Prologue: Before Six there was Five
Prologue:
.
A Decade of War and Peace
The parties emerged with two similar but different nominees. The Republican nominated businessman and former Democrat, Wendell Wilkie while the Democrats easily renominated President Franklin Delano Roosevelt but with a different VP with John Nance Garner being replaced with the Secretary of Agriculture and former Republican, Henry Agard Wallace. The two presidential hopefuls were similar as they were both interventionists in favor of supporting Britain, they supported the New Deal, both were New Yorkers and both were rumored adulterers. Even though the election was easily won by the ever popular Roosevelt.
But Wendell Wilkie, who was by then still 46 was seen as a potential future Republican leader and many, including his advisors knew this and forced the heavy drinker and smoker to drop most of his habits and to increase his publicity and this was achieved by himself and the help of his former opponent by him being sent to Britain as his personal representative and leading talks with Winston Churchill and he also went to the Soviet Union, China and North Africa during the wartime period.
[Snip]
Physically, he was a man slowly dying thanks to his bad health and this brought many concerns for the administration and for the President himself and so asked his estranged wife, Eleanor to rejoin him back with him.
Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt was a married couple but by the time of his rise into the presidency they had lived apart thanks to the formers many affairs and mistresses. But Franklin Roosevelt of 1942 was a different man, a sicker but wiser and older man and he decided to extend an olive branch to his estranged wife and offered her back to his life and to accompany him in his probably last years and Eleanor responded by asking that her husband leave any of his mistresses and if they still meet it would only be as friends or acquaintances, Roosevelt agreed to the request.
Most people would think that he would betray her later on but later records indicated that Franklin Roosevelt didn't do any sort of romantic relationship and stayed loyal to Eleanor because as historians would theorize that he was now dying and thought that he couldn't do it anymore. The effect was that even though they were still distant, they're relationship would improve and it even had a health improvement to the President as Churchill would write when he visited the Roosevelts in Hyde Park,
" The couple, which I had rarely seen together informally or even affectionately, now it seemed that they have become more close even if they haven't forgotten their past transgressions."
- The Decade of Miracle & Change by
Jack Kennedy
Jack Kennedy
Come 1944, the Democrats were rallying behind their leader for 12 years and it seemed that he would go to a convention which would nominate him easily but a problem emerged from one of the many factions of the party, the Southerners or more known as the Dixiecrats. They had been the most opposed to the New Deal and by 1944 there was a serious opposition in the South to oppose the President's leadership and they were led by one Harry Byrd, Senator from Virginia.
Byrd, being the leader of the Southern delegation was opposed to FDR'S policies on racial issues such as the Fair Employment and supporting African-American rights. He, in '44 was being convinced by his fellow Southerners to run for the Presidential nomination but he decided against it, knowing well of the President's popularity but an argument by one of the delegates convinced him to run for the VP nomination, knowing well that the next term would be the last for FDR. Most of the Deep South supported him with the exception of Tennessee, Texas and Florida who nominated one of their own as their choice. But Lady Fortuna had other plans as a week before the DNC, Senator Byrd was a victim in a car crash and was placed in coma for a month, this spelled madness for the Dixiecrats as they lost their standard bearer.
Senator Harry F. Byrd, known Segregationist
Another opposition came not against FDR but against his VP, Henry Agard Wallace. He was the son of a prominent Republican and Secretary of Agriculture, Harry Wallace. He had been a successful farmer in Iowa and so was tapped by the newly elected President Roosevelt into the same position as his father had occupied. By each passing year, Wallace proved to be an invaluable ally to Roosevelt as he passed the Agricultural Adjustment Act which gave aid to farmers by reducing surpluses with increased prices and his Social Conservation and Soil Allotment Act which payed the farmers to reduce their land and products. By 1936 he had changed his affiliation to a Democrat and was a leading surrogate for Roosevelt's campaign. He was so trusted by Roosevelt that he was named VP in 1940 and had been a yes man for Roosevelt during his tenure.
In 1944, Wallace was very popular in the eyes of the common man in the Democratic Party but viewed by the elites as a radical and incapable to lead as many thought that '44 would be a defining election for the Democrats as the President was declining in health even though he somewhat improved thanks to the presence of Eleanor. So came the Anti-Wallace movement which was led by Robert Hannagan, the DNC Chairman would push through other candidates for VP alongside the Dixiecrats and the Conservatives with names like Senator James Byrnes, a close ally of Roosevelt who was favored by the Dixiecrats and some Conservatives; Governor Prentice Cooper of Tennessee, favored by moderate Dixiecrats; Senator Robert S. Kerr, who was favored by moderates and even Speaker Rayburn, who was especially favored by the Texas delegates and most Conservatives but Rayburn later stated that he wasn't interested while others like Senators Truman & Barkley refused after seeing the disintegration of the Anti-Wallace Movement and the Dixiecrats splitting.
The Dixiecrats split from the rest of the Anti-Wallace Movement after a meeting with Roosevelt who was unconvinced by their arguments and many would think that he was influenced by the First Lady and most of the Progressive camp in his cabinet which later documents suggested was true.
The Anti-Wallace movement split with Hannagan and a few of his allies supporting the liberal Associate Justice William O. Douglas; Frank Walker, the Postmaster General and leading member of the movement would push through Truman while the Dixiecrats split into two camps, the more conservative members supporting Governor Cooper while the more moderate would support Senator Byrnes.
The convention was quick to renominate Roosevelt as it's nominee but the Vice Presidency was another whole monster as the factions fought against each other with Wallace easily winning the first ballot but still not enough for a win with Byrnes coming second, Truman third, Douglas fourth and Cooper coming last. Wallace later would commit to a plan which worked for a certain Republican candidate four years ago which was a flooding of supporters into the convention. There were chants of Wallace supporters but the opposition failed to combat the storm of the Wallace supporters and by the third ballot, Truman and Douglas had backed down and supported Wallace, easily winning him renomination for the Vice Presidency and many would thought, the next president.
A Victorious Henry Wallace Arrives
[Snip]
The Republican in 1944 was facing an internal problem as the party was split between the East Coast Moderates led by Thomas Dewey, West Coast Liberals with Earl Warren at its helm and the Midwest Conservatives with President's son Robert Taft leading the pack. But another Challenger came in the name of Wendell Wilkie. He changed the face of the Republican Party by changing their attitudes toward interventionist and containment against communism but he was perceived by many as an outsider and incapable and so many anti-Wilkie candidates emerged such as Tom Dewey, Harold Stassen and many more.
Taft had surprisingly not enter the primaries but instead endorsed his fellow Ohioan, Governor John W. Bricker but secretly them both and another leading conservative, Arthur Vandenberg wanted General Douglas MacArthur to be their nominee as he was conservative enough and was a popular war hero. Vandenberg had concluded that MacArthur couldn't win the nomination if he entered the primaries and only if a brokered convention happened and so the Conservatives quickly backed their monies into other candidates like Stassen, Bricker and even Wilkie as to make a brokered convention happened and it did happen.
Governor John W. Bricker of the Buckeye State
The first primary was the New Hampshire Primary where Wilkie had an advantage after he made speeches and campaigned heavily there and indeed he won but it was a hollow one with Dewey coming in a close second and surprisingly Stassen came in third. Wilkie's low performance broke his campaign and his only other victory in the primaries was the Maryland one but even there he was almost beaten by the unpledged delegates and so the 1940 nominee was essentially a non entity during the latter part of the primary.
The next main primary was the Wisconsin primary, the home state of General MacArthur and next state from Stassen's home state of Minnesota. There was an attempt to draft MacArthur into the primary but he declined after pressure from Senator Vandenberg and Taft to stick to the plan. So the election came down between two men, Harold Stassen with the overt support of the Conservatives and Tom Dewey and his moderates. In the end a close race ensued and Stassen won with Dewey's votes unexpectedly dropped with many considered that Stassen was being supported by the Conservatives with Bricker himself bowing out of the primary. The California and Oregon primaries was won by the Liberals, most southern states won by favorite sons and the rest was won by Dewey except Illinois which was closely won by Bricker.
As the Conservatives expected and wanted, the convention was wide open as none of the candidates had a majority with most of the delegates being divided by Dewey, Bricker and Stassen with Warren and Wilkie a distant trail. Then the Conservatives, as expected announced with General MacArthur that he would run for President and immediately Bricker and most of the Southern delegation endorsed him.
A Clearly Happy Douglas MacArthur
And so a concerned and shocked Tom Dewey would need a plan to fight against the resurging Conservatives and their standard bearer, General MacArthur. He, with his allies would ally themselves with Warren and his faction of liberals and even offering Warren the position of Vice President and the introduction of liberal reforms which Dewey agreed to. Many would later argue that if Dewey had clinched the nomination early on, Warren would've not accepted the position as he only accepted it to block the Conservatives from gaining the nomination.
Meanwhile another camp emerged with an unexpected alliance of Wilkie and Stassen with the aid of former Rep. Charles Christopherson who gave them the great plains delegation. They agreed on New Deal and Interventionism and knew they could succeed if only they worked together and so a deal was made if Wilkie was named as nominee, he would back Stassen as his running mate and Christopherson would be named as Secretary of State. The factions was set and the battle was started.
The first ballot was won by MacArthur with a large enough lead with Dewey coming second and Wilkie coming in third. The second ballot came and it was a relative shock with some of Wilkie's delegates being depleted as they either moved to Dewey or backed MacArthur. By the third ballot, Wilkie was out and MacArthur almost clinched the nomination with the support of most of Wilkie's Great Plains Delegates and by the fourth, seeing his support fade, Stassen would back MacArthur as he opposed the more liberal alliance of Dewey and so General Douglas MacArthur had won the Republican nomination.
MacArthur himself was still in the Pacific and didn't gave a speech but rather wrote a letter to the convention and it was read by his VP candidate, Senator Arthur Vandenberg.
"Fellow Americans! Fellow Republicans! Cheer not only for me but for all of us as you have chosen the right man for this party to lead itself into a new, bright future where we shall ride the wave of liberty and make this nation bright as the sun itself! We shall have victory not only in the election but by God I will win the war in the Pacific and defeat the Japanese Empire and bring upon it American Democracy!"
[Snip]
"Hurrah for America! Hurrah for General MacArthur!"
- Senator Arthur Vandenberg
- 1944 United States Presidential Election, Knowlepedia
President Roosevelt was undoubtedly angered by the prospect that his enemy was his own subordinate and requested that either MacArthur resigned from his commission or his face of the reconquest of the Philippines would be halted and the invasion of Formosa which was designed by Admiral Nimitz would go ahead and the thick headed MacArthur would choose neither and said that he was following a precedent of President Grant and Winfield Scott Hancock in which they didn't resigned their commission when they were nominated and Roosevelt pushed back by tightening control over MacArthur and effectively gave control over the theater to Admiral Nimitz. MacArthur would cry foul and would shout through the campaign season and to the general public that a conspiracy in which the Navy was undermining the land military and the proof was the rise of Nimitz.
The General himself didn't campaign and gave the job to his subordinates but he still have radio broadcasts as a way to campaign which by then was revolutionary. During the campaign, the Republicans argued that some of the New Deal was good use for the American public but not all of it was good like healthcare which was in the hands of the government and argued for smaller government and a less regulated economy as to increase free trade and free enterprise.
VP candidate Arthur Vandenberg, cheering General MacArthur as a wise and humble man
The Republicans aggressively attacked Roosevelt with the vice presidential candidate, Senator Vandenberg, during a speech in Oklahoma City would mock Roosevelt for a rumor that he took a US Warship to bring back his dog, Fala from Alaska saying that, "Roosevelt cares more for that dog than the success of our military in the Pacific!" And mocking his declining health which was stated that, "We don't want a dying man to be President! We want a healthy and vigorous man! And that man is Douglas MacArthur!"
President Roosevelt and VP Wallace, the President commenting over his health and commenting that,
"If I'm dead, this man's your next President!"
To counter these attacks, Roosevelt and VP Wallace would aggressively campaign and they would take many speeches reminding voters of the Hoover Presidency and the Ray of hope which was the New Deal. Them both also would make stump speeches about the successes of the war (both Roosevelt and Wallace dodged the Pacific theater as it was MacArthur territory and focused on European victories) and the necessary alliance with the Soviets as to calm down the more Conservative audience.
Wallace in particular had seemed to lower his opinion of the Soviet Union after he went there and was horrified after finding out that his visit was a sham after he found a hidden Gulag and was shocked to find many prisoners. Many historians would later point to the visit as to the lowered opinion of Wallace towards the Soviet Union after 1944 and this was echoed through his messages and even though many were still shedding positive light to them but it seems that it wasn't as positive as before because Wallace, during a speech in New York would dub the Soviets as "Devils disguised as Angels"
It seemed that the Roosevelt tactics were working as many people were still supportive of their president and many moderates to mild conservatives even gave more liking to the previously radical and eccentric VP, increasing their polling numbers even more but then the invasion of Palau Islands in August and the landings in Mindanao by October where MacArthur came back triumphantly to the land in which he promised to return and suddenly the polling numbers fell and MacArthur's rose and so Roosevelt needed another plan and then came the October surprise in the mold of a Republican congressman, Arthur Miller.
A Very Triumphant MacArthur in the Philippines
The MacArthur-Miller letter broke the campaign as it destroyed any chances for MacArthur to gain any votes from the more New Deale supportive side of the Republican Party and it showed that the candidate was allowing himself to support an unpopular thinking only because of his ego. By then, Roosevelt gained momentum and slide easily to reelection, especially with the victories not only in the Pacific but in Europe bringing another landslide for the President.
[Snip]
The defeated presidential nominee of 1940 had congratulated his frenemy on another victory but as Roosevelt was campaigning, he had developed a plan to unite the liberals and moderates of both parties and he had even contacted his fellow moderate and liberal Republicans, who were disheartened by the conservative shift in the Republicans and many stayed home but he offered them a new platform, a new party in which they would and will be triumphant, a Liberal Party in which they would shine in.
- The Birth of the Sixth Party System, by
Newt Gingrich
Newt Gingrich
Last edited: