Recent content by Deadtroopers

  1. Deadtroopers

    Malaya What If

    "In Churchill's mind..." That's the problem right there.
  2. Deadtroopers

    Malaya What If

    The only way the Nazis or Japanese were going to win was if they had not fought at all.
  3. Deadtroopers

    Malaya What If

    Exactly. Prussia was army with a country attached; the UK is the DHSS with a country attached. The devil is in the details and I'm not a fan. Send it to the USSR where it won't have those problems. See the Finns and the Buffalo.
  4. Deadtroopers

    Malaya What If

    Democrat majority Congress, 267-167(H) and 65-29(S). Given that, what need is there to maintain a coalition?
  5. Deadtroopers

    Malaya What If

    To benefit himself. He wrecked this country. That is his entire political career. I can't think of anything he did that was of a sigificant benefit to us.
  6. Deadtroopers

    Malaya What If

    The Carcano in 7.35mm was rubbish; not helped by very poor quality control of the powder used. In 6.5mm it was a with good powder it is a different beast. Like Japan, war caught the Ities changing calibre. They reverted to the 6.5mm, so the Finns not only got non-standard cal. rifles with bad...
  7. Deadtroopers

    Malaya What If

    Fantastic team, fantastic players. Jealousy gets you nowhere. :-)
  8. Deadtroopers

    A William and Mary Timeline: For Want Of An Heir

    A small gem. I like an author who knows when to stop. Well done!
  9. Deadtroopers

    In Britannia Salutem

    Nice tidbit, that last. Worry not, the muse will return. We will wait patiently until then.
  10. Deadtroopers

    The fate of science in the non-Abrahamic world

    Likewise one cannot have a conversation with persons thinking gods have any reality outside of their bonce and prophylactic legend-mongering. You can't make a fence around the Torah. That is my last word on the topic as you framing it.
  11. Deadtroopers

    The fate of science in the non-Abrahamic world

    Religion is nonsense with knobs on. I don't dismiss the historiacal reality of the phenomena however. I don't waste my time on nonesense per se; but the human propensity for such nonsense and the nonsense itself are historical players. The argument I am hearing is akin to my holding that an...
  12. Deadtroopers

    The fate of science in the non-Abrahamic world

    I already pointed out the Empire was already on the road to collapse and that Xtianity was a symptom not a cause. The Empire was already collapsing into ignorance before Xtianity came into prominence driven by that ignorance. Off of other societal collapses, I contend Renaissance by the Tenth...
  13. Deadtroopers

    The fate of science in the non-Abrahamic world

    Xtianity and Islam ARE ignorance and superstition.
  14. Deadtroopers

    It's A Long Way To Nagasaki: The Anglo-Japanese War

    I've got this tagged but I've been very remiss not actually reading it. I'll rectify that over the coming weeks. Well done, Sir! :)
  15. Deadtroopers

    The fate of science in the non-Abrahamic world

    Not the argument at all. Xtianity becoming significant was a symptom of the Crisis of the Third Century. The Empire was on its' way down the crapper to an age of ignorance with or without Xtianity. Xtianity just prolonged and reinforced that age ignorance. Going of the Bronze Age Collapes and...
Top