Search results

  1. AH discussion: Greatest city of the Middle Age.

    It's a bit late in the period, but spare a thought for Venice? One of the mightiest trading hubs of the contemporary Mediterranean, highly defensible, and utterly beautiful.
  2. Sports Careers That Might Have Been

    As strange as it may sound, Oswald Mosley as champion fencer.
  3. Anglo-German War in 1899-1900 (Who Wins?)

    It's like how in CoD Modern Warfare II the Russians somehow fly into the US on helos without ever mentioning the navy. Then as now, populist techno thriller writers didn't know their stuff. Which is fine, because if they did they'd have a really bored audience.
  4. Anglo-German War in 1899-1900 (Who Wins?)

    Some of this thread sounds like the contemporary 'invasion fiction' people actually wrote in the early 20th century. The alliances there were no less ludicrous.
  5. AHC: Effective Calvary in WWI (Western Front)

    Somehow facilitate a return to the 'war of movement' before tanks are developed. That's the simple answer.
  6. Fallout Style Series by Other Countries?

    I'd argue that a British fallout would either be faux Edwardian (perceived as not as 'Dickensian' as the Victorian age, generally seen as the sun-drenched 'last gasp' of civilization before the lights went out in WWI; it even includes an arms race and invasion scares), or Agatha Christie time...
  7. Racism in the USSR

    Having read this article in the Guardian-how were race relations in the Soviet Union? This appears to paint a very positive picture...
  8. Our Land in the East - An Alternate End for the Raj

    Impausibility levels of this timeline: intensifying. Not leas that the USA is recognizing (and implicitly backing) a state which wants to newly conquer an Empire larger than that of Alexander the Great.
  9. Orwell lives and writes into the 1980s

    Orwell later in his career was increasingly suffering from ill health and paranoia. If he lives into the '80s, then he is unlikely to be suffering from these problems until the very end.
  10. Connery plays James Bond/007 until the 1990es

    He just wouldn't want to do it by then, that's the problem.
  11. PC/WI V-3 "Millipede" Gun used on UK ports pre OVERLORD

    To judge from what happened to the V-1s and V-2s, it gets fed dodgy targetting information by allied intel and shells empty countryside.
  12. Fire and Ice: A Barbarossa 1905 TL

    Interesting, but I confess to being somewhat sceptical about how quickly these advances can be sustained with pre WWI logistics. I know that OTL's Eastern Front was pretty fast moving (for WWI), but getting to more or less the same place as OTL seems somewhat implausible. There are no tanks, no...
  13. AHC: Conceptualize a Video or Board Game Based on the US War in Afghanistan

    A Distant Plain's a pretty good one for grand strategy in the Afghan War: https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/127518/distant-plain
  14. TLIAW: The Unreformed Kingdom

    This was fascinating, the attention to detail was incredible. Thank you for writing it.
  15. WI German navy destroys British navy in Jutland.

    I think that was more sentimental attachment; weren't they were the German Admiral's old squadron.
  16. Have arcane UK undergo either revolution or break up

    Is this the same UK as the one I live in here?
  17. Worst Ground Attack Aircraft Of WW2

    First thought of mine was the infamous Fairey Battle, but that did a reasonable job in other roles.
  18. Modern Military vs WWII military

    By late WWII, most armies would have PIATs, bazookas, panzerfausts etc-enough to at least take out the tank's tracks or slow it down, before we get to mines. So it isn't that easy. As for smaller armies, not every modern army has access to large stockpiles of tanks, cluster munitions etc...
  19. Modern Military vs WWII military

    If you take a smaller modern military, and put it against one of the superpowers of WWII, the former may run out of ammunition before the latter runs out of bodies, but it would still be bloody.
  20. The average Heer soldier vs the average Red Army soldier.

    Do you mean infantryman? Tankist? Artillery crew? The term 'soldier' is extremely broad, and includes many questions such as equipment, supply, training, and so on, which inevitably link into other factors.
Top