Search results

  1. Were major strains of American evangelicalism opposed to slavery?

    Religious opposition to slavery just about did what was politically possible. I'm not sure the South would ever agree to children of slaves being born free or mandated manumission like Brazil for example.
  2. AHC - Popular American TV lawyer show w/no criminal or family law

    Does the show Suits count? Usually it's contracts or business clients in the show.
  3. WI: Trials after the Fall of Communism?

    Pretty much. After a half century of Communism, you would be extremely hard pressed to find people who didn't participate in some form of the system. If they do exist, they'll be extremely old like Adenauer, or really young and inexperienced. This is why lustration has been such a drawn out...
  4. WI: Iraq Invasion With Over 500,000 Troops

    I have no idea why they didn't, because anyone who pauses to think about it would conclude failing to do so would enable militias to emerge.
  5. WI Afghanistan war becomes Vietnam 2.0

    I don't see this happening. Even the Soviets didn't have as rough as an experience as Vietnam, although it was still pretty bad. Who is going to arm and supply the Taliban? Afghanistan was a pariah state, even before 9/11. Afghanistan's problem was that after 2003, it became a secondary...
  6. WI: Iraq Invasion With Over 500,000 Troops

    They should have either kept the army intact, or disarmed them when they disbanded it. They chose the worst option.
  7. The reconquest: King of France TL

    Henri would have been king otherwise. The monarchists tried to wait for him to die, but by then people didn't view the Third Republic as an instable regime that need changing.
  8. The reconquest: King of France TL

    The distinction isn't as pronounced since the majority of legitimists accepted Philippe d'Orleans as Chambord's heir. Action française case in point.
  9. If Saddam fell in 1991 would Bush Junior have gone into Iran instead?

    Iran is three times larger in population. They had enough problems with Iraq OTL. Since the United States hasn't dealt with Iran directly since 1980, I doubt that regime change would be a priority. The Arab states might go for it, but then again they might fear the return of an alliance...
  10. Islam and Christianity are friendly competitors?

    Christianity viewed Islam as a heresy for the longest time, instead of an independent religion. That's a big obstacle.
  11. WI: Kennedy Lives and Tries to Settle Vietnam Through Nuetrality

    Well, any POD that would be feasible would have to be before Diem's assassination. Otherwise ARVN is going to be consumed with purging loyalists, leading to a lack of junior officers leaving them in such a fragile position. If RVN looks like it's still a somewhat functional anticommunist...
  12. Possibility of a NAZI invasion of U.S.

    The Atlantic is too big to traverse. The US Navy (along with any other nation in the Americas who's anti-Nazi's Navy) would intercept and sink any invasion force well before the shoreline would ever become visible.
  13. WI: Kennedy Lives and Tries to Settle Vietnam Through Nuetrality

    Well there you go! I never knew they were willing to offer neutralizing Cuba as a trade for Vietnam.
  14. Kuomitang wins the Chinese Civil War

    I agree for the most part. I think Chiang would be more of a Ferdinand Marcos type figure than a wonderful modernizer. No cultural revolution, and great leap forward is a huge plus. Also, this probably means no Simplified Chinese being adopted. The biggest issue is centralizing authority and...
  15. WI: Kennedy Lives and Tries to Settle Vietnam Through Nuetrality

    The thing is, given the de facto failure of Laos, would he even attempt such? I do know that the Soviets weren't really invested in Vietnam, and would have been content with a partition. It was only after escalation that they saw the use in backing Hanoi.
  16. AHC/WI: Capetian Holy Roman Emperor

    Exactly what the title says. Bonus points if the Holy Roman Emperor is also simultaneously King of France. Extra credit if it is someone other than Francis I.
  17. Why didn't Romans repeat Alexander's invasion of India?

    Not really. Rome/Byzantium spent 700 years warring with them and the Sassanids that replaced them. If Rome spent all of its military power on a Parthian campaign, they might conquer Persia. Hence the general reluctance to go further than influence Armenia. Rome knew in advance that Persia would...
  18. Could the Soviets have won in Vietnam?

    The benefit the Soviets have is that they can resort to repressive tactics that the United States would have difficulty doing. Diem was deposed because of his authoritarianism, as well as his clique's corruption. The Soviets would not have such reservations about using secret police, mass...
  19. [WI] Iran converts to Catholicism instead of Shiism

    Apostasy in Islam is equally as bad. This won't change much.
  20. [WI] Iran converts to Catholicism instead of Shiism

    Iran converting back to Zoroastrianism is far likelier than this. Even then, the majority of Persian Christians would be Nestorian, not Catholic.
Top