Now before we begin, I would like to inform you that the following update that you are about to read was not written by yours truly, but is in actuality a Special Guest Update written by my good friend
Binky the Clown.
A while back, Binky came to me via PM and asked me if he could write a one off update for the TL about Spain, I agreed, and planned to have it as a special update for the 30th overall one, but delays have pushed it back to being the 31st.
In fact, Binky ended up writing what amounted to several updates worth of content about Spain, so instead of being a one off, the content he has written will be formatted into several proper updates and posted periodically in between my own work. Starting with this one.
With that out of the way now, let's begin reading; shall we?
=======
PART 31
A History of Spain During the Second World War – Part One
“Our regime is based on bayonets and blood, not hypocritical elections.” –
Francisco Franco Bahamonde [1]
A propaganda poster commemorating the Nationalist victory and portraying el Caudillo
as a dashing, charismatic individual.
Unlike in Germany and Italy where fascism rose to power through relatively peaceful means, the rise of fascism in Spain was a traumatic, bloody affair. Without the bloodshed of the Spanish Civil War, it is likely the
Falange Española would’ve remained but a footnote in Spanish history. Prior to the Civil War, the Falange was shunned by the Spanish right because of its republican and national syndicalist platform. Many conservatives viewed the Falange as a group of crypto-reds, despite the Falange’s fierce anti-Communism. In 1936, the Falange had around 10,000 members and received less than one percent of the vote – a dismal showing, even by the standards of the 1936 election.
However, the rise of the
Frente Popular and the subsequent Civil War in Spain resulted in the discreditation of traditional conservatism amongst the Spanish right. Their moderate approach had failed to prevent the left from seizing power, so a more radical solution was needed. With its violent, militaristic and fiercely nationalistic tone, the Falange was able to recruit thousands of new members. Its membership doubled twice over in the first months of the Civil War, and climbed to 650,000 members by 1939. The Falange was made the official political party of the
Movimiento Nacional, absorbing the Carlist
Communion Tradicionalista in 1937. Nationalist Caudillo Francisco Franco became
Jefe Nacional of the Falange, while Ramón Serrano Suñer became head of the Falange’s
Junta Politica.
Cuñadísimo
Serrano Suñer, visiting the headquarters of the Leibstandarde SS Adolf Hitler.
An alumnus of the University of Bologna, Suñer greatly admired Italian Fascism and had been a close friend of José Antonio Primo de Riviera. Suñer hoped to achieve the goals of the Falange as part of the new, Nationalist government in Spain. Suñer was no stranger to politics, having served in parliament as MP for Zaragosza and as an official in the CEDA - Spain’s largest right-wing political party prior to the Civil War. Franco, on the other hand, was a career military officer who rose through the ranks of the Spanish Army. Franco was already well known for his exploits in Africa during the Rif War and for his brutal suppression of a miners strike in Asturias. Franco had joined the Nationalists after the assassination of José Calvo Sotelo, taking command of the Army of Africa on July 17th, 1936.
With the help of his brother Nicolás, Franco contacted Germany and Italy, who airlifted the Army of Africa to metropolitan Spain. By the end of the year, Franco had been proclaimed
Generalísimo of the Nationalist forces and
Jefe del Estado. Franco’s diplomatic ties to Germany and Italy, combined with the combat experience of the Army of Africa, propelled him to the top of the Nationalist hierarchy. Franco gained almost unlimited powers and a degree of control over Spanish life that the medieval kings of Spain could only dream of. While Franco was no José Antonio Primo de Riviera, he was sympathetic to the goals of the Axis and to the illiberal, militaristic ideals of fascism.
In March of 1939, Spain joined the Anti-Comintern Pact alongside Germany, Italy and Japan. This was a largely symbolic gesture, as Spain was still recovering from the devastation caused by the Civil War. Nearly 30 percent of Spain’s maritime tonnage had been destroyed, as well as half of Spain’s railway locomotives. Eight percent of Spain’s housing and more than a third of Spain’s livestock had been lost. On the eve of the Italian invasion of France, Mussolini contacted Franco, urging him to invade France alongside Italy. Franco declined Mussolini’s offer, believing the tide would eventually turn in the Allies’ favor.
It would take Spain nearly a decade to recover from the carnage of the Civil War.
After the Fall of France, Franco began to re-assess Spanish neutrality. Spain changed its stance from one of neutrality to one of non-belligerence, just as Italy had done before entering the war. Hours later, Spain occupied the Tangier International Zone. Franco proclaimed it “a temporary measure to guarantee the continued neutrality of the zone.” While Britain accepted this move, Franco’s decision to claim Gibraltar a month later was less well received. In September, Franco sent a communiqué to Hitler, informing the
Führer that he was willing to join the Axis war effort in exchange for territorial concessions in Africa – namely French Morocco, western Algeria, French territory in the Sahara and Cameroon - control of Gibraltar and economic aid. Franco urged Hitler to attack Britain, citing the threat the Royal Navy posed to Spain and the continent at large, especially in the Mediterranean.
By late 1940, Hitler’s primary concern was preparing for the coming war in the east. A campaign against Britain would divert valuable resources from Operation Barbarossa. Hitler was also concerned about the state of the Spanish military, fearing that Spain would require substantial amounts of German reinforcement. The OKW determined that seizing Gibraltar would require two army corps, as well as significant amounts of airpower and heavy artillery. [2] Spain’s infrastructure was another concern, especially its railway network. Furthermore, Hitler was concerned that forcing Vichy France to cede territory to Spain would undermine the legitimacy of the Vichy government and result in the defection of French Africa to De Gaulle and the Allied camp. [3] With German troops already tied down in the Balkans, Hitler could ill-afford to expend any more manpower for the likes of Spain.
Less than a week after Operation Barbarossa began, Franco authorized the creation of the
División Española de Voluntarios to fight alongside the Wehrmacht on the Eastern Front. The
División Española would be placed under German command, but would technically be subordinate to the Army Ministry in Madrid. All officers of the Division Espanola were drawn from the regular army, as well as nearly seventy percent of its recruits. Contrary to popular belief, civilian Falangists comprised less than a third of the Division’s manpower. Franco’s annual address to the National Council – the Spanish equivalent of Mussolini’s Grand Council of Fascism – was peppered with pro-Axis rhetoric. He denounced “the eternal enemies” of Spain who engaged in “intrigues and betrayal” against it.
Franco went further, declaring “the war was wrongly conceived and the Allies have lost it,” concluding his speech by praising Germany for leading “the battle sought by Europe and Christianity for so many years, and in which the blood of our youth with be united with that of our comrades in the Axis, as a living expression of solidarity.” The ferocity and rhetoric of his speech came as a surprise to both the German and Italian ambassadors, who commented on the imprudence of these remarks. [4] By August, Franco’s remarks went from imprudent to prophetic as Leningrad fell to the Germans. This resulted in a surge of new recruits in Spain, eager to crush the Bolshevik menace. [5]
Francisco Franco visits the División Azul
before they cross the Pyrenees and head to Germany for further training.
A month after Leningrad fell, Suñer met with Franco at El Pardo to discuss the German war in the east. Suñer suggested participation in the German war effort against the Soviet Union could serve as a means of acquiring vital economic and military aid. Despite his bombastic speech two months prior, Franco remained concerned about the consequences of direct Spanish participation in the war. Suñer informed his brother-in-law that he’d ordered Foreign Minister José Félix de Lequerica and Ambassador José Finat [6] to draft a plan of action that would prevent Spain from coming into conflict with Britain, while still aiding Germany and the Axis war effort. Three weeks after the meeting at El Pardo, Léquerica and Finat met with Von Ribbentrop in Nuremburg.
Spain offered to supply 60,000 troops and 300 pilots to the Axis war effort, as well as to stop selling wolfram on the open market in favor of a quota system. Doing so would greatly benefit Germany, since the sale of Spanish wolfram on the open market gave an unfair advantage to Britain with its larger reserves of hard currency. [7] To allay German fears of a renewed conflict in the west, Finat guaranteed that Spain would remain neutral towards Britain and Free France, regardless of Spanish territorial ambitions. More ominously, Spain also promised to close its borders to Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi-occupied Europe. [8]
Spain would pay back its debt from the Civil War in four instalments, which Germany would use to purchase wolfram. Germany, meanwhile, would provide Spain with a minimal amount of military material at cost, with further economic and military aid to be provided once hostilities ended. [9] On October 4th , 1941 - the same day Spanish troops entered into combat on the Eastern Front – the Léquerica-Ribbentrop Agreement was ratified by both parties in Berlin. With it, Spain became a co-belligerent in Germany’s war with the Soviet Union, while simultaneously maintaining a façade of neutrality.
Back in Madrid, the Army Ministry reorganized the
Division Espanola de Voluntarios into the
Cuerpo Española de Voluntarios, while an air wing known as the
Aviación Legionaria was established to fight alongside the Cuerpo Espanola. Falangist Generals Agustín Muñoz Grandes and Juan Yagüe Blanco were placed in charge of the volunteers. Grandes was one of the most prominent neo-Falangist [10] generals in Spain, having briefly served as General Secretary of the Falange, while Yagüe had been Minister of Air until a falling out with Franco in the summer of 1940. [11] Grandes was renowned for his tactical genius and diligence, while Yagüe was reportedly the only Spanish commander the Condor Legion respected.
Agustín Muñoz Grandes (Left) and Juan Yagüe Blanco (Right)
Since neither group of volunteers were allowed to use official Spanish uniforms, they adopted a uniform comprised of the blue shirts of the Falange, the red berets of the Carlists and the khaki pants of the Army of Africa. Both the
Cuerpo Azul and
Legión Azul distinguished themselves in combat, playing a pivotal role at the Battle of Stalingrad. Hitler was particularly impressed by their exploits, deeming them “equal to the best” German divisions while also proclaiming Spaniards to be “the only tough Latins.” Officially, Spain remained non-belligerent. Franco had seen the way Hitler refused to assist the Italians in Africa and feared that fully committing himself to the Axis would result in the loss of Spain’s African colonies.
Nevertheless, Britain worried about Franco’s deepening ties with the Axis. Shortly after the German invasion of Poland, Britain placed a strict economic embargo on Spain, in which shippers around the world had to obtain clearance from the British consul for every shipment of cargo to Spain. Royal Navy inspectors maintained a blockade, certifying all ships entering Spain. [12] This blockade drew the ire of American merchants and isolationist groups such as the America First Committee. Britain justified its actions by accusing Spain of re-exporting American petroleum – specifically aviation fuel - to Germany. Ambassador Kennedy described the British blockade as “disgraceful” and railed against Britain for “sticking its nose in the business of a neutral country.” [13]
Shortly after the Fall of France, Churchill sent a personal letter to President Roosevelt, asking him to do whatever he could to stop American companies from exporting oil to Spain. [14] Roosevelt informed Churchill that it was extremely unlikely Congress would approve of such an embargo and the subject was quietly dropped. Spain responded to the British blockade with an embargo of its own, denying the British access to vital supplies of potash and iron ore. Churchill denounced Franco’s actions, once again asking Roosevelt to impose an embargo on Spain. This time, Roosevelt actively pushed congress to pass such an embargo; however, Franco had publicly condemned the Pearl Harbor attacks a month earlier, gaining significant public sympathy in the process. [15] Thus, the embargo failed to pass.
”I fear the Americans have made a tragic error, Samuel. [16] They have failed to understand the consequences of their actions, actions that will have ramifications for decades to come.” – Sir Winston Churchill, January 1942
Notes
1. OTL quote from Franco’s victory speech in Madrid.
2. Operation Felix.
3. Aside from the obvious economic factors, Hitler’s inability to guarantee Spanish control of French North Africa was the primary reason Franco sat the war out.
4. Surprisingly enough, this was an OTL speech given by Franco in July 1941.
5.
Hearts of Iron III reference FTW.
6. IOTL, José Félix de Lequerica wasn’t made Foreign Minister until 1945. The reasons for Lequerica’s early appointment will be made clear in the next update.
7. Spain tried this IOTL, but it fell apart.
8. This isn’t that much of a stretch, considering Franco’s rabid anti-Semitism. If anything, what happened OTL was far more implausible.
Of course, this also means that around 25,000 to 35,000 more people will die in the Holocaust ITTL.
: (
9. Such an agreement was made OTL, but in 1943.
10. Neo-Falangists are those who joined the Falange after the Civil War began, as opposed to before. Don’t be fooled, though: these guys were no less fascistic than the
Camisas Viejas.
11. There are rumors that the Germans were planning on having Yagüe overthrow Franco, but this is highly unlikely.
12. Believe it or not, this was done by the British IOTL.
13. Dammit Joseph! How is Jack supposed to have a political career if his father is going to be blamed for losing Europe to the Nazis ITTL?
: (
14. OTL, the United States placed an oil embargo on Spain the second the Battle of France ended and the Battle of Britain began. However, it is unlikely this would’ve occurred if the Battle of Britain hadn’t taken place.
15. With American oil still flowing into Spain, Franco is a little more tactful ITTL. OTL, the Spanish sent a telegram to the Japanese, congratulating them on successfully attacking the United States. This cable was intercepted by the OSS, who was not amused. Strangely enough, Franco wasn’t even all that fond of Imperial Japan, seeing their behavior as “barbaric.” Franco even offered to form a second Blue Division to fight alongside the Allies in the Pacific.
16. Referring to Sir Samuel Hoare, British Ambassador to Spain.
==================================
Hope you guys enjoyed Binky's first contribution to the timeline, the next scheduled update written by myself, Part 32; should still be arriving sometime on or before
February 22nd. As stated before.