Search results

  1. Jews in the non-Christian world

    Depends on what happens instead of Christianity. A continuation of paganism/neo-paganism? A new religion? Presumably Islam is butterflied away. I think "Jews in a_______ World" would narrow it down a little.
  2. English language develops second person plural

    Sometimes used as a noun in Canada to refer to Americans: "A bunch of you-alls were in the pub...."
  3. Koxinga invading Taiwan without the Dutch

    What's his motivation? Is he still allied with the Ming?
  4. What if Europe stayed primarily united as an empire as China did?

    Funny, I was just reading an article in Aeon about that (not that I necessarily agree with everything written): https://aeon.co/essays/how-the-fall-of-the-roman-empire-paved-the-road-to-modernity
  5. Deaths from Irish potatoe famine mitigated

    More Thomas Malthus than God. Politicians, especially Whigs (Liberals) believed that population inexorably outstripped food production and that to intervene would make the situation worse by trying to keep alive unsustainable numbers.
  6. Dutch retain Taiwan

    Yeah, the Qing received Taiwan back from Koxinga's grandson, but didn't really want it. They offered it back to the Dutch, who didn't want it either. The Emperor was finally persuaded to occupy it by the argument that if it was left to its fate it would become a haven for Japanese and Chinese...
  7. WI: No Long Pause

    Pacific Islands would have reached population limits earlier; other than that, not much. Tahiti, Samoa, Tonga, and Hawaii may have been more united internally. I think the distances were too great for them to have much effect on each other.
  8. ARW US gets canada, loyalists stay put

    There were three groups of Loyalists that did not have the option of assimilation: the American Indians, notably Mohawks in New York, who had fought for the British; their white allies- people like the Butlers- who were accused of massacring settlers while fighting for the British; the black...
  9. Earlier Napoleon

    A thread in the pre-1900 forum reminded me of an old story in which a British traveller meets a French officer in the 1760s or 1770s(?). The officer, a Corsican, has all kinds of ideas for French military triumph, but his lowly birth prevents his advancement. Sound familiar? (I might have asked...
  10. WI Napoleonic France one century earlier

    OT, but decades ago there was a story in which Napoleon himself had been born earlier. A British traveller in the south of France meets an army officer from Corsica who had all sorts of ideas for making France militarily triumphant, but, alas, his lowly birth doomed him to a lifetime of...
  11. AHC: Make Canada more heavily populated

    Start global warming a few hundred years earlier. Though most ATLs would have to be some form of geological departure. and hence ruled out of this forum, an earlier contact leading to more time to recover from disease might work, if- emphasis on the if- the 'depopulation and reforestation of the...
  12. WI: Motorized road transport developed before rail

    Pavane, by Keith Roberts, especially the first story, "The Lady Margaret", has this. Large steam freight haulers, smaller private vehicles (aided by sails).
  13. What If Ottawa Not Chosen as Canada's National Capital?

    Geographically central, yeah, but even now over three-quarters of the population lives east of it.
  14. Could James II have retained his throne if he was pragmatic about religion?

    'If Paris is worth a mass, then London is worth skipping mass.'
  15. DBWI: Octavian August does not create a hereditary monarchy

    OT is dubious- if Rome after Augustus was not a hereditary monarchy it would eventually degenerate to a struggle between various generals for control. The Praetorian Guard, instead of being a byword for loyalty down to the present day, might even turn into "king-makers", offering the crown to...
  16. AHC colonize California starting in 1700

    I wrote a TL where Britain established the sea otter fur trade with China in 1742, resulting in them establishing forts and claiming the Pacific coast from Alaska to San Francisco, with eventual settlement being mostly by fleeing Loyalists (the Rebels take Canada and Nova Scotia during the ARW...
  17. Why didn't the Irish take advantage of the British fighting in the ARW to launch their own rebellion?

    If the Franco-Spanish Invasion of Britain had gone ahead in 1779 the Irish might have more successful.
  18. White-Minority Dominions outside of Africa?

    The question is would they exist outside if Africa, and I think to get that you'd have to have a sizable white population. Northern Rhodesia had 1500 whites to 800,000 Africans and 75,000 white settlers to 2 .5 million natives in 1961. You'd have to get a substantial settler population to get...
  19. WI: American Constitution Requires Military Service If You Want Citizenship

    Don't want to derail this discussion but the society of Starship Troopers was not controlled by an elite military caste; serving members of the armed forces didn't even have the vote.
  20. Question: what are some post industrial Inventions that are possible without industry?

    The flying shuttle https://www.antonhowes.com/blog/is-innovation-in-human-nature
Top