1493: The Columbian Crusade

Hnau

Banned
The French corsair, Guillaume de Casenove, actually burns down Columbus' ship (in OTL his was one of the two that escaped) with flaming pitch. Just before he abandons the vessel, he promises God to rescue Constantinople from the Turks if He saved him. He jumps overboard, finds some floating debris (an oar or two) and swims for hours to the Portuguese coastline. Exhausted, he crawls onto the beach, and lets say he hallucinates a vision of the Holy Trinity approving of his mission. Luckily, a Portuguese servant-girl finds him, alerts a nearby village, whose men nurse Columbus back to health. In a few weeks he finds passage to Britain to hook up with the survivors of the attack, but soon he begins planning for his crusade.

In May 1476, the merchant apprentice Christopher Columbus took part in an armed convoy sent by Genoa to carry a valuable cargo to northern Europe. It was in August, as the fleet of six ships sailed passed the Portuguese coastline, that they were attacked by the French corsair Guillaume de Casenove. As the crew began to hurl flaming pitch onto the pirate's vessel, an accident caused Columbus' own ship to be set aflame. It is here that Christopher spoke quietly in prayer, "Dear God, am I to be your servant or not? I give my life to you, if you spare it now. I will free Constantinople. The Hagia Sophia will once again hear the music of the holy mass, only save me alive, dear God."

Christopher would leap into the sea and shortly thereafter find an oar which he would hang onto for dear life until, after hours of paddling, he would be thrown onto a wild Portuguese beach. So exhausted that he could barely move, the Genoan looked for water. In his desperation, he witnessed a vision of the Holy Trinity, who spoke to him, "Christopher Columbus, you are my servant. I have saved you alive for the holy work of taking baptism once more to the churches along the Bosporus, to be ruled no more by the heathen."

Soon thereafter, as if by God's grace, a woman from a nearby village found Columbus struggling for life. The men of the village would soon nurse him back to life. In a couple of days he would catch a ship to England to join his convoy once more.

With business there finished, Columbus soon married in 1478 to Filipa Moniz Perestrello, daughter of Genoese nobleman Bartolomeo Perestrello, the governor of Porto Santo. In 1479 his son Diego was born. He has already began spreading word about funding a crusade during his work as a merchant, earning the nickname as the "Crusader-Merchant" that brought about as much respect as humiliation. In 1482, however, his name and reputation allows him an audience at the court of newly-coronated King John II of Portugal. The discussion bore no fruit, but this aided his reputation and allowed him to speak with Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand II in 1483. Though they showed their support, eager to appear as more Christian than their rival King John, they were forced to decline investing or making agreements when the Reconquista was still ongoing.

Columbus determined that to finance his crusade he would have to gain papal support and the passion of the Italian states. In 1484 he would arrive in Rome just as Pope Innocent VIII would succeed Pope Sixtus IV, and witness his fiery speech calling for a crusade against the growing Ottoman Empire. Columbus sees this as a sign from above and immediately requests an audience with the Pope, making it known that as an independent fund-raiser and investor he has already put together a small army and navy to send against the Turks.

By 1485 the Pope receives the 'Crusader Merchant' and in a famous meeting he is energized by Columbus' passion and blesses him as a holy warrior of God. Columbus tells Pope Innocent VIII that the recent deliverance of Prince Cem, pretender to the Ottoman throne, to Papal custody is a godsend, evident that the Father desired him to be used to put 'a friend of Christendom' on the Ottoman throne. As their mutual enthusiasm builds in this meeting, the Pope reveals to Columbus that he has a plot underway with Neapolitan noblemen to overthrow King Ferdinand I, who had led the Kingdom of Naples in a war against the Papal States in 1482. He thus enlists Columbus to send for his ships and soldiers and prepare them to enter Naples on the scheduled day to support the coup d'etat.

Columbus sets out on this mission and in the later part of the year, he lands six ships and a small army (of mainly mercenaries and zealous volunteer-profiteers) at Naples. Leading his men himself, confident that God will protect him, his soldiers link up with the rebels and play a crucial part in taking the city center and capturing the King. Ferdinand II and the most important of the loyalist nobles are imprisoned at the Papal See, while the Neapolitans invite René II, Duke of Lorraine, claimant to the Kingdom of Naples, to take the crown.

Success in this adventure paid very nicely, with Neapolitan noblemen cementing Columbus with a high position in the Neapolitan navy as a de facto admiral of the fleet. King René II becomes the first to honor Christopher Columbus and pledge his newly-won Kingdom to a coalition of nations to re-take Constantinople and force Prince Cem on the throne of the Ottoman Empire. This was the beginning of the League of Naples, and from thence-forth, Columbus would base his organizing, planning, fund-raising and investment activities from the city. The reign of King René II would also see military expenditures rise in the Kingdom. René was motivated by the idea of crusade in order to re-take Jerusalem and the Holy Land, as he was a claimant to the Kingdom of Jerusalem as well.

Emboldened by Columbus' aid, as he had proven himself in battle, Pope Innocent VIII began once more the rally-call to Crusade. Christopher Columbus was told that two European powers would be vital to the success of a Tenth Crusade, the Kingdom of France and the Republic of Venice: France to supply the soldiers and artillery, Venice to supply the ships to carry them and to establish European dominance over the Mediterranean. Columbus would spend 1486 to 1488 in attempts to sway each to join the League of Naples.

Young King Charles VIII of France was still in his minority, and Columbus could not convince regents Anne of Beaujeu and Peter of Bourbon to lend their support, as they were involved in a successional crisis known as the Mad War. Negotiations were also compromised due to the fact that King René II had expressed sympathies for the rebelling lords. Columbus soon realized that he would not win France until Charles VIII, who held a fiery desire to win glory for Christendom by fighting the Ottomans, came to his majority.

While his association with King René II held up his progress with France, in the Venetian Republic his name helped considerably, for René II had fought for the Republic of Venice in the Battle of Adria. However, the Venetian Doge Agostino Barbarigo expressed reluctance to go to war with the Ottoman Empire when they had signed an expensive peace with them in 1479. Nevertheless, Columbus found investors and names in order to push ahead his goal.

He found hope in the Duchy of Milan, where Christopher Columbus promised Ludovico Sforza that he could assist him in receiving papal authority for the legitimacy of the ducal crown, of which Ludovico had stolen from his newphew Gian Sforza. Columbus also promised the old Genoan colonies along the Crimea could be made his possession once more, along with trading rights through the Bosporus Strait. The Duchy of Milan was thus the next power to join the League of Naples.

King Ferdinand II of Aragon and Queen Isabella of Castille, while they did favor the idea of a European crusade against the Turks, did not appreciate the theft of the Crown of Naples from the House of Trastamara. Their relationship with the Crusader-Merchant effectively ended from that moment on, though they wouldn't keep him from doing business with Spanish investors.

In May 1489, on his return to Naples, Christopher Columbus became aware that Catherine Cornaro, Queen of Cyprus, had forfeited her titles to the Republic of Venice. The Turks responded to the Venetian movement by pillaging and slaving along the Karpasia Peninsula in Cyprus. Christopher used this act of aggression to convince Agostino Barbarigo to join the League of Naples and begin preparations for war.

There was one piece left to the puzzle: the Kingdom of France. Venice would not embark to retake Constantinople with Milanese, Papal, Neapolitan and mercenary soldiers alone. It needed French manpower.

In 1490, Columbus made a quick stop to the Kingdom of Hungary, to speak with the brand-new monarch, Ladislaus II, who might reverse the papal opposition policies of his predecessor. In the months that he stayed, he realized that King Ladislaus II held very little real power, with the Hungarian nobles controlling his policies, and they were not about to risk their lands when they had just signed a peace treaty with the Ottoman Empire in 1484. Columbus thus left for France. Indeed, the Hungarian attendance was a failure for Cristoforo Colombo: it wasted precious time he could have used in the French court and alerted some pro-Ottoman Hungarian nobles to his plans. This would be passed in the months ahead to the bureaucracy of the Ottoman Empire.
 
Last edited:
Sweet! I've always wanted to see an actual TL of Orson Scott Card's Pastwatch. I've never found it particularly plausible, but it was still really freaking cool as an AH idea. I approve. :cool:
 

Hnau

Banned
I didn't find it plausible either. This timeline will feature a bloody crusade, but not a Tlaxcalan invasion of Europe (Card made up too many historical facts to make that situation work). I'm going to have Columbus capture Constantinople and then just see where it goes.
 

Hnau

Banned
In late 1490 the high crusader once again sailed for France, stopping in Milan, Savoy, Spain and Portugal to cash in investments and look for new ones. He would arrive at the court of King Charles VIII of France in Paris only in the summer of 1491. He informed the monarch personally of new developments and the accession of Venice into the League of Naples. Columbus' showmanship abilities paid off, as at the end of his audience he had earned a fast friend in King Charles. Christopher attended his majority ceremony on June 30, when he became 21-years old. However, Charles informed Columbus that the regents would not be willing to allow him full control over his kingdom until he had wed. He kept the Crusader-Merchant confident, however, when he revealed his plans to marry Anne of Brittany that December, bringing Brittany finally under the French crown. Nevertheless, Columbus and King Charles in secret assembled military minds loyal to the idea of crusade and instructed them to begin plans to build an army.

Invited to the wedding that winter, Columbus journeyed to King Henry VII of England, hoping to convince him to join the European kingdoms to fight for Christendom. The English king, however, was more concerned with internal affairs and destroying claimants to the throne, and bluntly sent Columbus back to France.

After King Charles' wedding, Columbus assisted him in securing independence from his regents, and was frequently mentioned as the 'Court Genoan'. He created a committee to advance preparations of the war. Before leaving for Naples in early 1492, Christopher Columbus reminded the young French king that the League awaited him, and to send crusaders to Naples as soon as he could muster them.

In April 1492, Columbus visited the aged Pope Innocent VIII, who had fallen ill earlier in the year. Fearing that he would not see the Crusade he had fought for, he instructed Columbus to do God's will and blessed him once more. He then informed Columbus that he had begun mobilizing his armies and fleets since Columbus' departure. The Pope awarded Columbus a few titles and fiefs, possessions he believed the next Pope might take for his own if it weren't under the possession of the famous Crusader-Merchant. The Tenth Crusade was expected to begin as soon as the winter waters receded in 1493. It would begin much sooner than that, as the Sublime Porte had decided on a pre-emptive attack against their enemies...

-EDITED: In the earlier version, the Ottomans attacked Corfu in November. Then I learned how Bayezid II never historically ordered any naval expeditions in the winter months, due to the dangerous waters during the season. My second idea was for the Ottoman Empire to send a fleet to take Corfu by July, 1492, as they did in the Turkish-Venetian War of 1499-1503. While alternatively, I could have the Europeans make the first attack, possibly straight to Anatolia, Bayezid II was a shrewd military leader, and I believe he would have made a pre-emptive attack.
- EDITED: In the earlier version, Spain supported the Crusade by giving Colombus basing rights in Sicily. It was pointed out that Ferdinand and Isabella wouldn't be so friendly to the League of Naples, as the Crown of Naples had been stolen from their House of Trastamara.
 
Last edited:
Its nice to see something good being made of Rene II

I will watch this one with interest !

Best Regards
Grey Wolf
 
Sweet. I was hoping that you'd find a way of pulling off the whole Tlaxcalan thing, but this is still, as I said, really freaking cool. Keep it up!
 
Its nice to see something good being made of Rene II

I will watch this one with interest !

Best Regards
Grey Wolf
I always thought he was an interesting figure. He had claims to Anjou, Provence, Lorraine, and Naples. His grandfather was also King of Aragon. :eek:


But as to the timeline: it's too bad you couldn't have Matthias Hunyadi survive for a few more years. I think he would have been much more interested in a crusade than Ladislaus II... :(
 
Great to see this in the works. How many does that make, Hnau? 4 in-progress TLs?

BTW, you refer to Henry VIII as king of England. It should be Henry VII.

While this Crusade should be pretty interesting, I'm also looking forward to an alt-discovery of the Western Hemisphere at some future date.
 

Hnau

Banned
Nichomacheus said:
Great to see this in the works. How many does that make, Hnau? 4 in-progress TLs?

Eh... now that you mention that, I must admit I have a problem. You'd think that extra summer free-time would give me time to hone a specific timeline to perfection, but the ideas just keep on coming. I'm not proud of it. For this piece, I'll probably follow my Oikoumene pattern: get through the initial concept (in this case, the end of the Columbian Crusade and contact with America) and then leave the long-term aftermath for later.

Faeelin said:
I await the Ottoman victory. Urrah!

What makes you so sure of this? I'm just drafting the beginning of the war, and it looks like either side has an equal chance of winning, so I must inquire why you feel so confident about the Empire's victory.

Let me introduce to you my most valuable resource, Fisher's War With Venice, 1499-1503. It has a lot of elements of total war between European nations and the Ottoman Empire and a fascinating amount of information. I know realize that Bayezid was something of a military genius, while the Ottomans had an amazing capacity to build new fleets in a season, repair their ships rapidly, copy Venetian designs mid-war, while Turkish captains were regarded as far superior to their Venetian counterparts. It still comes out pretty even though, because in this situation its the Europeans that have the initiative in the war, not the Ottomans, and they attack all at once, not staggered as in the Ottoman-Venetian war (when many powers united at one point). The Ottomans also feared Venetian galleys before this war and I believe that if the Venetians, French and Neapolitans push hard enough early in the war, it will shatter Ottoman naval strength in the eastern Mediterranean. Simmering rebellion in Anatolia and outright unrest amongst the Karamanids is spoken of as a motive in OTL for Bayezid to find a peace quickly: six years earlier, with Prince Cem as a pretender to the throne, this will be even more destabilizing, especially if the Crusaders can get Prince Cem to Anatolia.

Moreover, it looks like Hungarian king Ladislaus II wasn't that much of a push-over: he declared war in 1501 when hostilities accidentally broke out amongst the troops, invalidating a truce (as he will have to do in TTL if he enters). Moreover, he brought the Russians and Poles into the anti-Ottoman war and caused the Ottoman army to re-align all of their forces towards the Balkans. If that happens in this timeline, with a serious rebellion in Anatolia and Crusaders dominating the Mediterranean, the Bayezid II might just fold, restricted to Istanbul and his European portion of the Empire.

Ahh... this is a fun timeline to write, I'm excited to continue work on it. Bulgarian-Wallachian kingdom, resurgent Hungary, Crusader kingdoms in Thrace and Greece... Lots of fun to have.
 
Last edited:
What if the Mamluks, who had started to wane at this time, saw an oppurtunity to strike when the Ottomans are preoccupied with the new crusaders?

This could keep them propped up for several more years and not become under the yoke of the Ottomans as in OTL. This would also help the crusaders by drawing off more troops. Or it could be at the Venetians' request to Qaitbay because of the large dept he owed them.
 

corourke

Donor
This is my favorite time for PODs. We're getting up toward 1492... when will the Americas be discovered?
 
Charles VIII's claim to Naples

I like this timeline too, however would Charles VIII give up his claim to Naples so easily? OTL he conquered Naples as part of a long-term plan to actually do a crusade so he'd certainly be interested in the latter part.
 
What makes you so sure of this? I'm just drafting the beginning of the war, and it looks like either side has an equal chance of winning, so I must inquire why you feel so confident about the Empire's victory.

The way that the Ottomans managed to get to Vienna in 1526, and threaten Italian cities in the 1480s.
 
Yeah, but the Europeans weren't much of a united front, were they?

Not to be a wet blanket, but I think this will likely be known as the Columbian Crusade, or the Crusade for Constantinople or something like that rather than the Tenth. It seems like there were a lot of tangential crusades not counted for some reason and named for different things rather than the numbers.
 

Hnau

Banned
I believe I explained the reasons the Mamelukes won't be intervening any time soon in the earlier thread: they had succession issues, unrest in their territories, and a recent horrible plague in Cairo. Read this article.

I like this timeline too, however would Charles VIII give up his claim to Naples so easily?

My reasons for him abandoning his claim to Naples is A) a more long-term plan to take Naples by uniting his dynasty with fellow French noble, King Rene II, B) The fact that Naples is now under the control of a Frenchman makes there less of an urgency to take control of it, C) Early correspondance with Columbus focuses his ambitions on a Crusade for general benefits to European civilization, rather than for personal benefit. Columbus convinces King Charles VIII that he can't do it by himself.

Not to be a wet blanket, but I think this will likely be known as the Columbian Crusade

Understood, which is why I named the timeline as I did. The name 'Tenth Crusade' will likely be thrown around, but I don't think it will stick if Columbus remains the leading personality in the war.
 
Why should Charles care that a Frenchman controls...

...Naples. This wasn't about national interest, it was about a dynastic claim. Further, Lorraine was an independent Duchy, I'm not sure he'd even be considered French. Perhaps Charles could be bought off with Lorraine and Bar.
 

Hnau

Banned
You are absolutely right, bill_bruno, I didn't realize at this time that Lorraine was an independent Duchy. That was foolish of me. What I do know is that King Charles needed to be convinced to go after Naples, by Ludovico Sforza and his advisors. Well, Sforza won't be pushing him to take Naples ITTL, and his advisors might just agree with Columbus' position on the Crusade. Nevertheless, bringing 25,000 French soldiers into the Kingdom of Naples could cause problems. Especially when King Rene claims Jerusalem.

My idea: King Rene II was never one to push his claims through force. I believe he was quite content with Lorraine and Bar and adding Naples to his dominions gives him quite a job. I wonder if Columbus could broker a deal between the two monarchs, with King Charles VIII giving up his claim to Naples and King Rene II giving up his claim to the Kingdom of Jerusalem and perhaps the Duchy of Bar as well (which was partly within France's borders). Does this sound plausible?

June - The Italian states (principally the Duchy of Milan, the Republic of Venice, the Papal States, and the Kingdom of Naples) raise a standing army of 21,000 men.

August - 15,000 French crusaders and 2,000 Swiss mercenaries enter the Kingdom of Naples.

September - Christopher Columbus brokers the Treaty of Benevento, in which King Charles VIII of France ceded his dynastic claims to the Kingdom of Naples and in return King René II of Naples ceded his dynastic claim to the Kingdom of Jerusalem, as well as the territory of the Duchy of Bar within the Kingdom of France (including Bar) to the royal domain. There is also an agreement to base a quarter of the French army in Venice, so as to not threaten Naples as much.

November - Another 10,000 French crusaders and 6,000 French-employed Swiss mercenaries enter the Republic of Venice. Half of this army is soon relocated to the Kingdom of Naples.

-- NOTICE: I edited my last installment. My initial idea was for a land invasion of Corfu from the mainland in November. Then I realized that would be a stupid thing for the Ottomans to do, what with winter and the lack of naval support and all. The Ottomans will be sending a fleet to take Corfu in July, 1492, beginning the war half a year earlier than I had thought initially.
 
Last edited:
Top