2015 Turtledove Poll New World War II

[Glen]

(READ BEFORE VOTING!)
Remember that this is an Approval Voting poll, which means you may vote for multiple choices.

2015 Turtledove Poll Directory for all your voting needs!

A Valkyrie Rises over Europe Kaiser K
Shattered Citadel: A Worse German Defeat at Kursk lucaswillen05
April 1942 Alternate Indian Ocean Zheng He
Weber's Germany: The Veterinarian Totalitarian Tom Colton
Kolyma's Shadow: An Alternate Space Race nixonshead
The Boys in Blue Maeglin
How We Define Paradise or Desolation - An Alternate History of the Cold War MarshalBraginski & EVC

 

[Napoleon IV]

Just a quibble: since Marshal Braginsky is banned and EVC has taken over shouldn't it be Marshal Braginsky and EVC?

 

[Darth_Kiryan]

Webers Germany.

 

[Stolengood]

Just a quibble: since Marshal Braginsky is banned and EVC has taken over shouldn't it be Marshal Braginsky and EVC?

Also, why is voting for a banned guy's TL even an option? Especially since he's providing new updates "from beyond the grave", which surely must not be allowed? Especially considering the way he went out?

 

[Glen]

Just a quibble: since Marshal Braginsky is banned and EVC has taken over shouldn't it be Marshal Braginsky and EVC?

Coauthor added

 

[Glen]

Also, why is voting for a banned guy's TL even an option? Especially since he's providing new updates "from beyond the grave", which surely must not be allowed? Especially considering the way he went out?

We judge the work, not the member - and there is precedent to leaving & even adding to works of banned members.

 

[hasdrubal barca]

Im still amazed that i managed to snag the first comment on Weber's Germany.

 

[Kaiser K]

I am honored that I was considered for nomination in the first place, and even if I lose out; I am humbled that I was nominated in the first place.

 

[Maeglin]

I am honored that I was considered for nomination in the first place, and even if I lose out; I am humbled that I was nominated in the first place.

Same here.

 

[Zheng He]

I am honored that I was considered for nomination in the first place, and even if I lose out; I am humbled that I was nominated in the first place.

Concur, I cannot I believe I have been nominated. This is great and good luck to the other nominees.

 

[Driftless]

Concur, I cannot I believe I have been nominated. This is great and good luck to the other nominees.

April 1942 is a great thread. Very plausible, and well told

 

[Zheng He]

Congrats Tom...

 

[johnboy]

Indeed. Some bloody good timelines in there