Recent content by Bety

  1. Could "Israel" have been carved out of Germany?

    After WWII, in Czechia, they deported Germans and voted Communists.
  2. Could "Israel" have been carved out of Germany?

    I have argued it from a view of country, whoes first thing it did after getting rid of the Germans to satisfy its spite , was only to vote for better future---
  3. Could "Israel" have been carved out of Germany?

    I would certainly wish a good definition of what is meant by people's will. My age is more then 50. I have seen for what my parents voted for, and were crushed by the same.
  4. Could "Israel" have been carved out of Germany?

    The problem is, anywhere a Jewish state would be constituted, a problem would become. Maybe a Latin America would be a better joice, then Palestine. Maybe the correct answer to Holocaust would be - no state. This would be the only logical answer.
  5. AH Help - U.S.S.R. Related

    USSR ....thay just renamed to former Russia and having losts of problems with those who do not agree with the empire. I hope nobody here believes that by change of political regime all people living in the region go somewhere, and the country starts to be inhabited by.....name it.
  6. Challenge: All Jews for Jesus

    What do you mean by modern Jews? Do not mix nationality with believe. Jews were in diaspora even before time of Jesus.
  7. Communism before Democracy?

    Yes, its an ideal which is not surely new. And well in consonance with Marx, who was a good student of Hegel who really loved neoplatonism of which source was ...just name it.
  8. What the heck happened to religion back then?

    There always will be assholes. Take it as granted.
  9. What the heck happened to religion back then?

    I recommend for all posters on this thread to read Sermon on the Mount before they post. Please. I do not know why everyone is so preoccupied by his birth and death. It does not make him wrong or right.
  10. Communism before Democracy?

    Ehm. thats what Lenin preached, of course if you have a Dictature of proletariate as a step between. There was no democracy at Russia when he came to power. Of course at first Bolsheviks supported to be democrats - Like a noose supports a hanged man...
  11. Patton takes Prague - Capitalist Czechia, Communist Slovakia

    Liberal capitalism was surely not in after WII in Czechoslovakia. Socialist tendencies were even much more marked in Czechia then in Slovakia. Nationalization decrets of Benes where not thought up by Communists. So it would lead to leftis regime in someway, but not a Dictature of Proletariat...
  12. A Muslim world?

    I know one case when a drug containing alcohol really hurt a patient. Famous Czech actor, Vladimir Menšík got in a real problem when after quite successful treatment of his alcoholism - he abstined for 4 years - he got prescribed a medicine which contained alcohol. The whole alcoholic cycle...
  13. What if the nazis weren't evil?

    In Czechia I do not think the ideology of Nazis was the greatest issue..... They just invaded us. Lots of our best people died. Thats why they were the bad guys.
  14. WI Patton Stayed in the Czech Republic?

    Yes, you are right. Communist got 40% in 1946. Not a majority but quite a lot in our voting system. And yes, I am talking about generation of my parents. They were young but very far from stupid at the time. Hard to understand for me sometimes, but I try. And I would also wish my grandchildren...
  15. WI Patton Stayed in the Czech Republic?

    You sort of forgot the people. How do you think all became supporting communists? By power - no. Soviets freed them from Germans. The USA stopped at Plzen because they agreed with Russians. And let the Prague bleed. And all remembered Mnichov. And wanted better world. Communists were voted...
Top