Recent content by da Racontor

  1. da Racontor

    What If Judas Iscariot is made/canonized as a holy saint in Christianity, especially by catholicism and/or other denominations?

    Sure, the initial spread my not be effected much, but once people start trying to figure out what they believe in, it will either not be the Christianity we know any more. Either that or Christianity won't make internally consistent sense.
  2. da Racontor

    What If Judas Iscariot is made/canonized as a holy saint in Christianity, especially by catholicism and/or other denominations?

    The thing Greco-Roman gods are theologically defined differently. Greco-Roman gods are powerful beings but still are still beings & thus are finite. Abrahamic God, traditionally, is defined as exists itself, "I am Who am," if you prefer. And not a "finite being in the universe" as the infinite...
  3. da Racontor

    What If Judas Iscariot is made/canonized as a holy saint in Christianity, especially by catholicism and/or other denominations?

    But I see a few problems with this. I haven't read the book, so just going by your explanation. --First off, Judas was paid before the Last Supper, so he was already planning on betraying Him before Jesus said anything. If anything Jesus's comment would probably have been a warning, "I know...
  4. da Racontor

    WI: French War for Religion destroyed royal authority permanently

    I'd imagine everyone would be quiet desperate by that point, so might work.
  5. da Racontor

    WI: French War for Religion destroyed royal authority permanently

    I'll have to do some more thinking to come up with a good answer, but off the top of my head, 3 possibilities. -- All adult claimants die before the end of the war. Leaving only a young child. The regent (while traditionally the queen-mother, but doesn't have to be) takes over. Once the king...
  6. da Racontor

    Were black magic users and worshipers of dark gods and godesses (esp Satanic counterparts) not necessarily welcomed? Maybe even persecuted openly?

    Now that you mentioned it, I vaguely remember hearing this somewhere, though I don't remember where. There were plenty of Mediaeval exoteric text etc., but they have no direct "academically consistent" connection to the modern groups. They started to appear later; some do claim older lineages...
  7. da Racontor

    Were black magic users and worshipers of dark gods and godesses (esp Satanic counterparts) not necessarily welcomed? Maybe even persecuted openly?

    First off we have to define a few things. Our modern concept of Satanism, both ironic & un-ironic, didn't exist in the Middle Ages, nor did any modern occultist groups. At best, these groups can academically date themselves to at most the 1700s & that isn't going to be very many of them. And the...
  8. da Racontor

    Miscellaneous <1900 (Alternate) History Thread

    Or it could force the confrontation to to happen earlier just with the French Canadians & not the Irish. It's not like the 13 colonies weren't already into anti-Catholicism. The only Catholic to sign the declaration had was schooled in France as even Maryland was not that friendly to Catholics.
  9. da Racontor

    Miscellaneous <1900 (Alternate) History Thread

    Depends on how much & when. If the Lower Canada gets added to the original 13, you bet a potential state full of French speaking "papists" is going to effect things.
  10. da Racontor

    Map Thread XXII

    What scares me about it, is that the response to the inoculation is usually making the definition of person relative.
  11. da Racontor

    Miscellaneous <1900 (Alternate) History Thread

    The potential for changing what the ATL USA would look like it also much greater with any significant portion of OTL Canada.
  12. da Racontor

    Can industrialization happen without causing democracy?

    I completely agree. However, by that same token, it is unfair to call France in this age an absolute monarchy.
  13. da Racontor

    Can industrialization happen without causing democracy?

    If people always act rationally & in their best interests. But that's not always the case. In fact, Louis XV did make a huge gesture to the common people. The restoration of the parlements were supposed to be for the common people. The fact that it didn't actually do what was intended is a...
  14. da Racontor

    From were I am, it still seems a bit fringe, supposedly eaten mostly by those who like to...

    From were I am, it still seems a bit fringe, supposedly eaten mostly by those who like to "pretend to be homesteaders."
  15. da Racontor

    What is the difference between me & a "hipster?" Not only was did I like it before it was cool...

    What is the difference between me & a "hipster?" Not only was did I like it before it was cool, but I am saddened by the sour reputation they've gathered &, more importantly, I would be overjoyed if things like sourdough, sea shanties, and fedoras, etc. became mainstream again & would continue...
Top