Recent content by Maeglin

  1. Maeglin

    WI: The Maori go to South America instead of New Zealand

    Moa survive longer, and no-one chases off Tasman in 1642.
  2. Maeglin

    Alternate rugby history: Rugby becomes professionalised in 1893?

    Apartheid had two levels of problematic: The earlier issue is that South Africa objected to Maori and Pacific Island players coming as part of touring teams. The 1928, 1949, and 1960 New Zealand tours to South Africa were all-white. By the 1960s, you had a "No Maoris, No Tour!" movement in New...
  3. Maeglin

    Alternate rugby history: Rugby becomes professionalised in 1893?

    It took until the mid-1990s for real-life rugby union to turn professional. Scotland was not trivial at the time, and in fact was the most successful rugby nation of the nineteenth century (Wales would take over prior to the First World War). Moreover, one imagines that the elite amateurs of...
  4. Maeglin

    Alternate rugby history: Rugby becomes professionalised in 1893?

    Problem: I think you still get a split. Scottish Rugby at the time was incredibly anti-professional, to the point where they frowned on touring players getting pocket money to live off. If England endorses professionalism, Scotland's going to throw a hissy fit.
  5. Maeglin

    The Western Empire Survives by Escaping to America

    Not sure Roman ships were good enough to pull off a Trans-Atlantic voyage (Mediterranean waters are much calmer). But Plato's Atlantis was (1) clearly presented as metaphorical, (2) explicitly destroyed, and (3) located just beyond the Straits of Gibraltar - once you find the Canary Islands or...
  6. Maeglin

    Best monarch or head of state to kill off early for a more prosperous future

    Prosperity? Delay of Execution, perhaps. The issue with the Severans is that this is the point at which Grim Military Dictatorship becomes the order of the day. To get and maintain power, it was a matter of "enrich the soldiers, and scorn all other men." Put Commodus away (or give Pertinax more...
  7. Maeglin

    Best monarch or head of state to kill off early for a more prosperous future

    Assuming Arcadius dies on schedule in 408, that is still better than Honorius making it to 423.
  8. Maeglin

    Ronald Reagan and RFK are the major party nominees in 1968. Who is favored in the November?

    1968 was not 1980, or even 1976. Reagan (outside California) was regarded as a right-wing nut in 1968. So, so easy to paint as Goldwater 2.0.
  9. Maeglin

    What would Nixon’s second term look like if watergate had never happened and how would he be viewed today?

    Ted Kennedy had little real interest in the Presidency. He only ran in 1980 to spite Carter. Without Nixon getting discredited (though he might still be, with another scandal), no-one outside the South ever hears of Carter. The forces that pushed the Honest Outsider are no longer there, and...
  10. Maeglin

    WI: No Franco-Prussian War ?

    So far as No Commune goes... this also gives less space for Lenin to develop his more autocratic version of revolutionary socialism (Lenin was exploring Where the Commune Went Wrong). Of course, it's possible that another Commune analogy happens somewhere else, further down the line.
  11. Maeglin

    Would Latin American countries be accepted in NATO during the cold war?

    By the same token, Cuba was not in the Warsaw Pact. SEATO was famously called a "zoo of paper tigers." Any attempt at a Latin American equivalent would be an infamous who's-who of nasty juntas.
  12. Maeglin

    AHC Make Less Registered Democrats vote for Geroge W Bush in 2000

    The "conventional wisdom" at the time was that Clinton's scandals were a weakness. So Gore decided to steer clear - which is also why he picked Lieberman. Now, based off the 1998 midterms, there was probably good reason for rejecting that conventional wisdom, but at the time, that was his reasoning.
  13. Maeglin

    Third Party Presidents

    I think the most realistic option under these circumstances isn't Wallace. It's that the House and Senate leadership simply refuses to select anyone, whereupon the incumbent Speaker of the House, John W, McCormack becomes President.
  14. Maeglin

    What if Ireland and Scotland(Alba/Pictland) were pagan until much later?

    Irish monasteries also helped preserve Latin texts. Without them, we're basically reliant on the Carolingians to keep those texts alive.
Top