150th anniversary of the Battle of Gettysburg

Dialga

Banned
This goes in Non-Political Chat, where there are a few threads related to the topic.

Or did you just want to discuss the "what ifs" of the battle, e. g. if Stonewall Jackson had been alive and present at the battle?
 
I had just wanted to make a general remembrance.


Since you brought it up though: Lee often gets criticized for the third day (Pickett's Charge), how was his performance on the second day? I.e., was attacking Little Round Top the right move?
 
I had just wanted to make a general remembrance.


Since you brought it up though: Lee often gets criticized for the third day (Pickett's Charge), how was his performance on the second day? I.e., was attacking Little Round Top the right move?

The whole battle was a bad idea.
never good to fight a battle by running in to the enemy by accident.
 
Top