Search results

  1. Lenin Successor That ISN'T Stalin or Trotsky?

    I'm surprised nobody has even mentioned Bukharin. Of course, both Trotskiy and Bukharin had a lot of political baggage - Trotskiy from War Communism and his bloody-mindedness, Bukharin from the New Economic Policy and his foreign policy proposals. Of course Stalin managed to triangulate between...
  2. AHC: Conquistadors in 16th century Rus!

    Do Russian ones count? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yermak_Timofeyevich
  3. Avoid the Myth of the Dark Ages

    Basically, Justianian's ambition led to decades of war in Italy, and probably aggravated the war in Spain. Although it might not have devastated Africa as much as Italy and Spain.
  4. Avoid the Myth of the Dark Ages

    Byzantium? BYZANTIUM? They certainly made later late antiquity and the early middle ages a good deal darker than the periods might have been.
  5. Avoid the Myth of the Dark Ages

    So what point of departure could change that attitude? I suppose if paper-making reaches the west earlier, recorded history wouldn't depend so much on the price of papyrus, or [gah! expensive!] parchment, or on re-use of older sheets due to shortages. I suppose if Italy wasn't devastated by...
  6. Stalingrad like epic German defeat in 1915

    I think the Russian shell-shortage was at its worst in 1915, although increased production moderated it in 1916. I don't think the Russians could win many large battles until they sorted out their logistical problems. And they just didn't have nearly the heavy industrial base they needed to hold...
  7. Volgastan

    Except that they couldn't rely on Mediterranean agricultural techniques. If they are on the rivers, they will have water and arable land, but they are surrounded by [true] steppes. I think these colonies would depend on their relations with the neighboring pastoralists, and could easily fall...
  8. The Spartakiad

    I was imagining something different. Suppose that, after the battle of Mutina, many/more of the rebels from the north, including whole families, escape over the Alps, although Spartacus and most of the rebels from Italy turn south and are defeated as in our time line. What would it take for...
  9. 2 1/2 party system in US.

    But the distinction between libertarianism and classical liberalism goes back to the 1830s, even if the name only dates to the 1850s, and libertarians have generally avoided electoral politics. And in America, libertarianism was tied to abolitionism, and later to the labor movement, and suffered...
  10. Asking Otto/Byzzie guys: When did the Ottoman population first exceed the Byzantine?

    The late Byzantines and Ottomans are after my period, but there's some controversy between high count figures and low count figures for Roman and early Byzantine populations. I tend to favor a low count.
  11. 1941-42 Marshal Winter Demoted

    I figure that the better the Germans do in Typhoon, and the worse the Russians do in their winter counteroffensive, the better the Russians do by scaling back, if not cancelling, their spring offensives. And I second Usertron's comment that rail conversion is the real limit on the German offensive.
  12. How would you have handled Versailles?

    Which Republican faction? Half the Whites are monarchists. And none of the Whites are ready to restore Kerenskiy to power. And although some have paid lip-service to the Constituent Assembly, Kolchak's coup, and the dominant White opposition to socialism and land reform, make it clear that by...
  13. why didn't/don't urban native american cultures move particularly far north

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mississippian_culture The Mississipian Culture-Complex had a major city at Cahokia near what's now East St. Louis, and smaller cities farther north.
  14. How would you have handled Versailles?

    I wouldn't be in a position to dictate terms but I think this would be an improvement... 1. Screw the alliance with Serbia and split the war guilt clause. So say that the Black Hand, the Kaiser, and the German high command are jointly responsible for the war. 2. No reparations to the victors...
  15. How would you have handled Versailles?

    ... To help the Whites loot the countryside, slaughter the Jews, and restore the landlords to power? If anything, intervention only made the Civil War even worse. Of course, the Bolsheviks were hopelessly authoritarian by the end of 1918, but the Whites were too, and the great landlords had way...
  16. Challenge: Harold Godwinson cannonized as a saint in Anglican or Catholic churches

    IIRC, Harold was shipwrecked off Normandy years before, and William took Harold prisoner and coerced Harold to swear fealty. When Harold became king, William denounced Harold as an oath-breaker. Of course William would have invaded either way, but the papacy might not have the casus belli for...
  17. Challenge: No Abraham Religions

    What? Is there any evidence that early Germanic Christianity was homophobic? I mean most of the Gothic translation of the New Testament survives, and it's not homophobic. But at that time Roman Christianity was homophobic and transphobic.
  18. AHC: Gender-Equality in Christianity

    It doesn't look like Christianity-bashing to me. I think gender equality in early Christianity is always going to be at odds with the sharp inequalities in Roman society. But I think relative gender equality in some branches of medieval Christianity was more than possible. In the early 6th...
Top