Recent content by Genmotty

  1. What developments could have jump started artificial intelligence in our time?

    If mathematical algorithms had been promoted as a research topic in the Victorian and first half of the 20th century. Problems like the Travelling Salesman, that could be explored in the context of decision making theory. While neural nets and other forms of genetic algorithm may need to wait...
  2. A Cold War without Hydrogen Fusion Bombs

    "A decision on the proposal that an all-out effort be undertaken for the development of the "Super" cannot in our opinion be separated from consideration of broad national policy. A weapon like the "Super" is only an advantage when its energy release is from 100-1000 times greater than that of...
  3. AHC: mobile WWI

    It should be recognised that the German eastern front during the great war was fairly mobile, therefore it cannot be simply argued that technology or tactics were the reasons for the stalemate and attritional warfare of the western front during the great war. Indeed many commanders began the...
  4. Decisive Darkness: What if Japan hadn't surrendered in 1945?

    This thread: Decisively, dark. (not sure I've ever read 189 pages of something so somber)
  5. IJN Carrier attack on Hawaii - January 1942. Wargame for thread in progress.

    I am surprised at the level of non-success from the US player, it may be dice, but it also might be that he is not committing all in favour of being able to contest at every point and looking for an attack of opportunity. Either way, the initiative is now in the Japanese camp. I...
  6. Tank development if WWI ends before 1918.

    It would unlikely change the long term prospects of the notion. After all the notion of armoured cars, and armoured vehicles had been on the minds of several inventors around 1900 and before WWI. The first world war, essentially just catalysed armament companies to develop test models that...
  7. IJN Carrier attack on Hawaii - January 1942. Wargame for thread in progress.

    Well, if the battlewagons have put to sea, then the harbour flak/AA will be weakened. The question here is if the carriers will risk aircraft losses on a port strike, but then be weakened against a counter-airstrike and thus have to leave cripples that will be 'cleaned up' by the SAG group...
  8. IJN Carrier attack on Hawaii - January 1942. Wargame for thread in progress.

    You can, indeed intelligence is just one of those things that doesn't match well with pen and dice, because at it's heart was something more of a creative situation to real life problems, rather than a comparison/reduction of RL scenarios. I think the best way I've seen it done was in a WW1...
  9. IJN Carrier attack on Hawaii - January 1942. Wargame for thread in progress.

    Because we don't have a full inventory of what each player has available, it is still a little early to call who has the better advantage in the air. While the US is it deep water, it is plain and clear from the interrogation and other details voiced that the US player has retained air assets...
  10. Neutrals after a Nuclear War

    There would be many regional areas that would escape devastation. My home country in the Channel Islands would likely be one such location far too small to warrant a direct attack, yet far away enough from locations in Brest, Cherbourg and St. Malo to really be effected by fallout and the large...
  11. IJN Carrier attack on Hawaii - January 1942. Wargame for thread in progress.

    One of the key rules in the book of war, is not to do what the enemy might suspect you to do. If I may lend some advice from RTT and TTS games I have played vs players, this advice is golden. From the US perspective, they have a fall back position, that means that the prime US objective is...
  12. Japan free hand, how long does it last in China?

    Occupying and annexing China was never part of any of Imperial Japans goals or wishes. China was important to Japan in the same sense that India was important to the British Empire. What Japanese industrialists saw in China was a massive consumer market for Japanese produced goods and a vast...
  13. Japanese "win", German defeat

    Every single time this kind of thread comes up we have to remember that from Feb 1936, the Japanese Government was simply not in control of the Japanese Armed forces, and their was what we might call a 'millitary junta' in control over Japans Foreign policy. This gives massive room for 'wiggle'...
  14. WWI Diplomacy and Alliances: A Possibility

    Apart from 1940LaSalle most of you are talking out your arses I'm afraid to say; The US and European powers not wanting to include Asian equality into post Great War sentiments had nothing to do with Japan joining the Axis. Japan joined the axis because of the Anti-Comintern Pact...
  15. Japanese Alaska after 1905--Effect on Second World War?

    Historically Alaska was sold by the Russians to America in 1867. Thus any POD is 35 years before the Russo-Japanese war, and almost 70 years before WWII. Thus the butterflies make this an almost ASB proposition regarding WWII. For Imperial Russia to have not sold Alaska it would have had to...
Top