The following is the transcript of a segment of the PBS News America Votes broadcast, originally televised on election night, November 5, 2019.
ERIKA LÉPINE: “We finally have enough votes in to make a projection. Folks, it’s no surprise given what we’ve seen so far, but PBS News officially projects a Social Conservative majority. If these results hold up, this will be the first government formed by a right-wing party since 2002, and Robert Dayal will become the first American president of Indian descent. Since the right wing last held power, we’ve seen two Whig governments, a Farmer-Labor government, a Whig-Farmer-Labor coalition, a time when the Movement was the official opposition, and an election where the conservative vote was split three ways. The levers of power have eluded them through the years, but now, they've taken back power, and what a way to do it!”
LUIS WASHINGTON: “In just a few minutes, Dayal will address his supporters at the Social Conservative HQ in New York. But in the meantime, let’s talk about these results coming in. We have only about a third of the votes counted right now, but we’re already seeing battle lines for tonight being drawn. The Social Conservatives are well ahead of all other parties, while the Whigs and Farmer-Labor are neck-and-neck.”
LÉPINE: “I think it’s safe to say at this point in the night it’s going to be a fight for second place. This election started when the FLP broke off from the coalition, and the government lost a vote of no confidence. President Cunningham might go down in history for leading her party to a historic loss and a third place result. There's no good way this vote ends up for the Whigs, but avoiding that outcome would go a long way to shore up rank-and-file morale."
WASHINGTON: "Even if the Whigs end up with more seats than Farmer-Labor, I still don't see Cunningham having much of a future in the party."
LÉPINE: "I'll be honest, me neither. I suspect she'll be forced to resign as a first step to rebuilding."
WASHINGTON: "And on the other hand, it's a pretty good night for Farmer-Labor. If they outgain the Whigs and form the official opposition, this'll be their best result since 2009."
LÉPINE: "Hard to beat their performance in '09, but they can't not be satisfied looking at the results tonight. Their biggest challenge, I think, is going to be holding onto their seats come next election. A few more elections like this for them and they might have a shot at forming government!"
WASHINGTON: "That's been the goal, but now, let's talk a little bit about the Movement's performance tonight. They're losing most of their key districts in the Caribbean, but they're holding strong in the Canadas and Louisiana. I know Movement supporters haven’t been very optimistic about this election, but their losses seem imbalanced. They're losing Spanish speakers and retaining French speakers. Any idea why that is?”
LÉPINE: “You know, the Social Conservatives have spent quite a lot of effort trying to win over Spanish-speaking voters, and I think it's paying off. The Movement's taken a left-wing turn under Salazar and Gaulin. That message might work in the Canadas, but it leaves them open in the Caribbean and the Southwest."
WASHINGTON: "It was smart for the Social Conservatives to recognize that."
LÉPINE: "I know state-by-state polls are spotty at best, but they showed that the Movement was vulnerable. Plus, the Social Conservatives have always had a pretty strong foundation in Spanish-speaking regions, which helped clue them in on that line of attack."
WASHINGTON: “You know, the Social Conservatives have also had some trouble on their right flank. The United Democratic Party has campaigned hard against Dayal’s “Unite the Right” message, but it doesn’t look like they’ll be seriously threatening him. The UDP has three seats right now, two from West Florida and one from North Carolina. Not a bad night for them so far, but certainly not a great one.”
LÉPINE: “I don’t think there’s much of an appetite for even more right-wing splintering."
WASHINGTON: "Especially since the UDP is quite a bit to the right of the general public."
LÉPINE: "They’ll win seats off white identity politics and opposing open borders and free trade, but they won't do much beyond that. They’ll probably end up in 5th or 6th place, depending on if the Greens turn things around.”
WASHINGTON: “And it looks like Robert Dayal has emerged to address the crowd. Let’s pan over.”