Search results

  1. AHC: The US with a high speed rail system as prolific as in East Asia or western Europe

    Maybe. In the end there may have to be an Amtrak-like entity of some sort, although private operators would likely still skim the cream of the passenger service. But keep in mind that were moving infrastructure maintenance costs to the public sector here (as with roads and airports) eliminates...
  2. AHC: The US with a high speed rail system as prolific as in East Asia or western Europe

    The basic idea was to have the railroads in the United States function as the other transportation modes do: private vehicles on public infrastructure. In the case of Amtrak, on most of its system, it's the other way around - public vehicles on private infrastructure - and it doesn't seem to...
  3. AHC: The US with a high speed rail system as prolific as in East Asia or western Europe

    I did a timeline once (it might be floating around on this site, IIRC) where a massive financial crash of the railroads (the New York Central, specifically) in the Great Depression prompted a government takeover, but of the infrastructure ONLY - the lines were in essence taken over by the...
  4. AHC: The US with a high speed rail system as prolific as in East Asia or western Europe

    This (and also the guy a few pages back who spoke about improving infrastructure, another great comment that got lost in all the back-and-forth). HSR gets the sexy headlines, but it's important to remember that those European HSR systems didn't occur in a vacuum. They were basically...
  5. AHC: The US with a high speed rail system as prolific as in East Asia or western Europe

    Well, what I don't understand in these threads is why the auto advocates absolutely insist on framing the issue as cars vs. trains in some sort of battle to the death, as if you can only have one or the other, and improved trains means that people aren't going to be allowed to drive or some such...
  6. A stronger Poland: what would be the effects on Hungary and the Balkans?

    Jeez, it can't be THAT boring an idea.... How about the effects on the Reformation?
  7. A stronger Poland: what would be the effects on Hungary and the Balkans?

    I'm not at all well versed in the High Middle Ages/Renaissance period, so I thought I'd pose this notion more as a question for the better versed. I'm reading a history book currently that briefly discusses Tenth Century Eastern Europe, and the author asserted (and it makes sense) that at that...
  8. Weirdest alternate history Hitler?

    From an old AH site: Crazy Adolf's Mile of Cars
  9. A Blunted Sickle - Thread II

    This point seems almost frivolous amid talk of geopolitics and military hardware, but: The St. Louis Browns of the American League in 1941 had one of the worst win-loss records in American major league baseball. For this reason, they were unable to attract anywhere near the number of paying...
  10. AHC: Reversed Beatles and Rolling Stones

    That was exactly the point. The idea was that he was literally a last minute replacement and an extremely poor fit for the Stones, thus helping hasten their breakup.
  11. What actors/celebrities would you save from an early death and why?

    Lester Bangs. Be interesting to see what he would have written in the era of MTV. Brian Jones. Martin Niemoller.
  12. Paul McCartney not busted - could it have saved John Lennon?

    John might have made the tracks at the same time as OTL, but held back from releasing them. I can see him saying something like, "They'll all be asking me 'Are you following Paul?' No, I'm not following him....I'll wait for him to get out of the fooking way." Maybe Double Fantasy ends up with...
  13. Paul McCartney not busted - could it have saved John Lennon?

    Here's a thought that hasn't occurred to me in the past, for you Beatle fans: In January 1980, Paul McCartney was notoriously arrested entering Japan with marijuana at the start of what was supposed to be a Wings tour. After spending about a week in jail, he was ultimately released and went...
  14. WI: John And George Surviving Beatles?

    Ringo was sickly as a child, so it's not hard to imagine him having something chronic that takes him out relatively young, especially coupled with his heavy drinking.
  15. Every railfan has his own version of Esch-Cummins/Ripley/ICC final plan of 1929

    Probably have the B&O buy the WM branch; the EL doesn't really need it, since the north end doesn't connect with the EL system anywhere.
  16. What if you didn't fly over "flyover country"?

    Actually, I live in Oregon. I do think it's disingenuous, though, to pretend there's no condescension in the "flyover" term - I've witnessed it personally. Again, though, we're drifting off topic; this is an issue better suited to Political Chat.
  17. What if you didn't fly over "flyover country"?

    OK, I asked you politely to refrain from commenting on my posts. Since you ignored that request, the same way you ignored the intent of my original post, I'm going to be more blunt: go away. If you ignore this request a third time, I will take appropriate action.
  18. What if you didn't fly over "flyover country"?

    Look...you do this EVERY time this topic comes up no matter the context. I didn"t ask you to discuss the POD, so you're not even on topic. Please refrain from commenting on any of my posts in the future.
Top