Search results

  1. Alcsentre Calanice

    After Stalingrad what could Germany do to hold off the USSR as long as possible?

    Would getting rid if Hitler actually improve Germany's military situation? While the German military commanders were masters of operation, they had little grasp of great strategy and might not even realize how bad the situation it until it's too late to change anything. I wonder how the...
  2. Alcsentre Calanice

    Relations between post-CCW KMT China and post-WWII Japan?

    The interesting thing will be that China will be an internationally recognized regional power from the start. It's part of the American sphere and has a seat on the UN Security Council. I'm pretty sure that the US will exert quite some pressure on Japan to resolve its conflicts with China...
  3. Alcsentre Calanice

    What other cultures could develop elite fighter social classes?

    Roman Republican cavalry was weak because, just like Athenian cavalry, it lacked the numbers under the Republican militia system. Also, Rome's early opponents, the tribes of the Italic mountains, fought them in mountainous terrain, so the Romans had no real incentive to develop a strong mobile...
  4. Alcsentre Calanice

    USSR "won" in the cold war

    Thank you for the information! So you would prefer the 2017 game over the 1991 one? But which one is more realistic!
  5. Alcsentre Calanice

    What scenario can bring peace after Poland falls but before France falls?

    If you're alluding to the Popular Front: The leftist government spend more money for defense than the previous conservative governments.
  6. Alcsentre Calanice

    USSR "won" in the cold war

    What do you think are the main differences between the original and the new game? I only played the game on steam.
  7. Alcsentre Calanice

    How would YOU invade Greece as Italy?

    Troy's final revenge!
  8. Alcsentre Calanice

    Trajan and Hadrian era historians? Can anyone give me some names?

    Suetonius lived under Hadrian. Tacitus, too, was a historian of the early 2nd century.
  9. Alcsentre Calanice

    AHC: President Rudy Giuliani

    Just hope that he doesn't decide to become his own lawyer.
  10. Alcsentre Calanice

    Thoughts on Manstein?

    Just because he polished up his performance in his memoirs (and also try to trick the readers into believing that he had nothing to do with war crimes) he wasn't a bad general. He was a pretty able commander, actually. The same goes for Rommel. He wasn't an unstoppable military genius, but he...
  11. Alcsentre Calanice

    What was life like as a Jew/Muslim in the Byzantine Empire

    Jews and Muslim generally had a better status than pagans or heretics. Heresies were banned in a general sense, and heretics subject to systematic persecution under certain emperors. Meanwhile, Jews enjoyed freedom of religion since Julius Caesar, and Muslims were protected against persecutions...
  12. Alcsentre Calanice

    What was life like as a Jew/Muslim in the Byzantine Empire

    At some point in Byzantine history there was a mosque in Constantinople, for tradesmen IIRC.
  13. Alcsentre Calanice

    If Germany and the Soviet Union go to war first..what does France/Britain do?

    But why should France and Britain intervene on the Soviet side in a German-Soviet war? As much as the WAllies dislike Hitler, they are anticommunists to the core, so I don't think they would want to sabotage the destruction of the Soviet Union.
  14. Alcsentre Calanice

    AHC Make modern Russia have the same territory as the Soviet union.

    He did continue Lenin's policy, but originally, he wanted to integrate all SSRs into the USSR. That plan was opposed by Lenin.
  15. Alcsentre Calanice

    Effects on American Power if it remains in these borders?

    To know how it happens is pretty important to speculate about what will happen. An unrelated example is a surviving Roman Empire: The Roman Empore of the 1st century surviving will have very different consequences compared to a survival of Constantine's state. The same goes for the scenario you...
  16. Alcsentre Calanice

    Discussion: How Would You End The Great War

    The German proposal involved a plebiscite in the west and also in Schleswig (the map doesn't mentions the latter one); it also wanted to reserve to Austria an option to join Germany.
  17. Alcsentre Calanice

    Discussion: How Would You End The Great War

    If Austria gets to decide which country it will belong to in the future, this right should be a fortiori granted to Elsaß-Lothringen and South Tyrol. Especially the latter will most likely decide to remain with Austria, as it has no ethnic or historic connection to Italy whatsoever. A...
  18. Alcsentre Calanice

    Names of British monarchs

    If he chooses to take on another regnal name, he will have been known as Charles longer than as George. Moreover, I wonder if George will stick if he rules under this name for a couple of years after decades of just being "Prince Charles."
  19. Alcsentre Calanice

    Peasants, enrich yourselves! A right opposition USSR TL.

    Enrichissez-vous par le travail et par l'épargne – worst defense of the limited franchise ever.
  20. Alcsentre Calanice

    WI: Frederick William IV accepts the Crown of Germany...then proceeds to re-establish the HRE

    Any sources for that? Only that he accepted the crown as part of the Erfurt Union project. The Union constitution, approved by the kings of Prussia, Hanover and Saxony in 1849 and confirmed by an elected German parliament in 1850, made the king of Prussia president of the union. There was no...
Top