Search results

I take intercepts over the Channel preferable to ones where British targets are threatened, which allowing them to cross does. I also doubt FC would actually manage to reach them actually assembling (they might), but it's highly likely, IMO, FC would be able to intercept before LW fighters...

:confused: It's just like NWT, but with oil & Americans?

So, if somebody, anybody, has thoughts on old threads, we should a) not start new threads, since somebody will complain & b) not revive old ones?:confused: Which amounts to "shut the hell up about it", doesn't it?:confused:

That's perfectly possible with just a little work. Me too! Me too!;)

Wait, now. This presumes a) Winston accepts, which is ASB, IMO & b) Japan doesn't attack British colonies in Asia, which is unlikely at best. So aid to Britain still happens. It's not direct aid against Germany, but it's aid. And if FDR doesn't drop Britain like a hot rock, what do you suppose...

You appear to be the only one who doesn't mind....:confused: Some say "don't start new threads on old subjects", then some say "don't resurrect old ones"...:confused::confused: Believe it or not, the necro got me kicked over complaints.:rolleyes: I really, really don't get it. If someone (not...

In light of the Army General Board's disbelief in the need for heavier tank guns, I have real doubts anything remotely resembling the mooted Thomas would ever appear... (BTW, who's it named for?)

Hurtig's Canadian Encyclopedia (v3, p.1917) says "by 1583...settlement had developed on the central and eastern sections of the N side of the harbour."

WW1-era crypto (no cypher machines) didn't desperately need computers to break it. There are 2 areas that occur to me: better AA (pretty haphazard WW1), which makes improved a/c possible, in response; & better sub torpedo firecontrol ("Gen 0.5" TDC, equal to, if not better than, the sliderules...

Except U-103 wasn't a Type XXI. Picture Nautilus (SSN-571, not SS-168) attacking a convoy: run in submerged, get past the escorts & into the convoy columns (which even Type VIIs were capable of), shoot & scoot, then come back later (after the escorts can't find you) & do it again. Morton wiped...

Why don't they go via Suez, Alex, & Marseilles/Toulon? Too sensible?

Well... "optimistically estimate three torpedoes per ships sunk"? No. It's perfectly possible to sink a freighter with one fish. And a Type 21 could get so close (not having to deal with escorts until very close in), it could almost guarantee a hit. So, with 23 fish, 12 or more ships/patrol...

At least some of the reduction in BdU effectiveness has to be in reduced crew quality. The early war crews had years in service. Also, I think you underestimate the influence of the Type XXI: it effectively obsoleted every ASW weap the Allies were fielding, except (perhaps) radar-equipped...

Mine, too. Very probable. Which should (I hope!) eliminate the problem OTL of putting the Luzon Strait off-limits, since the OTL SWPA/POA boundary ran right through it.:eek: Not developed even yet AFAIK, tho there were recognition signals arranged. These didn't work too well: the one case I...

Actually, it gets even better. Without MacArthur's mania for return to the P.I., you can take off about 6mo more (between reconquest, Iwo, & Oki), presuming Wainwright isn't as fixated on return, or FDR is more resistant to his demands. (This also butterflies the stupid Peleliu op.:eek:) Plus...

Not sure exatly what you're ref to, but: fix the torpedoes, put them all in Empire waters, Yellow Sea, & Luzon/Formosa Strait, you can shut off Japan's economy by Jan '44, changing nothing else. If Nimitz can be persuaded to use mining to bottle up IJN units, & puts tankers #1 sooner, subtract...

Noted. I presumed, given the others did, without checking.:o (I should know better...) My apologies to Chet Smith. I was working on the presumption (evidently faulty) of prewar training, relying on submerged sonar approaches, being the overweening influence (esp. since he was, what, Class of...

I have to disagree, here. As a fighter, the P-39 was a dog. As a strafer, it was excellent, & it made a great partner for the P-38 & P-40: P-38s on top, sweeping off the hassles; P-40s in the middle, swatting the flies that get past; & P-39s on the bottom, kicking butt & taking names...

No prob. And just to be clear, I never expected a rewrite.:eek: I only want to point 'em out for anybody else reading who might contemplate the likes of it. (PW sub war is kind of a specialty with me.) I'm just catching up, & I'll be watching with great interest. I've alredy learned some things...

Blair puts Pollack inbound to Pearl from Mare Island 7 Dec... I really do find that extraordinarily unlikely, even allowing for the usual (probable) 80% failure rate. How does Pollack (presuming she's anywhere near Guam, which I can't confirm) get close enough for a shot on such a...