Search results

  1. No Franco Prussian War

    ?????????????????
  2. WI Soviets intervene militarily in Yom Kippur War?

    Israel had achieved its basic war aims - to defend its current territory, and to defeat the Arab armies in the field. The Syrian attack on the Golan Heights had been utterly repulsed, one Egyptian army was cut off and literally dying of thirst, a second was immobilised due to fuel being cut off...
  3. Horses, livestock in Aboriginal Australia

    The aboriginals would have eaten them into extinction, the way they ate all the native megafauna.
  4. Terrorist nuclear war before 1977

    ... apparently was possible Keeping Presidents in the Nuclear Dark (Episode #1: The Case of the Missing “Permissive Action Links”) Keeping Presidents in the Nuclear Dark (Episode #2: The SIOP Option that Wasn’t) Hair-Trigger Missiles Risk Catastrophic Terrorism Nuclear Recollections These are...
  5. Monica has better friends

    I think that if she were the sort of person who had better judgment about who to confide in, she would have had the good sense not to schtup her boss, too. So not only would there have been no-one to dob her in, there would have been nothing to dob her in for.
  6. WWI Result without American Involvement

    Exactly. The Turks, Austrians, Hungarians and Bulgarians all sued for peace without any Americans shooting at them. American troops went to France and fought there. There's a reason we don't hear about the US Marine assault on the walls of Kars, or the US Navy bombardment of Trieste, or the US...
  7. Amerindian States

    Mexico was a full nation and had the wheel and everything. Didn't stop the Yanquis from finding excuses to make war on and conquer large parts of them. No Amerindian state is going to be able to stand up to the USA, which will keep coming until they're utterly destroyed. They might, as they...
  8. Russian Victory in the Crimean War

    Perhaps the Russians could be more aggressive. In OTL, they occupied the Danubian Principalities, and it was then that Britain and France came in (even though the Russians withdrew - the British and French wouldn't let a silly thing like achieving their war aims without firing a shot stop them...
  9. Negotiated Settlement in WWI

    These are popular points of view, the idea that Germany's defeat and the harsh terms it received paved the way for fascism. This theory does not explain why fascism appeared first in Italy, a country which had won in the Great War, and at the same time as in Germany, also in Spain, a country...
  10. How much could the Centeral Powers get if they won WW1.

    I think it would not be too pleasant, going on OTL German plans for Europe post-war... See my Petain's Panic for an example.
  11. Louis Napoleon's Gallstones

    In my scenarios I prefer to have only one point of divergence. Otherwise all you learn is that if everything were different, then everything would be different. Which is neither surprising nor interesting. What's most interesting is when you change one small thing and see what happens. With...
  12. Louis Napoleon's Gallstones

    Yes, but in the passage of years it comes to the same thing. We're doing a sketch here, not the final work. The final work is when you get to do your pedantic nitpicking. :p And what was on the white flag? The fleur-de-lis. It was not a blank white flag, though of course that could be an...
  13. Louis Napoleon's Gallstones

    Yes, whatever. It's hard to keep track of them all. Now, have you a suggestion or contribution?
  14. Louis Napoleon's Gallstones

    It's occurred to me that the formation of the Third Republic in France was a very near thing. It was declared in Paris on the news of the defeat of the French army at Sedan, and the capture of the Emperor. And once the peace was made, a government was elected in favour of monarchy. The Bonaparte...
  15. Hohenzollern Restoration

    It's hard to say. But there were public uprisings against the government. In practice the government from 1916 to October 1918 was "Hindenburg and Ludendorff", but in principle the government was the Kaiser. Symbols matter to people. Also, as we see throughout history, when a leader leads people...
  16. Possible book - Soviet invasion of the UK...

    June 1940, Paris falls, Lord Halifax becomes PM of Britain. July 1940, Britain makes peace with Germany. May 1941, Germany invades USSR December 1941, Japan attacks Pearl Harbour, US enters war against Japan. Since the USA is not sending huge amounts of supplies to Britain and irritating...
  17. Hohenzollern Restoration

    Little Willy was a supporter of anyone he thought could get him a throne. One prospect is actually to have the US stay out of WWI, or else the Germans be defeated before the US enters the war. The French and British were keen on the idea of breaking up Germany into Hannover, Bavaria, Saxony...
  18. WI the Allies invaded Norway first?

    I think it'll not change the overall WWII a bit, but cause Norway to not join NATO after the war. Britain and France invade, Germany "liberates" Norway. Historically, Germany formed SS Division (motorised) Wiking, with three motorised infantry regiments - Germania (German), Westland (Dutch and...
  19. Atlantropa is BUILT

    It sounds like an Albert Speer project :D Naziwank and Sovietwank go together with constructionwank :p
  20. The Trial of Robert E. Lee

    I dunno about the Union in 1861, but traditionally resignation isn't automatic, someone higher up has to accept your resignation. "Charge that machinegun post!" "Er... I resign! See ya." "Not so fast, soldier." I suspect that when you're resigning so you can join a rebellious army, you don't...
Top