A different plan for 'Urgent Fury'

The invasion of Grenada in 1983 was the first large scale military maneuver since Vietnam for the US armed forces. Although completely successful in it's goals, the operation has been widely criticized in the way it was planned and carried out. Basically, there are two areas that are criticized:

1. The forces involved were a hodgepodge of essentially seven battalions of US special forces; Marines, Airborne, SEALS, Rangers, etc. Coordination between them was not always good. It's been alleged that the selection of forces was done to give all the services a shot at this first major conflict. An alternate plan proposed was to use mostly Marine units for the invasion.

2. The intelligence gathered before the invasion was nowhere near good enough. There was a real lack of 'boots on the ground' human intelligence, in spite of the fact that Grenada was in such chaos that it would have been absurdly easy to get it. The US didn't know how many Cuban soldiers were on the island (not that many, it turned out), where all the US medical students were living, and how many Grenadans were actually armed and in the field. The US was very lucky in that the Grenadans never took the students as hostages, since they didn't get around to rescuing them quickly.

So, leaving out the political aspects and concentrating on the military aspects only, WI the US had spent more time getting human intelligence and figured out the size and location of Cuban forces, roughly where the students were, and a better idea of Grenadan forces, and then made Urgent Fury a sole Marine/SEAL/Navy operation?
 
Top