Recent content by PlasmaTorch

  1. PlasmaTorch

    A More Plausible "Big One"

    I recall RanulfC stating that the reason the hanford reactors were ramped down was due to damage from neutron embrittlement (I.E, the wigner effect). The program cutbacks were merely a consequence of this. The americans just couldn't keep churning out bombs at that rate. This article from...
  2. PlasmaTorch

    Question: High-ranking non-nazi officers in the Luftwaffe

    Hard core man, fucking hard core.
  3. PlasmaTorch

    Question: High-ranking non-nazi officers in the Luftwaffe

    Okay, so Goering stepping down voluntarily isn't a option. What other options are there to make the luftwaffe command structure more efficient? Milch replacing Udet is an obvious choice. But how about replacing Jeschonnek with Gunter Korten, would that work?
  4. PlasmaTorch

    A More Plausible "Big One"

    I actually read some more of that thread today, and it amazes me just how many layers of FAIL there are in 'the big one.' One of the commentors said that there were 2600 aircraft involved in that single raid, many of them B-36s! It looks as if my previous summary (that the americans didn't need...
  5. PlasmaTorch

    Question: High-ranking non-nazi officers in the Luftwaffe

    I have encountered a similar dilemma with my story! The POD is set in April of 1941, however. I'm wondering how the luftwaffe could be reorganised into something less dysfunctional. Looking at a wikipedia article of the OKLs organisation, it isn't clear whether or not the rank of 'supreme...
  6. PlasmaTorch

    A More Plausible "Big One"

    Yes. The very premise of TBO is invalidated from the outset. There was actually a guy over on SB who did a good job of addressing the B-36 problem. Are you sure about that? The hanford reactors started having problems with the wigner effect sometime in 1946. The b reactor went first (because...
  7. PlasmaTorch

    A More Plausible "Big One"

    Yeah, thats pretty much my opinion. If britain signs a white peace with germany, its really hard to get america in the war. Its actually far more plausible to go the route that AANW did: The nazis manage to squeak out a win at stalingrad, which causes fragmentation within the soviet politiburo...
  8. PlasmaTorch

    A More Plausible "Big One"

    Before you can proceed with a story even vaguely resembling that of the big one, you have to recognise a simple fact: Namely, that the americans are not going to wait multiple years until they have built up a stockpile of over 200 atom bombs. They are going to start dropping bombs on germany as...
  9. PlasmaTorch

    With no America and no lend lease could Germany win on the eastern front?

    For the holodomor, snyder gives a figure of over 5 million deaths, which is much too low. The best study on this matter comes from oleh wolowyna, who concluded that over 7.6 million people died in the famines. For the gulags, snyder gives a figure of 1 million deaths. The minimum accepted...
  10. PlasmaTorch

    With no America and no lend lease could Germany win on the eastern front?

    That number is most likely too low. This website does an overview of the megadeaths that occurred in the 19th and 20th century. There are various estimates available for the number of people joseph stalin murdered, but one of the most balanced accounts comes from robert conquest. He gives a...
  11. PlasmaTorch

    With no America and no lend lease could Germany win on the eastern front?

    Liquidation is a broad category: Mass murderers like stalin, hitler, and mao use it as a euphemism. It can mean 'killed', or it can mean 'resettled.' But WRT generalplan ost, even if the majority of the population was exiled instead of killed, you would still expect a high mortality rate. Being...
  12. PlasmaTorch

    WI the Germans won at Stalingrad?

    They have alot of resources and material, yes. But their fighting power was still low in 1943, while the germans retained high fighting power. That equation wouldn't change until mid 1944, when the allys gained more experience and the germans suffered a manpower implosion. And if you look at an...
  13. PlasmaTorch

    With no America and no lend lease could Germany win on the eastern front?

    Citation needed for that. A couple elitist magazines 'showing support' for the USSR in 1941 doesn't count. Nor does propaganda from madison avenue.
  14. PlasmaTorch

    Which Post 1900 TL Should I do next?

    Not as interesting as 'A different kind of terror.'
  15. PlasmaTorch

    Which Post 1900 TL Should I do next?

    Are you only going to write 1 story, or 2 of them?
Top