alternatehistory.com

Operation Christian Freedom

Explanation: There's a conspiracy that Thomas Harens was actually a stalking horse for John Kerry in the 2004 election in an attempt to sabotage George Bush in Minnesota. Let's assume that this was legitimate and that Kerry takes it up to 11.

2001-2005: George W. Bush/Dick Cheney (Republican)
2000: Al Gore/Joe Liebermann (Democratic) , Ralph Nader/Winona LaDuke (Green)
2005-2008: John Kerry/John Edwards (Democratic)
2004: George W. Bush/Dick Cheney (Republican) , Thomas Harens/Virgil Goode (Christian Freedom)
2008-2009: John Kerry/Vacant (Democratic)
2009-2013: John Kerry/Barack Obama (Democratic)
2008: Mitt Romney/Lindsey Graham (Republican) , Virgil Goode/Duncan Hunter (Christian Freedom)
2013-0000: Barack Obama/Hillary Clinton (Democratic)
2012: Chris Christie/Kelly Ayotte (Republican) , Tom Tancredo/Michelle Bachmann (Christian Freedom)
2016: Ted Cruz/Phil Bryant (Christian Freedom) , Jeb Bush/Susan Collins (Republican)