Recent content by BenC

  1. BenC

    Expansion of the United Kingdom within Europe post 1700

    Iceland seems the most obvious answer. It was repeatedly offered up for sale or as collateral to England pre-1700 by Denmark, but that's before the PoD. There were multiple opportunities for the United Kingdom to annex it during the Napoleonic Wars. The issue is getting the British government...
  2. BenC

    Pride Goes Before a Fall: A Revolutionary Greece Timeline

    The timeline has been worth it just for the fact it's cleaned up the the US-Canadian border. Another excellent update, looking forward to the next.
  3. BenC

    AHC: More micro states in europe

    The Free Territory of Trieste remains a thing, perhaps because of a less conciliatory stance towards Italy after the war. A thousand or so more Faroese vote for independence in 1946, leading to the Faroe Islands gaining full independence from Denmark rather than autonomy.
  4. BenC

    South Asian Settler Colonies

    Not sure they count as the settling wasn't led by a South Asian polity, but Trinidad and Guyana are both plurality South Asian in OTL.
  5. BenC

    Why did the British need Australia as a penal colony when they already have vast tracks of land in Canada?

    It's not wise, when you've just lost the majority of British North America, to start settling convicts in the part you've managed to hold on to. It would upset the existing settlers, the convicts aren't going to be positively inclined towards the British government either, and would only...
  6. BenC

    AHC: Another Christian majority nation in Asia.

    If Sarawak gains independence, never federates with Malaysia, avoids annexation by Indonesia, and receives the same level of missionary activity, it might fit the bill. It's still currently plurality Christian even in a country with Islam as the state religion.
  7. BenC

    AHC/WI Make Christianity formally become a kind of "second ethnic identity" similar to Judaism

    Protestantism and Catholicism basically amount to ethnic identities in Northern Ireland and Scotland, used to be the case in England too.
  8. BenC

    WI: Great Anglo-Saxon Migration to the British Isles, AngloSaxons conquer Ireland, Scottish Lowlands

    The Scottish get their name from an Irish tribe, but Scots is a Germanic language/English variant. Gaelic is the Celtic language in Scotland.
  9. BenC

    Cities that wouldn't exist if borders were different.

    No partition of India and there's no Islamabad, Karachi would be far smaller too.
  10. BenC

    Pride Goes Before a Fall: A Revolutionary Greece Timeline

    That's 3 times in quick succession I've thought there was an update, only for it to be a nothing comment. I see irony of me adding another nothing comment.
  11. BenC

    Pride Goes Before a Fall: A Revolutionary Greece Timeline

    Very glad to see this back, enjoyed that update. It's good that the famine has been dealt with far better in this timeline, even if it's still a disappointingly slow response from the British government.
  12. BenC

    Why is Muhammad a common Muslim name, but Jesus not a common Christian name?

    “It is the responsibility of every father to choose a good name for his child." "Whoever gets four sons, and he has not named even one after me has been cruel on me" - Muhammad As I understand, it's a religious/cultural tradition to name at least one of your sons after the Prophet.
  13. BenC

    Possible to change majority identity of a territory post-1600?

    Plenty of examples, but most will be down to colonialism and an overarching identity forming and solidifying upon independence. A Pakistani identity is a relatively modern thing, and it trickled down from the top.
  14. BenC

    AHC: More countries in the world adopt English as their official language.

    Some of the countries on that map don't actually have English as the official language as it is. Might see the Sudanese and Somali governments keeping English as an official language when they gain independence. Similar with other former British colonies at the point of independence, like the...
  15. BenC

    Most irrational decisions in history that worked

    Not sure you could say either of these decisions worked, which is the key point of the title. One died childless, the other was overthrown for being Catholic.
Top