Search results

  1. How long could a Nazi insurgency have lasted?

    A Nazi IRA is an interesting thought. A bunch of criminals occasionally popping up and murdering people before melting into the general population. No reason that couldn't work, apolitical serial killers do even in countries that aren't in ruins afterall. Some Nazis sympathisers in Switzerland...
  2. Plausibility check: Colonial power controls Japan?

    The problem is that Japan is a very well organised country and it plays by pretty similar rules to European nations. Its somewhere Europeans can do business with without needing to conquer anything. You've also the problem of the 19th century political situation between the Europeans. You...
  3. (WI) Brettons migrate to Ireland

    Yeah. They were foreigners. There was little in the way of pan-celtic thinking. One of the key reasons for the Britons inviting over the English and fleeing to Brittany in the first place was Irish raiders.
  4. Doing away with religions

    Plus the Israelites weren't exactly a widespread and large in numbers people. Lots of ethnic groups have been wiped out over the course of history, no reason they couldn't be one among the many. You could also stop it developing into a rather unique religion with some early changes to keep it...
  5. Australia Colonised By India

    The big question you need to be asking is not are they capable of it- of course they are; the question is why would they? What is there to make them want to colonize Australia? That is what you need to tackle
  6. WI: More sporting Berwicks

    This is in after 1900 but it is really more of a late victorian period onwards question, no 1900 limit needed. Berwick Rangers are a rather insignificant football team from a small town which have never really amounted to anything. They are however fairly famous down to one odd fact about...
  7. AHC/WI: Transpacific Slave Trade

    To get Indians instead of Chinese perhaps you could afflict the Americans with the same type of thinking that Brits in the mid 20th century had with regards to muslims- they are loyal, hard working people who don't complain...not like those shifty pagans. I think you'd probaly need a big war...
  8. WI: a world without the Sex Pistols

    Though the punk sound had been fairly well developed earlier with e.g. The Ramones, the Sex Pistols are widely regarded as the first true punk band because such a major part of punk was about the style, attitude and fashion, not just the music. Without them punk could well follow a more Ramonesy...
  9. AHC: The British buy Alaska?

    The entire point of Alaska selling it to the USA was they figured the Brits (enemy number 1) were bound to take it anyway so they might as well rip off the Americans while they lose it. Pretty similar reasoning to the Louisiana Purchase. Nations tend not to sell land just for the hell of it...
  10. Poland says Yes!

    It wasn't the corridor hitter asked for, that was Polish. It was Danzig he wanted. If Poland have up Danzig then they would probably buy themselves a few months before the Germans then make other demands. Which is a good thing for the allies. The entire point of appeasement was that time was...
  11. AHC: United Kingdom of Scandinavia after Congress of Vienna

    The trouble is two of the big winners of the Napoleonic wars with Russia and Britain. Both of whom really don't like the idea of one nation, especially a powerful one, controlling the entrance to the Baltic. Not to mention that Prussia wouldn't approve of a new and powerful nation on its...
  12. WI: The British empire federates in the 1890s

    I disagree. Two points there. 1: Out of nowhere suddenly getting a say where there was none before and not much demand for it- that will make people happy 2:In the EU neither all people nor all countries have an equal say and it works fine. But generally as I said there's no real point...
  13. WI: The British empire federates in the 1890s

    The trouble is, what would the Imperial Parliament do? Domestic decisions are best handled locally and foreign policy isn't exactly something people are going to vote solely about. The way things evolved IOTL with regular meetings of the commonwealth leaders is the logical way for things to...
  14. Without its OTL policy of appeasing America, Britain would be a greater power today?

    In the 20th century yes, Britain could have done with being less trusting of the US. This is in before 1900 though so I've no idea what you're talking about with "appeasing america". Do you mean such things as not caring to fight over Washington and the like? The impact of such minor things...
  15. Allies bomb Auschwitz

    Assuming it was possible and the british were willing to do it then thee question remains of : Bomb what? Auschwitz is a big place. Was there intelligence of which part of it had the guards quarters? And then hitting that area correctly wouldn't be guarantied...
  16. Nazi colonization after a victory.

    I think if you look at the population density of OTL Ukraine and the major farming areas of the US, Australia, etc... you will see that it really doesn't take too many people to make efficient use of A LOT of land with modern farming techniques.
  17. Majority White-European African country?

    Larger and more disease resistant native population, less migrants from outside, the time in which most of Africa was colonized was a post slavery and less rapey time.
  18. Majority White-European African country?

    IOTL the Dutch arrived in South Africa at a pretty similar time to the Bantu peoples. Earlier even at the Cape. Speed up Dutch settlement there or slow down the Bantu migrations and you will leave only the Khoisans for Europeans to deal with, who are much less advanced and far fewer. A lot...
  19. How can I create a Jewish US state?

    Well, yeah, that was the point of my post. :p
  20. Pre-Sakoku Japan and Catholicism

    The trouble there is that the Emperor really helped to bind the country together. No matter what the actual political situation looked like there was always the emperor of Japan whose religious role is often gravely overlooked. It is true that over the Edo period it weakened and the Meiji...
Top