alternatehistory.com
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
New profile posts
New threadmarks
Latest activity
Members
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Word Count:
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Members
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Julian's latest activity
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
I think you're underestimating the severity of the German reaction to having a city burned in a single night even by 1,000 bombers...
Apr 16, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
Assertions should be backed up with facts. More fuel doesn't equal enough fuel. Germany had 2 million tons in reserve in December 1940...
Apr 16, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
On a related note, after digging through a few books on the decision making process for Barbarossa I think it's actually questionable...
Apr 16, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
I think the core problem with a Mediterranean strategy, which Axis planners recognized IOTL, is that while it improves Germany's...
Apr 16, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
Germany would have fuel shortages even without a war with the USSR. I’d suggest reading the many numbers cited on fuel in this thread -...
Apr 16, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
On the topic of nuclear weapons specifically, I think you're underestimating the severity of the German reaction to having a city burned...
Apr 14, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
A good point, which I think does help Germany improve aircraft production by 1942-1943 compared to OTL. However, here we run into the...
Apr 14, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
No number are being put on the table to back up that disagreement. Carl Krauch, Goering's Plenipotentiary for Chemical Issues, estimated...
Apr 13, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
I don't think we're in disagreement, then! Germany will be better off by 1944, but it won't have enough fuel or productive capacity to...
Apr 13, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
You can see my other posts on the fuel situation - while the Germans will be better off than OTL, because invading the USSR was a...
Apr 13, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
Even without Barbarossa and substantial cutbacks to military operations, Germany's oil industry planners expected its fuel reserves - as...
Apr 13, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
I’d suggest looking at the other posts on fuel in this thread. The Germans estimated that, even with no major military operations in...
Apr 13, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
I don’t think Roosevelt wanting to oppose “Team Eurasian Conquest and Genocide” is imperialist. Especially when the Nazis were pretty...
Apr 13, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
German pilots were getting half the training time of US/British pilots by 1943-1944 because of fuel shortages, just an hour a week in...
Apr 13, 2021
Julian
replied to the thread
How much different would cancelling operation Barbarossa make on WW2
.
The US and UK were actively planning for a joint war against Germany as early as January 1941 with staff conferences. The “US will...
Apr 12, 2021
Members
Top