alternatehistory.com
Benito Mussolini: The Diminished Duce (1945-64)
Benito Mussolini: The Diminished Duce (1945-64)
Chamberlain (L), Mussolini (C), Balbo (second from right) and Ciano (FR) in 1938
Postwar:
Although Italy only had its’ former colonies restored in the San Francisco Treaty, there was a sense of relief and resignationa bout the outcome. Yes, there were almost 500,000 Italian casualties from the Second Great War and no - Italy hadn’t really gained anything other than a few Greek islands, Malta and *Albania* but it could’ve been worse. Mussolini’s prestige had taken a beating, but he got credit for resisting German entreaties for widening Italy’s involvement in the Eastern Front.
Besides - what was the alternative? Between the reds in France and the reds in Russia and the reds in the Balkans what else could Italy have done? America was far away. So the Italian public fell behind fascism - not out of any great enthusiasm - but out of a sense of weary resignation.
But even if the public did, the elites were not as compliant. Yes - fascism was seen as necessary, but Mussolini’s powers were vastly reduced. Although the Italian regime had proclaimed Balbo dead, he had miraculously come back to life from the powers of not actually being dead. This set of a round of recriminations in the Fascist Grand Council with Ciano leading the opposition to weaken Mussolini.
The outcome was the creation of a Triumverate between Balbo, Mussolini and Ciano. Mussolini still had entrenched support among the grandees of fascism and also (surprisingly) from the wider population. He was kept in his rule of Duce while Balbo becamse the head of the Fascist Grand Council and Ciano became Prime Minister.
While the Triumverate had their many divisions - Ciano wanted a closer relationship with the Anglos, Balbo wanted an independent foreign policy and Mussolini wanted to stay in the Axis. Ciano wanted a more open, slightly more liberalized economy, Balbo wanted an increase to Autarky and Mussolini was in favour of the status quo. One area they did agree on was the need to bring the colonies back into line.
Ethiopian troops armed with mislaid Italian equipment captured by Entente forces
The subjugation wars:
Although Libya and Ethiopia had been returned to Italian administration, departing Entente troops clumsily mislaid tons of arms and ammunition and when they had new arms and ammunition allocated to replaces these - they also mislaid them. The Kingdom of Libya and the Empire of Ethiopia thus were proclaimed before Italy could return and she had to fight a long, bloody war to reclaim them. In addition - a steady trickle of supplies from the Entente and Comintern kept up the insurgency.
But while King Idris in Libya and Emperor Sailesee had troops that were brave, determined and and had the home field advantage, Italy had tanks and planes and poison gas. Italy also had support from her German ally who wanted to keep some troops doing military exercises.
Although Libya and Ethipia still has nationalist guerillas operating till today, Libya was formally subdued in 1948 with Ethiopia following two years later in 1950. But even though the subjugation was succesful, Italy had inherited ruined colonies with restive populations and was looking at decades of debt from the war effort.
Black gold:
But the follow up drilling to initial explorations done in the 1940s would dramatically change Italy’s fortune. Oil was struck in 1954 and by 1960 Libya was in the middle of an oil boom - as was the Italian economy as the supercharged exports fed domestic handouts and consumption. Italy was open for business - being the primary exporter of Oil to the Third Reich - but also now the British Empire which now needed new sources of oil. The Axis demand for oil intensified after Mao’s election to the Presidency and the closing off of the Persian oil markets to the Axis was particularly good for Italy which now became the primary source of oil for the Axis powers.
Realignment:
Italy was having to navigate it’s way in a changing world. The entry of the British into the Axis and the withdrawal of the Chinese meant that a new world order was being formed. Between the ‘anti-colonial powers’ of France, China and the Soviet Union (just don’t tell that to the central Asians, Baltic Germans, eastern Europeans or the Caucus peoples) and the ‘colonial powers’ of Japan, Britain, Italy and Germany. But this was still an interregnum period where sentimental ties with China between the pact of steel members kept China from being fully part of the Communist/Anti-Colonial block.
Korean People's Army Troops marching across Manchuria into North Korea where a worker's uprising had taken some cities in the North.
Korean War:
Nowhere was the dilemma of ‘realignment’ more confusingly demonstrated than the Korean War. Although Mao’s China had been steadily drifting towards the Comintern, the joint support of the USSR, China, France, Vietnam and other left-leaning powers for the Korean People’s Army’s uprising in Korea and ‘invasion’ (if you ask a South Korean) or ‘liberation’ (if you ask a North Korean) on 25 June 1960 spooked anti-communists throughout the world. Adding to this confusion was the fact that technically, although China was no longer part of the Pact of Steel, China had recently renewed a multi-lateral defence pact with Italy and Germany. However, Japan was applying to be a member of the Pact of Steel. Added to this foreign policy confusion was economic and domestic considerations. As the Chinese economy recovered from it’s slump the rising wave of Chinese middle class and elites increased their demand for fine Italian luxury goods. But China was also fueling leftist agitation within Ethiopia and Libya so there was genuinely condition.
The confusion of the various powers was illustrated when a resolution came before the UN to condemn the ‘invasion’ of Korea. The Chinese, French and Soviet delegations walked out in protest - leaving them unable to vote against the motion. But it meant that the Japanese proposal passed with British and American support while Italians and Germans abstained. By the time the Chinese delegation realized their mistake - the motion had already passed and there was a UN Force approved for deployment for Korea.
The predictable wave of denunciation from the Chinese, French and Soviet delegations around western imperialism came, but as did a concrete call for a counter-UN force - the “International Brigades.” This was an open call for any power to send forth volunteers to liberate Korea against Japanese rule.
Italy’s response was nuanced - she decided to send troops to aid both the Empire of Korea and the People’s Republic of Korea. A ‘blackshirt’ volunteer division was planned to aid the Empire of Korea as part of the UN Task Force. Italy asked for volunteers among the most staunchest and fiercest anti-communists. When there weren’t enough volunteers, hardened criminals were recruited to fill the ranks. Conversely, a ‘redshirt’ volunteer division was planned - and the response of this was more enthusiastic - among the ranks of political prisoners and those on internal exile as well as students and idealists.
Korea was a strange war. Chinese, Soviet, Mexican French, New Zealand volunteers would fight alongside the Korean People’s Army alongside their ideological enemies - in the Italian Garibaldi Division and in the regular Heer forces that were deployed to Korea. They would fight against Japanese, American, British, Australian and various Latin American troops. The Spanish Federation would have troops also fighting on both sides, sometimes the same state sent troops to both sides, sometimes it was the same city.
During the Korean War, Italian forces gave themselves a good accounting. The Blackshirt division fought with a combination of ideological zeal and the desperation of doomed men who would be given pardons if they returned and the Garibaldi division fought with the shining idealism of international brigaders.
The Blackshirt division covered themselves in glory at Daegu on April 26 1961, blunting the advance of Tukachevksy’s T-62 tanks with nothing but their panzerfausts and 90s mounted on trucks and allowing the UN Forces time to regroup and counter-attack.
It was the Garibaldi division that held off the might of the American X Corps as they landed in Inchon in 1962 and delayed them for long enough that the People’s Army could counter-attack with the 1st Panzer Division. The subsequent destruction of the X Corps in the “Christmas Surrender” led famously to Defense Secretary Eisenhower’s resignation as he leaked plans by the American President to escalate the conflict through nuclear weapons. The outcry of this forced him to back down and ultimately led to the ceasefire on 27 July 1963 which divided Korea along the Han and Bukhan rivers.
But the repercussion of the war lasted beyond just the effects of the war. Close to 20,000 Italian troops had fought side by side besides the ‘red hordes’ and found that they were just human beings like them. Even the 20,000 Blackshirts that fought against the Reds developed a respect for their ferocity. In trying to position herself strategically, Mussolini had unwittingly laid down a severe challenge for the fascist regime in the future.
Mussolini would not live to see this day. As the American voters swept in President Eisenhower on November 3 1964, Mussolini would breath his last. He was the last of the contemporary of Hitler, Chiang and Stalin and clung onto power for the longest - with nearly 50 years in power.
Chamberlain (L), Mussolini (C), Balbo (second from right) and Ciano (FR) in 1938
Postwar:
Although Italy only had its’ former colonies restored in the San Francisco Treaty, there was a sense of relief and resignationa bout the outcome. Yes, there were almost 500,000 Italian casualties from the Second Great War and no - Italy hadn’t really gained anything other than a few Greek islands, Malta and *Albania* but it could’ve been worse. Mussolini’s prestige had taken a beating, but he got credit for resisting German entreaties for widening Italy’s involvement in the Eastern Front.
Besides - what was the alternative? Between the reds in France and the reds in Russia and the reds in the Balkans what else could Italy have done? America was far away. So the Italian public fell behind fascism - not out of any great enthusiasm - but out of a sense of weary resignation.
But even if the public did, the elites were not as compliant. Yes - fascism was seen as necessary, but Mussolini’s powers were vastly reduced. Although the Italian regime had proclaimed Balbo dead, he had miraculously come back to life from the powers of not actually being dead. This set of a round of recriminations in the Fascist Grand Council with Ciano leading the opposition to weaken Mussolini.
The outcome was the creation of a Triumverate between Balbo, Mussolini and Ciano. Mussolini still had entrenched support among the grandees of fascism and also (surprisingly) from the wider population. He was kept in his rule of Duce while Balbo becamse the head of the Fascist Grand Council and Ciano became Prime Minister.
While the Triumverate had their many divisions - Ciano wanted a closer relationship with the Anglos, Balbo wanted an independent foreign policy and Mussolini wanted to stay in the Axis. Ciano wanted a more open, slightly more liberalized economy, Balbo wanted an increase to Autarky and Mussolini was in favour of the status quo. One area they did agree on was the need to bring the colonies back into line.
Ethiopian troops armed with mislaid Italian equipment captured by Entente forces
The subjugation wars:
Although Libya and Ethiopia had been returned to Italian administration, departing Entente troops clumsily mislaid tons of arms and ammunition and when they had new arms and ammunition allocated to replaces these - they also mislaid them. The Kingdom of Libya and the Empire of Ethiopia thus were proclaimed before Italy could return and she had to fight a long, bloody war to reclaim them. In addition - a steady trickle of supplies from the Entente and Comintern kept up the insurgency.
But while King Idris in Libya and Emperor Sailesee had troops that were brave, determined and and had the home field advantage, Italy had tanks and planes and poison gas. Italy also had support from her German ally who wanted to keep some troops doing military exercises.
Although Libya and Ethipia still has nationalist guerillas operating till today, Libya was formally subdued in 1948 with Ethiopia following two years later in 1950. But even though the subjugation was succesful, Italy had inherited ruined colonies with restive populations and was looking at decades of debt from the war effort.
Black gold:
But the follow up drilling to initial explorations done in the 1940s would dramatically change Italy’s fortune. Oil was struck in 1954 and by 1960 Libya was in the middle of an oil boom - as was the Italian economy as the supercharged exports fed domestic handouts and consumption. Italy was open for business - being the primary exporter of Oil to the Third Reich - but also now the British Empire which now needed new sources of oil. The Axis demand for oil intensified after Mao’s election to the Presidency and the closing off of the Persian oil markets to the Axis was particularly good for Italy which now became the primary source of oil for the Axis powers.
Realignment:
Italy was having to navigate it’s way in a changing world. The entry of the British into the Axis and the withdrawal of the Chinese meant that a new world order was being formed. Between the ‘anti-colonial powers’ of France, China and the Soviet Union (just don’t tell that to the central Asians, Baltic Germans, eastern Europeans or the Caucus peoples) and the ‘colonial powers’ of Japan, Britain, Italy and Germany. But this was still an interregnum period where sentimental ties with China between the pact of steel members kept China from being fully part of the Communist/Anti-Colonial block.
Korean People's Army Troops marching across Manchuria into North Korea where a worker's uprising had taken some cities in the North.
Korean War:
Nowhere was the dilemma of ‘realignment’ more confusingly demonstrated than the Korean War. Although Mao’s China had been steadily drifting towards the Comintern, the joint support of the USSR, China, France, Vietnam and other left-leaning powers for the Korean People’s Army’s uprising in Korea and ‘invasion’ (if you ask a South Korean) or ‘liberation’ (if you ask a North Korean) on 25 June 1960 spooked anti-communists throughout the world. Adding to this confusion was the fact that technically, although China was no longer part of the Pact of Steel, China had recently renewed a multi-lateral defence pact with Italy and Germany. However, Japan was applying to be a member of the Pact of Steel. Added to this foreign policy confusion was economic and domestic considerations. As the Chinese economy recovered from it’s slump the rising wave of Chinese middle class and elites increased their demand for fine Italian luxury goods. But China was also fueling leftist agitation within Ethiopia and Libya so there was genuinely condition.
The confusion of the various powers was illustrated when a resolution came before the UN to condemn the ‘invasion’ of Korea. The Chinese, French and Soviet delegations walked out in protest - leaving them unable to vote against the motion. But it meant that the Japanese proposal passed with British and American support while Italians and Germans abstained. By the time the Chinese delegation realized their mistake - the motion had already passed and there was a UN Force approved for deployment for Korea.
The predictable wave of denunciation from the Chinese, French and Soviet delegations around western imperialism came, but as did a concrete call for a counter-UN force - the “International Brigades.” This was an open call for any power to send forth volunteers to liberate Korea against Japanese rule.
Italy’s response was nuanced - she decided to send troops to aid both the Empire of Korea and the People’s Republic of Korea. A ‘blackshirt’ volunteer division was planned to aid the Empire of Korea as part of the UN Task Force. Italy asked for volunteers among the most staunchest and fiercest anti-communists. When there weren’t enough volunteers, hardened criminals were recruited to fill the ranks. Conversely, a ‘redshirt’ volunteer division was planned - and the response of this was more enthusiastic - among the ranks of political prisoners and those on internal exile as well as students and idealists.
Korea was a strange war. Chinese, Soviet, Mexican French, New Zealand volunteers would fight alongside the Korean People’s Army alongside their ideological enemies - in the Italian Garibaldi Division and in the regular Heer forces that were deployed to Korea. They would fight against Japanese, American, British, Australian and various Latin American troops. The Spanish Federation would have troops also fighting on both sides, sometimes the same state sent troops to both sides, sometimes it was the same city.
During the Korean War, Italian forces gave themselves a good accounting. The Blackshirt division fought with a combination of ideological zeal and the desperation of doomed men who would be given pardons if they returned and the Garibaldi division fought with the shining idealism of international brigaders.
The Blackshirt division covered themselves in glory at Daegu on April 26 1961, blunting the advance of Tukachevksy’s T-62 tanks with nothing but their panzerfausts and 90s mounted on trucks and allowing the UN Forces time to regroup and counter-attack.
It was the Garibaldi division that held off the might of the American X Corps as they landed in Inchon in 1962 and delayed them for long enough that the People’s Army could counter-attack with the 1st Panzer Division. The subsequent destruction of the X Corps in the “Christmas Surrender” led famously to Defense Secretary Eisenhower’s resignation as he leaked plans by the American President to escalate the conflict through nuclear weapons. The outcry of this forced him to back down and ultimately led to the ceasefire on 27 July 1963 which divided Korea along the Han and Bukhan rivers.
But the repercussion of the war lasted beyond just the effects of the war. Close to 20,000 Italian troops had fought side by side besides the ‘red hordes’ and found that they were just human beings like them. Even the 20,000 Blackshirts that fought against the Reds developed a respect for their ferocity. In trying to position herself strategically, Mussolini had unwittingly laid down a severe challenge for the fascist regime in the future.
Mussolini would not live to see this day. As the American voters swept in President Eisenhower on November 3 1964, Mussolini would breath his last. He was the last of the contemporary of Hitler, Chiang and Stalin and clung onto power for the longest - with nearly 50 years in power.
- CCA
- Word Count: 1.6k