Thursday, February 28th 2019
Features: What you'll need to know for the papal conclave
Vatican City — With Pope Victor IV's long papacy over, the first papal conclave since 1995 is expected to begin within the next few days. With the former pontiff only a few miles away, 120 members of the College of Cardinals will meet to elect his successor within a few days. Owing to the pope emeritus' (as he is now called) long reign, there is only one cardinal (Archbishop Mirza Nurkić of Bosnia and Herzegovina) who will participate in this conclave who also took part in the conclave that elected Victor.
The Roman Catholic Church's millennia-long history has led to a truly unique and intricate system for selecting their leader, and with the last conclave held a quarter-century ago, most people are not aware of the exact process by which a new pope is elected.
Who elects the Pope?
The pope is elected by members of the College of Cardinals, the formal name for the body of all current and former cardinals, the top rank in the Roman Catholic church hierarchy underneath the pope himself.
By papal law, only cardinals under 80 years of age at the time of the papacy becoming vacant (meaning they cannot be born before February 28, 1939) are eligible to participate in conclaves, although ineligible cardinals are allowed to attend as observers (the travel distances involved for most cardinals and the advanced age of ineligible cardinals makes this a formality for all but a few cardinals who reside in or close to Rome). The conclave is further limited to only 120 eligible cardinals (or cardinal-electors, as they are called) participating. Currently there are 122 eligible cardinal electors, but three (Seán O'Flannigan of Ireland, Joseph-Luc Bezungu of Zaire and Vincent Kandulna of India) have declined to participate owing to ill health.
Who is eligible?
As the pope is technically the Bishop of Rome, the qualifications for the pope are the same as for a bishop: a person must be a baptized adult man who belongs to the Roman Catholic Church.
Effectively, though, it is only the members of the College of Cardinals themselves who have a chance at being elected. The last time someone from outside the College of Cardinals was elected was 1378 (when Pope Urban VI was elected).
Election Procedures
Traditionally, the papacy becomes vacant only with the death of the incumbent. It was only with Celestine VI's resignation after suffering grievous injuries in a 1981 assassination attempt that the ability of modern popes to resign was confirmed. As with Victor IV's resignation, Celestine's resignation was submitted to the College of Cardinals and the Cardinal Camerlengo (the official who oversees the property and revenue of the Holy See and who traditionally ran the pope's household) accepts the resignation and symbolically destroys or defaces any symbols of the previous pope's authority. He then declares the papacy vacant, starting a period of
sede vacante (Latin for "empty seat").
This period, in the case of the death of the previous pope, typically lasts 15 days as the late pope is mourned and buried. In the case of a papal resignation such as with the current
sede vacante, the College of Cardinals can choose to limit the period to as few as three days before convening to elect the new pope.
The conclave is presided over traditionally by the Dean of the College of Cardinals, the most senior member of the college. But if either he or the Vice-Dean (the second-most senior member) are ineligible to participate, the duty falls to the highest eligible cardinal-bishop to preside. For this conclave, Cardinal Secretary of State Francisco Petrucci will preside as the most senior cardinal-bishop eligible to participate. Before the conclave begins, every participating cardinal attends Mass at the Sistine Chapel and takes a public vow promising not to divulge the events of the conclave, with a punishment of excommunication for violators. Then, the official presiding over the conclave orders everyone except the participants expelled from the chapel and seals the members inside until the conclave is over.
To be elected, one candidate needs a two-thirds majority of all participants. On the first day of the conclave, one ballot may take place. If, in the very likely event, that no candidate receives the necessary amount of votes, balloting continues the next day. A maximum of four ballots may take place on each of the next two days. If no candidate is elected at the end of the third day of voting, the voting is suspended for one day of prayer and contemplation before resuming on the fifth day of the conclave. If there is no winner after a further seven further ballots, the conclave is again suspended for a day of prayer and contemplation, a cycle that repeats if a further seven ballots fail to elect a winner. If no candidate has been elected after this second round of seven ballots with no winner, only the candidates with the two highest vote totals in the previous round of voting can be chosen from until one of the two receives the necessary two-thirds of the vote to become the next pope.
The vote totals are not publicized and after every round of voting, the ballots are destroyed to prevent information from leaking to the outside. The burning of the ballot papers with chemical additives to change the color of the smoke from the chapel's chimney also signals to the outside world the results of that ballot: black smoke indicates that no pope was elected, and white smoke indicates that a pope has been elected.
Once a pope has been elected, he chooses a papal name to be known by during his reign. Then he dresses in papal robes and is introduced to the world from the chapel's balcony with the declaration of "
habemus papam" (Latin for "we have a pope").
What's new
There have been several changes to the conclave process since the last one in 1995:
Following rapprochement with the Maronite Church and the Syro-Malanka Church in 2007 and 2012, respectively, their leaders have been made
ex officio cardinals and are thus eligible to participate. Marionite Grand Patriarch Nasrallah Boutros al-Ghali and Syro-Malanka Major-Archbishop Isaac Baselios will thus be the first members of their specific churches to participate alongside members of the mainline Roman Catholic Church in a papal conclave.
With the increasing prevalence and ease of concealment of electronic devices such as recorders, cell phones and video cameras, the Vatican will sweep the chapel twice for electronic devices, and similarly search every participating cardinal and conclave staff before they are allowed inside. Vatican City already does not have Wi-Fi access, but wireless signal jammers will be deployed to prevent any electronic communication from reaching in or out of the chapel during the conclave.
The Vatican, however, is not completely in the technological dark ages: an official live-stream of the chapel chimney will reportedly go online after the cardinals are sealed inside and the official papal Twitter account will resume activity by declaring "
habemus papem" once a new pope is elected.
Top candidates
Out of the 119 participants at the papal conclave, it is widely predicted that only nine men have a real chance at becoming the new pope. Called
papabile (Italian for "pope-able"), it is almost certain that the new pope will be one of these nine men. Ranked in order of aggregate odds as they current stand on the Irish bookmaking website PaddyPower.com:
Francisco Petrucci
Nationality: Italian
Position: Cardinal Secretary of State
Age: 65
Outlook: Moderate
Odds: 5:1
Notes: Groomed as a potential successor by Victor IV, but has made enemies in Vatican political battles. Will be presiding over the conclave as the senior eligible cardinal-bishop.
Joseph Wambui
Nationality: Kenyan.
Position: Prefect for the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples, formerly Archbishop of Nairobi
Age: 70
Outlook: Moderate
Odds: 7:1
Notes: Considered by many to be Victor IV's spiritual and intellectual heir apparent, Wambui would be the perfect candidate to further the pope emeritus' legacy.
Martino Fabbri
Nationality: Italian
Position: Archbishop of Florence
Age: 73
Outlook: Conservative
Odds: 12:1
Notes: For those who find Petrucci too moderate, Archbishop Fabbri is perhaps the only Italian who can reclaim the See of St. Peter for the first time since 1978.
Sebastian Gómez
Nationality: Chilean
Position: Archbishop of Santiago de Chile
Age: 68
Outlook: Conservative
Odds: 14/1
Notes: Combing a conservative theology, with a strong record of service to the marginalized, Gómez is a leading contender to be the first South American pope.
Vincent Bouchard
Nationality: Canadian
Position: Archbishop of Toronto
Age: 67
Outlook: Moderate
Odds: 20/1
Notes: One of the first cardinals to embrace social media and a regular face on television, Bouchard has developed a reputation for being able to present Catholic theology in an engaging way. The Archbishop of Toronto could well be the perfect pope for the Internet age.
Eduardo Ramos
Nationality: Portuguese
Position: Patriarch of Lisbon
Age: 70
Outlook: Conservative
Odds: 20/1
Notes: A renowned theologian and church historian, Ramos is considered the co-leader (alongside Cardinal Visser) of the church's conservative wing.
Ambroos Visser
Nationality: Dutch
Position: Prefect for the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith, formerly Archbishop of Utrecht
Age: 70
Outlook: Conservative
Odds: 25/1
Notes: One of Pope Victor's more outspoken critics, it is believed he was appointed prefect in order to shore up Victor's conservative credentials. He would be the second Dutch pope in thirty years if elected.
Carlos Ortega
Nationality: Spanish
Position: Archbishop of Barcelona
Age: 71
Outlook: Moderate
Odds: 33/1
Notes: One of the Victor IV's closest allies, and his main trouble-shooter, Ortega had repeatedly been offered positions within the Curia, but reportedly prefers to steer clear of Vatican politics.
Naveen Kapoor
Nationality: Indian
Position: Archbishop of Bombay
Age: 62
Outlook: Liberal
Odds: 75/1
Notes: The youngest papabili (the singular form of papabile) and one of the newest cardinals, Kapoor is a liberation theologian who has been the leading spokesman for the church's liberal wing, pushing ideas such as women's ordination. Normally, he would not be seriously considered but for the fact that his intellect and sense of humor have made him popular with his colleagues.