Search results

  1. Pirate Madagascar

    Agreed, it's a very impressive timeline
  2. Could there have been a way to invade England?

    You're very right, troops made most of the way on transport ships and climbed down on ropes over the side. Then formed up and dashed for the shore
  3. Could there have been a way to invade England?

    It's not that the barges were so bad but that they would be very vulnerable against small attack craft like destroyers. The Allies' landing craft of 1944 on wards had the advantage of being almost totally protected from any seaborne threat by the massive Allied combined naval force. The upshot...
  4. Pirate Madagascar

    Just want to make it known that i'm still reading and very much enjoying this timeline. One thing i'm still not sure on though is that despite the large number of warships and settlements i always imagined the total population of Madagascar being quite low. If you include all the pirates of...
  5. Did japan have a choice?

    Before that but after lend-lease the American public was, iirc, over 2 thirds against war with Germany. Before the Axis declarations, there wasn't much of a direct cause for war in the States
  6. Did japan have a choice?

    without pearl the US would never have been directly involved with Japan, despite the atrocities. Roosevelt had a hard enough time convincing the public that fighting Germany was necessary. The embargo was an effective means of forcing American policy onto Japan without intervening in their war...
  7. Luckier IJN at Leyte

    I don't think that the Japanese naval forces around the Philippines could have achieved anywhere near the decisive success that they wanted, the IJN did have some luck at Leyte, managing to get a fleet near to the landing fleet without encountering the USN carriers. Then getting another fleet to...
  8. WI: Al Gore ran for President in 2008

    wonder if he would have accepted a vice-presidency under another clinton if he had failed to win the nomination?
  9. Most Overrated Battles (as PoDs)?

    Strangely the best way for Germany to win that battle would have been not to fight it at all. With Germans waltzing all over europe and with no visible enemy to fight at home, we probably would have lost the will to fight on.
  10. Kaiserreich mod for Darkest Hour

    exactly the same as all other versions, Steam just acts like the game launcher. You can actually play the game even with steam closed. just go to your steamapps folder and common and it's all there in Darkest hour. Put mods into the mods folder and fire her up, the game launcher has a mod...
  11. More effective Abwehr?

    Hi all, had a quick search through the forums but couldn't find anything relating to this recently so i decided to throw a quick thread up. Would there be any way of making the Abwehr more effective? would it take as little as replacing Canaris with someone more sympathetic to Nazi goals...
  12. Celtic central europe

    without Rome would the pressures that created the migration period simply disappear?
  13. AHC/WI: USSR Invades Nazi Germany

    could the USSR really hide or explain away the massive troop movements needed to prepare for an invasion of Germany like the Germans before Barbarossa? Despite many of the advantages that they would gain from a pre-emptive attack, the shortcomings of their armed forces at the time combined...
  14. The Fountainhead Filibuster: Tales from Objectivist Katanga

    very clever title, enjoying this so far. hoping to see the rang gang get smashed by the locals :) subbed
  15. CH: Amazing Video Game Based Movie

    goodbye sweet potential :D someone please make a cultural TL of this, even if i'm not the biggest fan of his work. Peter Jackson would surely have Neill Blomkamp involved (District 9) and i would love to see that film.
  16. What happened to "The Revolution Will Not Be Live"?

    nooooooooooooooooooooooooo
  17. DBWI: CH: Hitler's a bad guy

    there is always one....
  18. Chickens never evolve

    what a bleak world that would be
  19. Could the Third Reich have been more successful than OTL?

    earlier Barbarossa, a whole extra army to send to the east, not having to use vital manpower to police the balkans (also the possibility of brow beating the Yugoslavs into joining them) more tanks, more planes, less transport to support the logistics. sure, the Germans would have had to...
  20. WI: Montana Class Battleships Completed?

    keep the US out of a pacific war until they are laid down and you get a couple made. if the pacific does blow up, the moment a midway like battle happens (or sooner) then they will get pushed down in priority and, depending on how long the war goes on for, maybe cancelled. if everything goes...
Top