NBS Election HQ: Gubernatorial race ratings
Sunday, May 29th, 2022
With the presidential primary process almost at an end, most states have begun their primaries for down-ballot races. With several races' nominees having been decided by those same primaries, NBS' political team is ready to release our initial race ratings for all the gubernatorial races that will be up in 2022.
One caveat that should be kept in mind is that several incumbents who are eligible to run for re-election have been rumored to be on the short-list for the vice presidential nomination of either the Democratic or Republican tickets. State laws differ about whether that incumbent would be allowed to run for re-election simultaneously, and if not, it could substantially impact the rating of the race.
Alabama
Incumbent:
Edward West (R)
Rating:
Safe R
Notes: West has little to worry about in deep-red Alabama even if the Republican presidential ticket continues to struggle in the polls.
Arizona
Incumbent:
Scott Phillips (R) - term-limited
Rating: Toss-Up
Notes: The open race in Arizona looks likely to be a tough race for both parties, similar to the Senate race incumbent governor Scott Phillips (prevented from seeking a third term by term limits) is running in. While both parties have multiple candidates who could win their nominations for the August primary, Democrats seem to have already settled on secretary of state Kate Fernandez, while the GOP race looks to be down to congressman Troy Foster and activist Jan Kaznowski, whose outlandish claims and ties to fringe far-right groups have alarmed Republican leaders in Phoenix.
California
Incumbent:
Abbie Heilemann (D) - term-limited
Rating:
Safe D
Notes: While former Secretary of Labor Gael Cordova still has to win the Democratic primary in June, his overwhelming fundraising advantage and endorsements from Democratic power-players from the White House to local officials in California mean he's all but assured to have won the Democratic nomination. Which, in a blue state like California, means he will become the next governor in November, the first Latino to do so in almost 150 years.
Colorado
Incumbent:
Lance McKey (D)
Rating:
Lean D
Notes: While the Republicans have yet to pick between the two state senators (Gus Lopez and Tom Ronchetti) looking to take on McKey, they'll likely find it to be a tough road. Colorado has moved into a state that leans Democratic on the presidential level, and McKey has succeeded in keeping all parts of the Democratic coalition in the Centennial State happy.
Connecticut
Incumbent:
Cal Beaushaw (D)
Rating:
Safe D
Notes: With no gubernatorial term limits, Beaushaw is running for a third term. At 71, he's made it clear that this will be his final political campaign, and with the empty Connecticut Republican bench, likely the easiest gubernatorial campaign he will face.
Georgia
Incumbent:
Jeremy Johnson (R)
Rating:
Lean R
Notes: For the first time in years, the winner of the Georgia Republican primary doesn't have an easy ride to the governor's mansion. Johnson won last Tuesday's GOP primary unopposed, but the Democrats put up activist and state senator Kelsey Gardner. Gardner is the charismatic face of the push by younger and African-American activists to expand voting rights and access in Georgia and would be both Georgia's first female and first African-American governor should she win. The result will ultimately hinge on both the presidential race and how well state Democrats' turnout efforts perform.
Hawaii
Incumbent:
Shane Burns (D)
Rating:
Safe D
Notes: Hawaii is one of the safest Democratic states in the nation (nearly 70% of voters there voted for President Seaborn four years ago), and with the weakness of Republicans in the Aloha State, Burns' reelection is assured.
Indiana
Incumbent:
Matthew Stillman (R)
Rating:
Safe R
Notes: While Stillman has been floated as a possible running mate for Alan Duke, state law would require him to abandon what polls say would be an easy re-election campaign to join a GOP ticket down by double-digits at the start of June. Unless he decides to take that risk and forces the state GOP to find a last-minute replacement to run for governor, we're projecting this race will be an easy Republican victory over state representative Jonathan Dawes, the only Democrat remaining ahead of next week's primary.
Iowa
Incumbent:
James Edwards (D)
Rating: Toss-Up
Notes: Edwards is one of the top targets for Republicans this year, having won in 2018 thanks to incumbent Carl York's attempt to secure a third term by stoking culture war issues (attempting to ban same-sex marriage and promoting a group that practiced conversion therapy on LGBT youth). He's clashed repeatedly with the GOP legislature, but still has solid approval ratings in the Republican-leaning state. Congressman Kevin Nix is the clear front runner in next week's Republican primary, and has already shifted to general election footing.
Louisiana
Incumbent:
Kevin Haynes (R)
Rating:
Safe R
Notes: Democrats in the Pelican State were encouraged by Rick Remick hanging on to his Senate seat in 2020, but seem to have accepted that Colfax mayor Simon Law (the party's gubernatorial nominee) will not come close to unseating Haynes this year.
Massachusetts
Incumbent:
Sam Rust (D)
Rating:
Safe D
Notes: While it won't be official until the state's gubernatorial primary in early September, incumbent governor Sam Rust will win the Democratic nomination for a third time in a row. His likely opponent, state senator Lewis Taylor, has been attempting to distance himself from Alan Duke and has dropped hints that he may support independent presidential candidate Andrew Long instead.
Michigan
Incumbent:
Ben Laurion (R) - term-limited
Rating:
Lean D
Notes: Ben Laurion's stunning fall from GOP frontrunner for the presidency to electoral albatross has had massive down-ballot effects in Michigan. Laurion's successor as state attorney general, Dianne Maguire, is almost sure to be the Democratic nominee after the August primary and has already been playing up her own role in the investigation into state regulatory agencies' actions under Laurion. Businessman Ted Podres leads the pack of Republican candidates that is notable for its lack of heavy hitters.
Montana
Incumbent:
Monty Fisher (R)
Rating: Toss-Up
Notes: Montana gaining a second seat in the House of Representatives and the subsequent redistricting put at-large congressman Alan Price (D) out of a job. So now he wants Fisher's. Between Montana's unique political dynamics, Fisher already distancing himself from Alan Duke, and Price's high name-recognition, this is going to be an interesting race to watch.
Nevada
Incumbent:
Dalton Creel (D)
Rating: Toss-Up
Notes: Like the state's simultaneous Senate election, the gubernatorial race here is shaping up to be a tough contest even if the state is almost certainly going to vote for Sam Seaborn again. Creel is all but assured of the Democratic nomination, and former congressman Joey Cano has pulled ahead in polls for the GOP nomination thanks to a significant fundraising advantage. Should Cano win the nomination, this would set-up a rematch of the 2018 contest, which Creel won by fewer than 2,500 votes.
New Hampshire
Incumbent:
Elizabeth Bartlet (D)
Rating:
Lean D
Notes: The eldest daughter of former president Josiah Bartlet is reportedly under consideration to be Sam Seaborn's running mate. The question about whether Seaborn, who attempted to nominate Barlet's mother, former First Lady Abby Bartlet, to be Secretary of Health and Human Services, should do such a thing is a matter best left to the comments section. But if Bartlet is nominated, she could also continue running for a third term as governor. Businessman Walt Lacroix is heads and shoulders above other announced GOP candidates in terms of fundraising and endorsements, but will face an uphill struggle if Bartlet remains focused entirely on her re-election bid.
New Mexico
Incumbent:
Will Diego (D)
Rating:
Lean D
Notes: Diego is another contender for the Democratic vice presidential nomination, and unlike fellow governor Elizabeth Bartlet (NH, see above), he would have to end his bid for re-election if he is chosen to join the ticket. With Diego unopposed for next week's Democratic primary, the prediction with him in the race is that he would likely prevail over his most likely opponent, state representative Rick Tinnin (R). If he is chosen as Seaborn's running mate, this race's rating will almost certainly change to a toss-up.
New York
Incumbent:
Hakeem El-Amin (D)
Rating:
Safe D
Notes: El-Amin's selection as part of Sam Seaborn's vice presidential search committee highlights the high regard the national party sees in New York's current chief executive. His likely opponent, congressman Del Roberts (R), should just hope that he can drive up the GOP turnout in enough upstate and Long Island areas to keep the party competitive in the state legislature.
North Carolina
Incumbent:
David McNamara (R) - term-limited
Rating:
Lean R
Notes: Lieutenant Governor Gabriel Huxley is the odds-on favorite to succeed McNamara, who rebounded from a Senate career dogged by extramarital affairs and substance abuse to be one of the nation's most popular governors. However, as of now, with the presumptive Republican presidential nominee trailing President Seaborn by over a dozen percentage points, there remains a chance that state senator Erica Johnson (the Democratic nominee) could make it to the governor's mansion.
Ohio
Incumbent:
Art Scheider (R)
Rating: Toss-Up
Notes: Ohio's race is one of the trickiest to predict at this juncture. Scheider is unpopular and trails the Democratic nominee, congresswoman and former governor Josie Bail, in every head-to-head poll since Bail won the Democratic primary earlier this month. However, the Ohio Green Party is caught in a fracas over the call by former senator Haydn Straus, former senator and the party's presidential nominee four years ago, to withdraw their nominee, attorney Sarah Clark-Green, and endorse Bail. Clark-Green, who had run as a paper candidate for Straus under the assumption that he would join the race, has joined in calling for a special meeting of the party's executive to decide the matter. Additionally, Scheider has been under consideration to join the GOP ticket, and if selected, would have to be replaced with a new gubernatorial nominee. With both the uncertainty over whether a Green candidate will remain on the ballot, and if Scheider will indeed remain the Republican nominee, we cannot predict the outcome of this race with any degree of certainty.
South Dakota
Incumbent:
Richard Dean (R)
Rating:
Safe R
Notes: Dean won almost 70% of the vote four years ago, and it seems likely he will achieve a similarly high vote total this year.
Tennessee
Incumbent:
Terrance Klein (D)
Rating: Toss-Up
Notes: Despite Tennessee being solidly Republican, Klein has strong approval ratings for a Democratic governor in the South. Congressman Walter Peterson is leading in polls for the Republican primary in August. Whoever the Republicans nominate will have a good shot at unseating Klein, but only if they can avoid antagonizing either part of the split in the Republican camp that has resulted from Alan Duke's victory in the presidential primaries.
Wisconsin
Incumbent:
Mark Croft (R)
Rating: Toss-Up
Notes: Wisconsin is going to have two tough re-election campaigns for statewide Republicans this year, with both Croft and senator James Clarke seeking re-election. Croft's likely opponent, Dane County executive and former teacher Chris Bock, has decided to make the cuts to education funding passed under Croft and the Republican-led state legislature a central issue of the campaign. Clarke, meanwhile, is touting his economic record as a pitch for re-election, even as Wisconsin's state rankings in economic metrics have changed very little since Croft became governor.