatly restricting sufism to coastal territories where Sufis actually were permitted to live, unlike the Yucatan which was entirely sufi after Islamization.

Islam among the Nahua
--------------------------------------------------------

Mishikan Islam, already syncretized with Totonacan beliefs close to Arab settlements, became wildly nativized the further inland it penetrated. Islam became little more than a name, a strategy to find an alternative religious and social system to the repressive Aztec state ideology. Islam even lost its own name, from Yixilam as it was known on the coast to Teoawat / Teuawatl, (plural Teteawah) lit. “the holiness of the Arabs”. It was also called teocihuatlacopotin, that is, lit. “the divine servants”, after the Nahuatl understanding of the meaning of muslim as being “one who submits”. This conception of Islam as the faith of the downtrodden gave it appeal to lower class tribute peoples in the empire but it also sunk the religions reputation among the upper classes. It was a rebellious religion that encouraged social cohesion against the Mexica elite. Eventually this rebelliousness would translate to a vibrant native warrior tradition, rooted both in traditional Mesoamerican warfare and the Islamic ghazi. These Nahua holy warriors, the Teteyaotiacahuan will play a pivotal role in the fall of the Aztec empire in the 16th century.

Native Mishikian Islam can be conceived of along similar lines to native nahua religion. The Ometeotl duality of Ometecuhtli and Omecihuatl was supplemented by the Abrahamic God and Muhammad, called Tonacamotititlanini and Tonacatitlantli respectively. Tonacamotititlanini was a compound of the nahuatl Tonaca, meaning “lord” and Motititlanini, “servant / one who crawls”. This was a nahuatl interpretation of the transcendant nature of the Abrahamic God, the lord of those who crawl [prostrate] before Him, as the Arabs were observed to do. His title is thus read as The Lord of those who Crawl [before him]. Tonacatitlantli was similarly a portmanteau of Lord and titlantili, “messenger”, the concept of Muhammad as the great messenger being very widespread among converted Amerindians. His title was then, The Lord of the Messengers / Messenger Lord. Both were seen as transcendent figures, the one who received worship and then the other who allotted rewards for it.

Other Gods were still recognized, though the warlike central deities of Aztec state religion like Huitzilopochtli fell quickly out of favor. Key to Mishiki Islam was duality. Angels, associated with the Centzonmimixcoa northern star gods, were paired against Demons, associated with the warlike star gods of the southern skies, the Centzonhuitznahua. Paradise, Miyaoaxocan, “the place of flowers / the place of youthful women” was the topmost of the 13 layers of reality (7 layers of heaven, 6 of hell to conform with both nahua, and Islamic teachings on the afterlife). Hell was directly linked to the nahua Mictlan, the Islamic Iblis associated with Mictlantecuhtli, though this was a significant departure from the true conception of hell in the Quran. Worship was carried out in the traditional ways, with outdoor ceremonies in front of a teocalli (temple), which was entirely indistinguishable from a pagan temple from the outside. Worshippers prayed five times a day, outdoors on woven mats. A post was commonly erected at the end of the temple courtyard that marked the qibla (direction towards Mecca) and wrapped with cloth bundles. This post became known as the Teoestaca, the “sacred post”, and a centerpiece for the conducting of Islamic prayer. The small size of traditional temples meant that all the traditional functions of the mosque were moved outside, with the pyramid of the teocalli reserved for the iman (teopixqui, the same word as for a pagan priest) to oversee prayer.

Sacrifice was rare in official ceremonies, being replaced with ‘faux’ sacrifices to satisfy traditional beliefs as well as the Islamic restrictions against the consumption of creatures killed at altars (Al Ma’idah 5:3), usually made of clay or paper. Animal sacrifices still occurred in the most rural areas in a folk-medicine context. Another circumvention of Islamic restrictions was in alcohol. Pulque was a vital part of traditional life, and yet was forbidden by Islam (being an alcoholic drink). It continued to be drunk, but with impish cleverness after the period of pulque-drinking was over the imbiber would reverse his cup and sprinkle water on the clay base of it, thereby ‘inverting’ the pulque and reversing the ritual act of drinking the liquid. With no Arabs or literate Imans around to monitor such practices, there was no stopping such rampant syncretism.

The five pillars were seen as aspects of ritually correct behavior that ensured spiritual and bodily health, and much like among the Totonacs the social aspect of Islam was its most desired feature. Unique to Islamized Mishiki was the concept of cacahuatech¸lit. “besides the cacao”. This was a borrowing from the Totonacs, a union of Sawm and Zakat, a form of universal welfare within the village where each member both lived modestly and shared what they saved through modesty with others. It came from choosing between chocolate, a valuable commodity in Mesoamerica, and a simpler corn tortilla or squash, to choose the food, “besides the cacao”. It is noticeable that the Arabic language did not supersede nahuatl as a method for understanding Islamic concepts. Most Islamized Mishiki did not know a single word of Arabic perhaps beyond a broken rendering of the shahada, if at that-nor would they have ever seen a Quran. Those Arabic terms that did travel along the trade routes were adopted to suit Nahuatl phonology rather than the other way around. Most of the proselytizing done in Mishikah was done by local believers, converted natives (usually Totonacs) who had been educated by Arabs and travelled within the empire, literate in their faith but facing far less scrutiny from Aztec authorities. They explained Islam in nahuatl, relying on the charity of local leaders. These traveling priests doubled as merchants, often the same middlemen Arabs relied on to facilitate trade from the interior. They were called by the Arabs Boshtekin, from the nahuatl Pochtecah. The strict anti-Muslim attitudes of the Aztec elite after the mid 15th century meant that these merchants were the only avenue for Islamic teachings to enter a region, since Arabs were closely monitored on any trips inland, and prevented from speaking of their religion. Despite these efforts, Islam spread rapidly through the Aztec empire, becoming a militant ideology as the 15th turned to the 16th century, though in a form almost entirely incomprehensible to the Arabs themselves.​
 
Last edited:
If I could FB love this update, I would. Should or when the Aztec Empire finally collapse, there presents an opportunity for these Islamized Pochteca to fill in the power vacuum and become not only religious and commercial leaders but political leaders in their own right.
 
If I could FB love this update, I would. Should or when the Aztec Empire finally collapse, there presents an opportunity for these Islamized Pochteca to fill in the power vacuum and become not only religious and commercial leaders but political leaders in their own right.

When the Mexica collapse its going to be a bloodbath, thats all I can say...the sort of ghazi uprisings that troubled the Riysh are nothing compared to the sort of religious warfare that is going to occur in the 16th century in Mexico.
 
Ouch.
That...
Never mind the Mayapan, Ghazis through the Dar al-Islam in the 16th century (or at least Sufi orders) going to rip their way around Mexico until the latter repents to the correct orthodoxy.
I guess we won't see a surviving Aztec state after all :frown:

How are the Tarascans? They are in the Western/Pacific coast of South Mexico IIRC, so what do they (or other deeper tribals) felt about the new sailors from the East?

The Philippines will likely be completely, or near completely islamized in this timeline. [maybe even taiwan...].
:kisskiss: a Hui/Malay (pan-Austronesians) Taiwan that serves as trading/colonization base for West Pacific would be cool.
I forgot one other impact, no Portuguese mean no Japanese teppo (matchlock) which... is going to change everything about the Sengoku.
Malay traders-missionaries (From Bugis or Luzon?) coming up to Kyushu and selling Turkish/Javanese cannons would be quite cool no? :p

Edit: oh yeah, after this generation I think the wandering sufis/missionaries will be mostly local Native Americans compared to Arabs.
In SEA, Minangkabau was only completely Islamicised in the late 15th century or early-to-mid 16th century (no one knows exactly when) BUT three Minangkabauan men converted a million (and seven kingdoms) of Buginese in 1605, and of course Manila was Islamicised around the 1550s by Brunei traders who were described in 1514 by the Portuguese as "the King is pagan while the traders are Moor"

I think that will make Aztec forbidding Arabs to the interior more, ah, hard to do?

Edit2: ouch, I've just realised what Mexico situation remind me of.
They're mid-Majapahit.
We'll see who are the Demak ini this situation.
 
Last edited:
Ouch.
That...
Never mind the Mayapan, Ghazis through the Dar al-Islam in the 16th century (or at least Sufi orders) going to rip their way around Mexico until the latter repents to the correct orthodoxy.
I guess we won't see a surviving Aztec state after all :frown:

How are the Tarascans? They are in the Western/Pacific coast of South Mexico IIRC, so what do they (or other deeper tribals) felt about the new sailors from the East?


:kisskiss: a Hui/Malay (pan-Austronesians) Taiwan that serves as trading/colonization base for West Pacific would be cool.
I forgot one other impact, no Portuguese mean no Japanese teppo (matchlock) which... is going to change everything about the Sengoku.
Malay traders-missionaries (From Bugis or Luzon?) coming up to Kyushu and selling Turkish/Javanese cannons would be quite cool no? :p

Edit: oh yeah, after this generation I think the wandering sufis/missionaries will be mostly local Native Americans compared to Arabs.
In SEA, Minangkabau was only completely Islamicised in the late 15th century or early-to-mid 16th century (no one knows exactly when) BUT three Minangkabauan men converted a million (and seven kingdoms) of Buginese in 1605, and of course Manila was Islamicised around the 1550s by Brunei traders who were described in 1514 by the Portuguese as "the King is pagan while the traders are Moor"

I think that will make Aztec forbidding Arabs to the interior more, ah, hard to do?

Edit2: ouch, I've just realised what Mexico situation remind me of.
They're mid-Majapahit.
We'll see who are the Demak ini this situation.

You...you just get it, you get it.

The Tarascans are busy fighting off the Aztecs. They are too far north to be in the area of immediate cultural contact, though I suppose some trade goods are making it indirectly to Al-Kutash from Tzintzuntzan. The thing is, many of the peoples in Mexico are used to foreign groups moving in and carving out their own pocket territories in the area (the Aztecs were one such group not too long ago), so the Arabs are not some sort of earth-shattering cataclysm like the Spanish were. However, rumors about stuff like horses, the chichime ixhueyac (long-faced dog), and metal weaponry are circulating. Arabs are not going to look as foreign to most nahua peoples as white iberians are (though Al-andalus by this point is so racially diverse that you could get anyone from very pale to sudanese).

I dread doing what will become a necessary update on SE Asia as much as I dread one on europe, because of my aforementioned lack of expertise in the area, but Taiwan will not Islamism too rapidly I think-the Hui are more of a interior Chinese ethnicity, expect something more like a Islamic Peranakan Chinese group. Also except there to be a lot of zeal in Europe about missionary work to counteract spreading Islamic influence, starting ofc in Iberia. Some events in OTL in East Asia will be mirrored ATL, thats all I am going to say.

Lastly, the Aztecs went from being wary, but friendly to the Arabs to being paranoid about them in as much time as it took for a Aztec administrator to meet a Islamized native. In their eyes, it is a blatant violation of the sort of goodwill agreement the Arabs have with them to trade freely within the empire. As you saw in my latest update, despite increasingly draconian restrictions on Arabs it is not arabs who are doing the converting, its largely middle-class, Totonac and nahua merchants. Moctezuma I died in the midst of trying to curb this, the next few emperors are going to have to deal with it...the aztecs are not exactly the sort of empire that is going to easily tolerate a spreading, dissident religion that directly threatens the source of their states political and religious legitimacy (human sacrifice just being one part of that). They are going to try and crush Islam like its a bug.

@WilliamOfOckham Thanks for that. I've been actually wondering what people thought of my writing style so its good to hear its actually readable enough.
 
Last edited:
The care to style definitely shows, but I think alternate Americas are very interesting in and of themselves. It's an astonishing historical fluke in OTL that a whole hemisphere ended up in the modern world with practically no indigenous political representation - a fluke which users on this forum all too often take for granted. So I'm excited to see anything that gives the Americas a fighting chance, and (some of) them being Muslim is all the better.

Any plans for the less densely-populated North(ern) and South America? I think that immunisation's ~200-year head start on settler colonialism might have some exciting effects on the Mississippi or East Coast. Large areas devastated (>75% depopulated) by disease, war etc. but without external challengers are fertile ground for centralised states, as old "tribal" or village identities collapse. Just think - a North American Charlemagne!
 
Last edited:
Any plans for the less densely-population North(ern) and South America? I think that immunisation's ~200-year head start on settler colonialism might have some exciting effects on the Mississippi or East Coast. Large areas devastated (>75% depopulated) by disease, war etc. but without external challengers are fertile ground for centralised states, as old "tribal" or village identities collapse. Just think - a North American Charlemagne!
As someone considering a scenario where Old World diseases reach the Americas long before the Old Worlders can capitalise on the disruption I hadn't thought of it that way.
 
The care to style definitely shows, but I think alternate Americas are very interesting in and of themselves. It's an astonishing historical fluke in OTL that a whole hemisphere ended up in the modern world with practically no indigenous political representation - a fluke which users on this forum all too often take for granted. So I'm excited to see anything that gives the Americas a fighting chance, and (some of) them being Muslim is all the better.

Any plans for the less densely-population North(ern) and South America? I think that immunisation's ~200-year head start on settler colonialism might have some exciting effects on the Mississippi or East Coast. Large areas devastated (>75% depopulated) by disease, war etc. but without external challengers are fertile ground for centralised states, as old "tribal" or village identities collapse. Just think - a North American Charlemagne!

As someone considering a scenario where Old World diseases reach the Americas long before the Old Worlders can capitalise on the disruption I hadn't thought of it that way.

That is exactly a point I have been hoping people would catch on. The timescale between the arrival of Old World disease and any actual external Old World threat is much, much wider here, and the eventual Old World threat is oftentimes much less than anything in OTL (well, except for slave raiders, lots of those running around), so societies have more time to recover. Now, the death toll is still going to be gargantuan, its just biology. The Mississippians are going to completely collapse as a society, as are peoples in the Amazon basin, Peru, East Coast US, literally everywhere - but the other pressures are going to be lesser, there will be more time for these areas to demographically recover, and there is going to be more egalitarianism overall, so expect more resilient post-contact native societies overall. Though, don't expect the Arabs to be the nicest of people either, its just cheaper right now to tolerate the natives than to exterminate them. If that equation changes, morality is going to fly out the window very quickly.

@inawarminister

If you are drawing similarities to Majapahit, good eye, but I would caution that the societal and governmental structure of Mexico is very unique. In Mesoamerica, there is not as much of a tradition of being the 'successor' of a previous great state geographically, when a new empire started in Mesoamerica it was founded by a different ethnicity in a different geographic location. The old sites and old capital become sacred places of pilgrimage, but outside of a sort of mystical reverence for the legacy of the empire the new state would move forward on its own terms. So, when inevitably Islamized altepeme arise in the nahua territories in the center of Mexica territory, do not expect them to paint themselves as heirs of the Aztecs, like Demak did with Majapahit - they will be their own entities entirely and not even pay lip service to the Triple Alliance (everyone hated them anyways).
 
Last edited:
What were some of the important settlements of Moorish America? I'm just curious. Great timeline, by the way; I am already subscribed to it. :)

All the largest Arabized cities are on Boriken [Puerto Rico], since it was the first large island discovered and because it was effectively depopulated by disease, necessitating mass Arab colonization to repopulate the island. Buhuq, Bohiyya are the largest of these, with Medinet Damea on Damea [Montserrat] a quasi-capital of the Riysh. They are sprawling frontier cities with few stone buildings but with many adobe houses and tent slums around them. Buhuq and Bohiyya have somewhat built-up city centers with the beginnings of stone, urban districts like in Iberia and both have large fortresses strategically located in them. The vast majority of trade bound for Iberia passes between Boriken and Damea before sailing for the Canaries.

There are smaller cities on Mulukah [Hispaniola] and the eastern shore of Sayadin [Cuba], but they are really large trade settlements, with permanent houses only for the entourages of merchants and those who work at the docks and the farms immediately in the vicinity. Most of the Arab population of the Riysh is transitory, moving from small trading posts to other small trading posts, or working in villages centered in agricultural areas (these would mostly be Canarian and Azorian Arabs brought to work depopulated lands, the former are primarily middle-class Andalusis). Much of the interior of Sayadin and western Mulukah are Islamized Taino towns, few Arabs live there except in a governmental or mercantile function.

There are also native settlements that are beginning to turn into proper Old World cities, the foremost of these is Mayabat [Mayapan], which is the capital of the Wilayat al-Maya and already before conquest the largest city in the Yucatan. It is a oddly planned city, with a traditional Mesoamerican, Maya ritual center that has been engulfed by a sprawling warren of Arab style houses and souqs, with a large mosque and palace erected atop the pre-contact central plaza. There are then Maya villages and small Arab towns radiating outwards. A similar sort of urban plan is beginning to develop in most large cities in the Yucatan, like Zama [Tulum] for instance. The Yucatan is different from the Riysh in that most Arabs are urbanized, since the Maya still absolutely demographically and geographically dominate the countryside.

There are no large Arab settlements north of the Yucatan, only trading posts on the outskirts of native cities.
 
I continue to be interested in the extent to which we took a similar idea in different directions and explored completely different takes on it.
 
Top