Search results

  1. marathag

    AHC/WI: Make South Vietnam win the Vietnam War with a POD after 1968

    If they have to worry about starving, then food should be priority #1, and not shipping munitions to the Iron Triangle via Laos and Cambodia in any great quantity Guys pushing bicycles carries a fraction as much as the trucks, which is why they bother to put pipelines from the North all the way...
  2. marathag

    AHC/WI: Make South Vietnam win the Vietnam War with a POD after 1968

    Like South Korea was in 1954 Most of the problem of '74-'75 was lack of fuel. Every other US client could maintain US gear, and M41 Tanks and F-5 Fighters were not high on the complexity scale in any case Problem One Solve Internal Security They had gotten that fairly well sorted out by time...
  3. marathag

    The Forge of Weyland

    If the French are flying say, twice the Sorties of OTL, they should experience at least the same ratio of Lost/damaged in Combat to enemy aircraft Lost/damaged in Combat from AAA Lost/damaged from Friendly Fire Lost/damaged from Accidents Enemy aircraft destroyed/damaged Enemy ground forces...
  4. marathag

    The Forge of Weyland

    Stalin should be pleased, his plan of ' Let's You and Him fight' is working with the Fascist and Colonial powers stuck in a grinding war against each other. Rather than a fast Knock Out of France, that not even the Germans really expected. What is the status of Operation Pike? OTL planning was...
  5. marathag

    What were the biggest tech and weapon mistakes and missed opportunities of Germany in ww2

    oil/water separation is trivial at the refinery level. That why salt domes are popular for storing oil
  6. marathag

    AHC/WI: Make South Vietnam win the Vietnam War with a POD after 1968

    The South was already one, but hardly perfect. But better than the North, that was not a republic, and isn't to this very day.
  7. marathag

    AHC/WI: Make South Vietnam win the Vietnam War with a POD after 1968

    Submission? No, just unable to receive any cargo from the WP or USSR. No cargo, no supplies to continue the fight in the south. By 1969, the Trail was truck based, not bicycles of 1963. Truck need fuel, and in 1969 onwards, that meant Haiphong as the only place that could recieve fuel in the...
  8. marathag

    AHC/WI: Make South Vietnam win the Vietnam War with a POD after 1968

    if no supplies are getting into the North, than there is nothing to be sent south by any method
  9. marathag

    Hang gliders in combat

    Navigation is a problem, and gliders aren't cheap, and are limited in the amount of gear carried. Next proble, using higher altitude to launch, or glider tugs, or even ground slingshot/catapult to get them into the air Probably easier using ground infiltration
  10. marathag

    What were the biggest tech and weapon mistakes and missed opportunities of Germany in ww2

    Oil molecules are almost entirely without a charge, they won't mix with charged water molecules that carry the sodium chloride Na+ and Cl- ions That's why Oil is used as a dielectric fluid Separate the Water, the Salt goes with it. Simple.
  11. marathag

    AHC/WI: Make South Vietnam win the Vietnam War with a POD after 1968

    Linebacker II Bombing and Pocket Money mining in 1968 after Tet. And don't stop the bombing keep hammering anything military related, as permitted by those relaxed RoEs North Vietnam can't supply the Troops in the South, Laos or Cambodia . Wait for a peace Treaty where the North vacates all...
  12. marathag

    Railroads Plausibility Check: Fold Rock Island and Milwaukee Road into Conrail

    there is a chance for one, but not both to be part of an expanded Conrail
  13. marathag

    Why so many nazis commit suicide at the end of WWII?

    Why? They know what they did, and were too cowardly to face justice
  14. marathag

    What were the biggest tech and weapon mistakes and missed opportunities of Germany in ww2

    But kills the trains and trucks needed to support them
  15. marathag

    What were the biggest tech and weapon mistakes and missed opportunities of Germany in ww2

    Not really. Put a hole thru the cylinder, it loses efficiency or stops, same for piston. Hole in the output line? Vents steam to the of volume of the cylinder, but without engine rotation that's all that goes, as demand pump is no longer turning either. Water and flame are cut back. Its a very...
  16. marathag

    Have Hudson Motors continue to be viable company up to the present.

    They screwed up in not refreshing the Hornet, pretty much unchanged since '48, and blew a wad of cash on the compact market, just as the sales were plummeting, like with the smaller Studebaker Champion and Henry J
  17. marathag

    What were the biggest tech and weapon mistakes and missed opportunities of Germany in ww2

    If basing from the Henschel flash boilers, not much would happen, same for the Sentinel, also a water tube style boiler. Fire-tube boilers are the ones that go *boom* when run dry or punctured
  18. marathag

    What were the biggest tech and weapon mistakes and missed opportunities of Germany in ww2

    Probably would have been fine for the originally planned 30 ton tank, but not for 45. Now the US got away with the Jumbos, but that was at limit of what the US would accept for reliability
  19. marathag

    Have Hudson Motors continue to be viable company up to the present.

    They could do Buick or Olds, Chrysler too, but not Lincoln as it was in the '50s.
  20. marathag

    WI: The Enterprise completes its five year mission (Star Trek survives for 5 seasons)

    Does the US still do emergency military shipments into Israel, and block direct help from the USSR for Egypt when they were on the ropes? Kissinger was the right man at the right place to have kept things from spinning out to WWIII
Top