Recent content by eighthgear

  1. Without the French intervention in Mexico, Would a French conquest of Japan be possible ?

    Japan in the 1860s is not exactly the strongest of states. Whilst the Tokugawa and various domains were in the process of modernizing their armed forces, they had a long ways to go before they'd match any of the European powers. Furthermore, there was rising discontent, with certain domains -...
  2. AHC: Revive the Battleship

    That's going into ASB territory. Directed energy weapons are only recently starting to look practical for air defense, and that's with 21st century materials science and engineering. German researchers in the 1940s had no hope of coming up with anything that could even be used as a basis for an...
  3. Obscure Remnant Ethno-Linguistic Groups

    They aren’t as obscure as some of the other groups mentioned here, but the Ainu of Hokkaido come to mind. The Ainu language is possibly an isolate, and the Ainu themselves are likely the small remnant of what was once the dominant ethno-linguistic group of the Japanese islands during the Jomon...
  4. What if Mussolini joined the allies in Wolrd War 2?

    Probably as an authoritarian but useful Cold War ally, similar to Franco’s Spain. However, as with Franco l suspect that the fascist government would not last long following Mussolini’s eventual death. If Italy becomes a liberal democracy then his reputation would probably be that of a thug who...
  5. WI: Churchill wins 1945 UK election, Indian independence is at hand

    Without a significant PoD, by 1945 there’s no putting the Indian independence genie back in the bottle. If Churchill wins the election and tries to keep India by force, the resulting protests, strikes, and potentially riots and violence would quickly turn the British public against him. If an...
  6. What if the sino-soviet union was formed or the soviet union annexed china?

    At the end of the day, Chinese communists, like Vietnamese ones, were also nationalists. They would not support China becoming a subservient territory of Moscow. The USSR would end up facing a large war if they tried to take over China, something that wouldn’t be easy - just ask the Japanese.
  7. How would Oda Nobunaga handle the Imjin War

    I'm not fully sure whether there would be an Imjin War at all. It's commonly stated that Hideyoshi was following Nobunaga's dream by attempting to conquer China (by way of Korea), but whether Nobunaga himself would have launched such a foolhardy campaign or whether Hideyoshi was just making...
  8. Leyte Gulf

    This was during Hailstone, correct? Is there any source you recommend that offers more details on this engagement? I don’t doubt you; I was just trying to find more info on it and couldn’t find much beyond sparse wiki-style writeups.
  9. AHC: Allied Imperial Japan in world war 2

    You'd probably have to go back to at least the late 19th century and change the fundamental nature of Imperial Japan. You'd somehow have to give all the Meiji genro mindsets similar to that of Saionji Kinmochi, who was the most liberal of the lot, in order to end up with a constitution that is...
  10. AHC: Have communism end in China the way it ended in Russia

    You probably also have to make the PLA more independent-minded. The Soviet Army was a bit less totally controlled by the party than the PLA was in China, and whilst some elements tried to preserve the Soviet system (hence the August coup attempt), most did not. The PLA on the other hand is quite...
  11. What if the German Empire was exiled to one of their African colonies?

    Yup. You'd need major PoDs here going back to the 19th century to make this remotely feasible.
  12. What if the German Empire was exiled to one of their African colonies?

    Germany would never do that, as the whole point of getting a colonial empire was to show that they were an equal to Britain and France. Giving up colonies is a sign of weakness. Even if they did, they'd have to leave behind German military bases, and said bases would probably come under Entente...
  13. Japanese pop culture if the imperial government survived

    Anime as we know it was born out of the circumstances of post-war Japan, so anime if the 30s-style Imperial system had survived would be pretty much unrecognizable from what we know today. Animation was used by the Imperial government in the 30s and 40s as a form of propaganda, with cartoons...
  14. What if the German Empire was exiled to one of their African colonies?

    The problem is that you have to have a POD which somehow prevents Germany's colonies from just being run over. German West Africa, Southwest Africa, and New Guinea were all overrun by British, French, and Commonwealth forces pretty easily, with dealing with terrain often being more difficult...
  15. No 1918 Armistice, could France keep fighting?

    The French could keep on fighting, because the Germans clearly couldn't. Vittorio Veneto kicked in the door on the rotten structure that was Austria-Hungary. The Ottomans signed their own armistice with the Entente as well. This means that the Central Powers are down to just Germany. Germany's...
Top