alternatehistory.com

So this requires a lot of explanation beforehand - this list is actually a write-up of an utterly bizarre timeline called 'The Bold Frontier (j.f.k. lives)' by a random banned member.

It is literally the definition of 'shitty, poorly formatted timeline' - the POD is JFK lives and the content aside from the listing of elections is almost entirely incomprehensible or batshit crazy.
But nearly all of the presidents in it are really inspired, original picks - to the point that it's actually disconcerting that someone who seems functionally illiterate could make something even remotely this well-thought. Seriously though - it makes absolutely no sense and you should check it out.
Without further ado,


The Bold Frontier

1961-1965: John F. Kennedy / Lyndon B. Johnson (Democratic)
1960: Richard M. Nixon / Henry Cabot Lodge Jr. (Republican)
1965-1969: John F. Kennedy / Albert A. Gore (Democratic)
1964: Barry M. Goldwater / Francis E. Dorn (Republican)
1969-1973: Charles H. Percy / Roman L. Hruska (Republican)
1968: Hubert H. Humphrey II / J. Terry Sanford (Democratic) George C. Wallace, Jr. / Curtis E. LeMay (American Independent)
1973-1976: Hubert H. Humphrey II / T. LeRoy Collins (Democratic)
1972: Charles H. Percy / Roman L. Hruska (Republican)
1976-1977: T. LeRoy Collins / vacant (Democratic)
1977-1981: T. LeRoy Collins / Edmund S. Muskie (Democratic)
1976: Robert J. Dole / William E. Miller (Republican)
1981-1989: Howard H. Baker, Jr. / Paul D. Laxalt (Republican)
1980: T. LeRoy Collins / Edmund S. Muskie (Democratic), Eugene J. McCarthy / John B. Anderson (Independent)
1984: Gary W. Hart / Lloyd M. Bentsen, Jr. (Democratic)
1989-1993: Paul D. Laxalt / Jack F. Kemp (Republican)
1988: Mario M. Cuomo / John H. Glenn, Jr. (Democratic) H. Ross Perot / Pat Choate (Reform)
1993-1993: Jerry L. Litton / Peter E. Duel (Democratic)
1992: Paul D. Laxalt / M. Elizabeth A. H. Dole (Republican)
1993-1997: Peter E. Duel / vacant (Democratic)
1997-2001: Peter E. Duel / Reubin O’D. Askew (Democratic)
1996: Carroll A. Campbell, Jr. / J. Danforth Quayle (Republican)
2001-2005: William H. Frist / Jeffry L. Flake (Republican)
2000: Richard A. Gephardt / John D. Rockefeller IV (Democratic) H. Ross Perot / Pat Choate (Reform)
2005-2013: John F. Kennedy, Jr. / William W. Bradley (Democratic)
2004: William H. Frist / Michael D. Huckabee (Republican)
2008: Lincoln D. Chafee / Kelly A. Ayotte (Republican)
2013-: Elbert L. Guillory / Michael B. Enzi (Republican)
2012: Mark R. Warner / Andrew M. Cuomo (Democratic)