alternatehistory.com

Details are intentionally sparse because I may be interested in making this into a full-fledged timeline.
The first underlined name in any given election notes the individual elected President, the second notes the Vice President. This is important to note due to House and Senate contingent elections and the confusion of the 1796 election.
Any candidate who received electoral votes is listed, so I apologize for the mass of names in the first three elections before things got ironed out. It's just OTL though, so feel free to skip over those.
Candidates with (parenthesis and italics) garnered a significant amount of the popular vote, but did not receive electoral votes.
(+) follows tickets which saw another candidate of the same party receive votes for Vice President, truncated for simplicity's sake.

Parties represented are keyed below. Colors are coordinated to attempt to show relations between ideological platforms, where possible.

Non-Partisan
Federalist Party
Anti-Federalist Party
Republican Party (first), aka. Democratic-Republican Party
Democratic Party
National Republican/Anti-Jackson Party
National Republican/Whig Party
Nullifier Party
Anti-Masonic Party
Liberty Party
Republican Party (second)
Independent Party
Populist Party


1788
George Washington
John Adams
John Jay
Robert Harrison
John Ruteledge
John Hancock
George Clinton
Samuel Huntington
John Milton
James Armstrong
Benjamin Lincoln
Edward Telfair

1792
George Washington
John Adams
George Clinton
Thomas Jefferson
Aaron Burr

1796
John Adams
Thomas Jefferson
Thomas Pinckney
Aaron Burr
Samuel Adams
Oliver Ellsworth
George Clinton
John Jay
James Iredell
George Washington
John Henry
Samuel Johnson
Charles Pinckney

1800
Thomas Jefferson & Aaron Burr
John Adams & Charles Pinckney
John Jay

1804
Thomas Jefferson & George Clinton
Charles Pinckney & Rufus King

1808
James Madison & George Clinton
Charles Pinckney & Rufus King

1812
James Madison & Elbridge Gerry
DeWitt Clinton & Jared Ingersoll
Rufus King & Jared Ingersoll

1816
James Monroe & Daniel Tompkins
Rufus King & John E Howard (+)

1820
James Monroe & Daniel Tompkins
John Q Adams & Daniel Tompkins

1824
Andrew Jackson & John C Calhoun (+)
John Q Adams & John C Calhoun (+)
William H Crawford & Nathaniel Macon
Henry Clay & Nathan Sanford
House contingent election:
John Q Adams
Andrew Jackson
William H Crawford

1828
Andrew Jackson & John C Calhoun (+)
John Q Adams & Richard Rush

1832
Andrew Jackson & Martin Van Buren
Henry Clay & John Sergeant
John Floyd & Henry Lee
William Wirt & Amos Ellmaker

1836
Martin Van Buren & Richard Johnson
William H Harrison & Francis Granger
Hugh White & John Tyler
Daniel Webster & Francis Granger
Willie P Mangum & John Tyler
Senate contingent election:
Richard Johnson
Francis Granger

1840
Martin Van Buren & James K Polk (+)
William H Harrison & John Tyler

1844
Martin Van Buren & Robert J Walker
Henry Clay & Theodore Frelinghuysen
(James Birney & Thomas Morris)

1848
Winfield Scott & John Morehead
James K Polk & Nathan Clifford
(John P Hale & Leicester King)

1852
Millard Fillmore & John M Clayton
Stephen Douglas & William R King
(John P Hale & George W Julian)

1856
Lewis Cass & William Marcy
John McLean & William Johnston
Millard Fillmore & John M Clayton (+)

1860
Salmon Chase & Henry W Davis
Stephen Douglas & James Pearce

1864
Salmon Chase & Ira Harris
Stanley Matthews & Reverdy Johnson

1868
Schuyler Colfax & William Kelley
James Buchanan & Augustus Dodge

1872
Schuyler Colfax & William Kelley
Lucius Robinson & Thomas Hendricks

1876
Benjamin Bristow & Alfred Terry lost popular vote
Lucius Robinson & Allen Thurmond
(Samuel Kirkwood & Barzillai Chambers)

1880
William Rosecrans & Thomas Bayard
Benjamin Bristow & David Davis

1884
Thomas Bayard & Edville Evans
George Boutwell & John Logan
Benjamin F Butler & Solon Chase

1888
Walter Q Gresham & Levi Morton
Thomas Bayard & Edville Evans

1892
William Cleveland & Elisha Bartley
Walter Q Gresham & Levi Morton
Benjamin F Butler & James Weaver

1896
William Cleveland & Elisha Bartley
Alexander Ramsey & Ebenezer Hoar
(James Weaver & Benajah South)

1900
Bruce Lowrie & James Gaither
William Cleveland & Elisha Bartley