Recent content by ninebucks

  1. WI: Karl Marx born 100 years earlier?

    I don't think the opposition to religion did Marxism any harm to the movement, quite the opposite I'd argue. Anti-clericalism had been strong throughout for centuries before Marx. Hardly. It's just semantics.
  2. You in charge of Star Trek: TNG 2010

    I like the idea of setting it on the Enterprise-C, rather than the -D, mostly because I think the Excelsior class is the swishiest, sexiest-looking starship design in all Star Trek. The political context will be very different from OTL's TNG, as the Federation will face much stronger external...
  3. You in charge of Star Trek: The Original Series

    Practically speaking, it'd probably be best to keep the series as similar to OTL as possible. The last thing I'd want to do is jeopardise any chances of the franchise's long-term survival. But here are some tweaks I'd make: 1) I like the idea of a series bible, that'd be good to create a...
  4. What were Axis plans in Central/South Asia?

    None? Despite what the popular imagination may say, the Axis did not seriously have any plans for global domination.
  5. The Giants of north america

    It's just a tall tale. Seriously, there are not, nor have there ever been, giants. The fact is that you cannot just scale things up and expect them to work the same. A human being above a certain size would be crushed under their own weight and simply not be biologically viable.
  6. What Would a CSA History Textbook Look Like Today?

    I partially agree. Obviously the fact that Southern Blacks were held as slaves, while the economic exploitation of Poor Whites was more subtle established pretty strongly among the culture very strong racial divisions. But then I also believe that Reconstruction did a lot of harm by reaching out...
  7. What Would a CSA History Textbook Look Like Today?

    I'm going to differ with you on your third presupposition, in that I believe a surviving CSA is likely to take a massive swing to the Left by the early 20th century - precisely because the levels of wealth disparity caused by a slave-holder system would be totally unsustainable. The concept of...
  8. A statement of multiversal odds - France was the most likely European hegemon

    In what sense does France have a 'central position'? The same could be said about everywhere else in the world at that time. 'National' languages only emerged after the nations in question established enough of an education infrastructure to force kids throughout their realm to start...
  9. Indian-Pakistani re-unification

    India is in as much of a mess as Pakistan, the difference is that Pakistan just has a couple of really big messes, while India has hundreds and hundreds of smaller messes.
  10. Challenge: Barack Obama As Prime Minister of Australia

    ASB, Australians are all massive racists.
  11. Judaism without Khazars

    With no Khazars, the story of European Jewry would have ended with the expulsions of the Middle Ages. Seeing as there's a good chance Hitler himself had some Jewish background, he'd be wiped out of this timeline too.
  12. Alternative anthems of countries

    I think the fact that 'Rule Britannia' ISN'T our national anthem in OTL, is pretty much ASB as it is.
  13. Soviet Stealth

    There are the ekronoplans. They're pretty stealthy.
  14. The Hungarian Invasion of Romania, 1993...

    In 1992, Moldova was fighting against the separatists in Transnistria. This would be the perfect time for a Romania-Moldova 'anschluss', as Moldova needs helping out with its war, and this hypothetical Romanian Nationalist government will win an early victory in its struggle to unite and purify...
  15. Was the cultural/civilisation split of Europe and the Middle East inevitable?

    This all sounds a bit too Huntingtonian for my tastes, with all this talk of civilisational splits. The world has always been too complicated to just divide into distinct civilisation-blocs.
Top