Search results

  1. Place In the Sun: What If Italy Joined the Central Powers?

    It's pretty simple; the US, at least with a post-1865 POD, was always going to rise into a global superpower and, accordingly, is very, very overpowered in the HOI games. The 2ACW exists so as to nerf the United States in the Kaiserreich universe, but even with it, whichever faction wins out can...
  2. The Campaign Trail Game Has Returned.

    Has the new site fixed some of the issues of the old one? Particularly with the 1968 scenario and getting questions clearly meant for Wallace while playing as Nixon or Humphrey, or vice versa.
  3. Defeat in WWI: Will France go radical or not?

    A better model to look at, rather than the Kaiserreich radical model or other TLs having notNazi France, is how the Vichy regime justified itself and its ideology. While obviously adjacent to and collaborative with fascism, the Vichy ideology distinctly lacked either militarism or revanchism...
  4. What are some cliches in a Central Powers victory TL?

    The ones that come to mind: 1. The tendency to assume that every German postwar proposal/desire would have actually come to fruition, no matter how difficult it would have been to impose peace terms or hold on to conquered lands. We know the Allies couldn't get their most extreme demands (the...
  5. The Campaign Trail Game Has Returned.

    https://www.americanhistoryusa.com/campaign-trail/game/2225847 Great result with Ford on Normal; picked Baker and mixed moderate answers with a few appeals to the Reaganites (opposing Roe, the "reducing government" answer), won OTL Ford + OH, WI, PA, MS, HI. I think I could have won New York if...
  6. Miscellaneous >1900 (Alternate) History Thread

    It was extremely close, both in the popular vote and in the electoral margin (on the surface it looks like a decent-sized win for Kennedy, but a swing of 0.8% towards Nixon flips Hawaii, Illinois, Missouri, New Mexico, and the tipping point of New Jersey.
  7. WI McCain, In 2008, Had Picked Joe Lieberman Instead Of Sarah Palin As His VP?

    I honestly think he would have done worse. Palin turned off swing voters but was red meat for a conservative base who had been very cool on McCain during the primaries, and might have helped McCain with women and the "PUMA" vote (2008 had a smaller gender gap than the few elections before or...
  8. WI: Imperial Japan and Nazi Germany hated one another so much that they couldn't form a tenable alliance?

    Germany would continue to back China through arms sales and military advisors, though this might dry up after a European war starts. However, this won't fix US disapproval towards Japan's expansionism and I don't think it would lead to an Axis China either. Maybe the Sino-Japanese War remains...
  9. Miscellaneous >1900 (Alternate) History Thread

    Pop-culture POD--Seth MacFarlane doesn't miss his flight on 9/11/2001 and dies in the hijackings. Family Guy remembered as a cult hit cut tragically short while adult animation in the late 2000s and 2010s probably looks very different.
  10. Map Thread XX

    From a purely territorial standpoint yes, but ITTL they won't lose a literal third of their population and Warsaw will be at least partially intact.
  11. WI: Biden nominated in 1988

    As you might know (and without getting too into the specifics of his current presidency or his 2020 bid), Biden's first of three runs for the presidency occurred in 1988. As a youngish but experienced moderate with both foreign policy expertise and blue-collar bona-fides, he was formidable in...
  12. Hinckley shoots pimps instead of politicians

    Briefly becomes right-wing tabloid hero, probably gunned down unceremoniously at some point.
  13. Non-ideological Cold War

    You've just reinvented regular great power rivalries.
  14. Alternate Wikipedia Infoboxes VI (Do Not Post Current Politics or Political Figures Here)

    @King of the Uzbeks i assume a TL where the Republican Party remains dominant among Black voters?
  15. Idea for a surviving independent Manchuria/Manchukuo

    Probably a status like Irish IOTL, where few people speak it in daily life outside the boonies but where the state actively promotes it in the educational system.
  16. How accurate is the description of the Naval War in the Atlantic in Tom Clancy's "Red Storm Rising"?

    RSR for the most part lacks that. The Jack Ryan novels are where he gets politically charged through his self-insert fantasy character.
  17. Map Thread XX

    Sub-Saharan Africa is likely to bear the worst brunt of climate change later in the 21st century. I think that map is heavily simplified and perhaps a bit lazy (space-filling empire vibes) but I also don't necessarily think that the author was being intentionally racist.
  18. Why Did Clinton Do Better in the South than Gore?

    Obama did better in the coastal and urban South, because Virginia and North Carolina had radically demographically changed since 2000 + Obama's massive gains with college-educated white voters. But he did much worse in the rural/upland South, which had been the strongest states for both Clinton...
  19. Alternate Wikipedia Infoboxes VI (Do Not Post Current Politics or Political Figures Here)

    My inclination is that, like the counties in New Mexico and South Texas that had existing notable Hispanic populations after US annexation but well before mass immigration from Mexico, that the US states of Sonora, Chihuahua, and Baja California would be dominated by local patrons, some of whom...
  20. Fallen Eagle: The World After the Clinton Assassination - A Timeline

    Both were New Democrats who shared very similar policy positions--socially moderate-liberal, generally supportive of deregulation. Gore might be slightly more dovish than Clinton, though that might be butterflied given how this timeline started. However, US involvement in Afghanistan might...
Top