Search results

  1. WI: 1910, PM Balfour?

    That doesn't really seem like something Redmond would do at all. He might have been strung along by the Liberals and known it, but he always knew who the real enemy was and how disastrous an election would've been at that point.
  2. WI: 1910, PM Balfour?

    Balfour Ministry II: Electric Boogaloo pretty much totally derails British foreign policy by eliminating Grey from the picture; I can't see the Tories maintaining the Russian entente at all when the Liberals had such a hard time with it themselves although Henry Wilson, noted traitor, would...
  3. What Should Be the Ideal Size of Germany?

    I always thought that map was remarkable for having Austria as a participant in the "dismember Germany" party (huh?) and having to compensate by, apparently, speaking Italian, going by the place names there.
  4. What would happen if the Roman Empire simply was non-existent

    Okay, there's a pretty colossal difference of scale between the situation in the Greek East and the situation in Gaul. I'm as down on the general historical Greek tendency to be depressingly, unconstructively fratricidal as anybody, but while men like Antigonos, Antiochos, and Seleukos never...
  5. What would happen if the Roman Empire simply was non-existent

    Yeah, that's off by a century. It's been recognized since Mommsen (more recently, Arthur Eckstein has written multiple books on the subject) that Rome's macrohistorical "turn" to the Greek East happened around 200 BC, and was connected to the Second Makedonian War and the war against Antiochos...
  6. Against our Expections: Russian Victory in the Russo-Japanese War

    Hi, I'm new here, but I wrote something with a decidedly similar PoD (basically, victory at Sandepu) over the last few months and posted it on another forum. It's finished, about 80k words and a butt ton of footnotes. I was actually thinking about posting it here but then I saw this thread and...
  7. What Should Be the Ideal Size of Germany?

    Pft, Franconians have better beer than both of them and will one day liberate themselves from bayerisch oppression
  8. What Should Be the Ideal Size of Germany?

    The German Confederation plus the rest of Prussia and Schleswig.
  9. A History of the Pontic Empire

    Mmm, I honestly think that Antiochos Grypos would've put up more of a fight than that, but what's done is done. What happened to Kleopatra Selene in the wreck of the Seleukid Empire? She'd make a decent wife (and she'd almost certainly have been gunning for the position herself)...
  10. Could the Bosnian crisis of 1908 have lead to an early ww1?

    Fundamentally, France and Britain were unwilling and unready to go to war in 1908-9. Russia, potentially, was - all they have to do is reject Bülow's "Yes or No" note, which was theoretically an option - but they would have done so alone. As an aside, most of the initial revulsion in the...
  11. If Germany wins WWI, can a Fascist France and Russia gang up on Germny and win during

    I think most economic historians of any note have shied away from any sort of single-cause model for the GD. Interest rates weren't the only, maybe even not the primary, factor. It's a lovely cocktail. But the Federal Reserve's interest rates were tied quite closely to the Allied war effort...
  12. If Germany wins WWI, can a Fascist France and Russia gang up on Germny and win during

    Well, the far right did get reasonably popular in the early thirties in OTL despite France having won the war. François de la Rocque and his ilk didn't just come out of nowhere, and the rioting of the far right and alleged coup attempts on their part led pretty much directly to the...
Top