Restoration of the Great Ming: A Tianqi Timeline

1637, part 1
Tiangong_Kaiwu_Drawloom.jpg

Depiction of a drawloom from the Tiangong Kaiwu, published in 1637

For some months, the emperor refuses to leave his private quarters.

This goes unnoticed by most of his subjects. The ordinary peasant farmer, city-dweller, even low-ranking members of the imperial bureaucracy have gotten used to a mostly distant and impersonal sovereign. The emperor’s grandfather had pretty much codified that practice, although it cannot have been said that emperors were especially hands-on even then.

Still, the extent of the emperor’s seclusion was apparently notable even to his contemporaries. The episode is mostly minimized in official chronicles, but historians are in agreement from other primary sources that the emperor was experiencing a severe depressive episode in response to the death of Yuan Chonghuan in battle.

Meanwhile, outside of the imperial palaces, events continue to turn. The four Oirats are sufficiently impressed by the Ming military expeditions to send embassies to Beijing pledging -- well, not submission, but something closer to friendship and also please don’t kill us. Ejei Khan, despite arguably “winning” the recent battle, takes a good look at the frankly unsustainable casualty figures that result from waging war with the Ming. During the following campaign seasons, he instead falls upon the Manchu, leaving China’s northern frontier mostly undisturbed for now.

In Dongshan, the announcement is officially made that gold has been discovered along the eastern coast. The reaction from the Portuguese, Dutch, and Spanish is one of grumbling at the missed opportunity -- or, at least, it would have been, but those nations are distracted by their quarrels with each other. The Dutch have been fighting the Spanish for generations over freedom and have been fighting the Portuguese for almost as long over colonial possessions. There’s intrigues afoot in Japan (where the conflict sometimes adopts religious overtones). Dutch and English cooperation was probably one of the factors that led to the merchant John Weddell being rebuffed from Chinese ports; he did not, apparently, endear himself to the Portuguese merchants who had already secured a foothold in the region.[1]

Further afield, the great emperor of the Mughals, Shah Jahan, reacts with some bemusement to a letter from the Ming court. Having heard rumors of Shah Jahan’s persecution of the Jesuits in his realm, the Tianqi Emperor had apparently dictated a suitably disapproving response (although historians disagree on the exact wording of the authentic letter). Shah Jahan shrugs his shoulders and continues with his life. After all, his forces have just taken the stronghold of Nagpur and he’s got some neat ideas for building projects. Life is good.

Song Yingxing, an amateur scientist and failed exam candidate (seriously he made at least five different attempts at the jinshi degree before giving up), publishes his Tiangong Kaiwu (天工開物, “Explanation of Works Under Heaven”), one of the more interesting of the Ming-era encyclopedias. The text is very useful to historians, as it provides an extremely in-depth view of all aspects of the Ming economy circa 1637. Song includes an inscription thanking the gunpowder enthusiast Sun Yuanhua for his contributions to the book, although the Tiangong Kaiwu nonetheless includes some curious references to archaic but awesome-sounding gunpowder weapons (e.g. a description which greatly resembles the “thunder crash bomb” invented some hundreds of years earlier).[2]

In Joseon, the king Injo (or, at least, whichever ministers are presently manipulating him) orders a massive offensive against the Manchus to the north.[3] Some figures within the Joseon court dream of pushing far enough to restore the old frontiers of Balhae, one of the predecessor states to Goryeo (which was itself the immediate predecessor of the ruling Joseon dynasty). That’s probably a little bit out of reach, though. Injo finds himself in the curious position of sorta-technically cooperating with the Northern Yuan, who are encroaching on the Jurchens from the west as Joseon’s armies do so from the east. A formal agreement between Ejei Khan and King Injo is nowhere to be had, of course. Injo favors closer relations with the Ming and is not about to get in trouble by negotiating with the wrong people, even if the enemy of my enemy is my friend.

All these things happen, and then, as summer rolls around, the Tianqi Emperor finally emerges from seclusion...



Footnotes
[1] John Weddell was a real guy who existed IOTL and who failed to make much of an impression in China on account of the Portuguese already being there. (It’s honestly amazing how little success the English / British had in China literally up until the Opium Wars. Then again, their ambitions were generally focused elsewhere.)
[2] Song Yingxing was also a real person from OTL. ITTL he has managed to get a bit more expert insight on his writing, so his description of gunpowder weapons is a little less anachronistic than IOTL. But only a little bit. Dude really liked his long-obsolete explosives.
[3] This is in sharp contrast with OTL, where Hong Taiji had proclaimed himself founding emperor of the Qing dynasty and then launched another invasion of Joseon, in which (predictably) the Qing won handily.
 
So as shown here, steppe incursions are really hard for the Chinese, even with larger forces.

Nice sneak peeks on Ming neighbours, I was kinda hoping that Shahjahan would taunt Ming saying "If my ancestor the Great Emir Timur lived long enough, you wouldn’t be staying in Khanbaliq". Of course, too far away and too preoccupied with other matters, trolling is a waste of time.

Interesting that 4 Oirats are submitting to Ming, will we have an earlier Khoshkut khanate in Tibet? Gelug school will be patronised like OTL unless something crazy happens.

I'm sorry for not commenting earlier as my notifications don't seem to work.
 
So as shown here, steppe incursions are really hard for the Chinese, even with larger forces.

Nice sneak peeks on Ming neighbours, I was kinda hoping that Shahjahan would taunt Ming saying "If my ancestor the Great Emir Timur lived long enough, you wouldn’t be staying in Khanbaliq". Of course, too far away and too preoccupied with other matters, trolling is a waste of time.

Interesting that 4 Oirats are submitting to Ming, will we have an earlier Khoshkut khanate in Tibet? Gelug school will be patronised like OTL unless something crazy happens.

I'm sorry for not commenting earlier as my notifications don't seem to work.
Thank you for commenting! I'll be honest, I was getting a little demoralized from the recent comment drought (and it's not on you, don't worry) although the fact that my posts were still getting liked was a good sign -- anyways, no worries, water under the bridge. Let's rock and roll with this timeline.

Yep, taking an army onto the steppe is risky even when everything goes right. Not that it's impossible (and many Chinese dynasties have managed some level of domination over the steppe, IOTL and ITTL) but it's a lot different from campaigning in an area of agrarian settlement. The flipside is that steppe nomad societies tend to have much lower population density (and much lower population) so they can't typically absorb losses as well. There's this image of hordes of warriors on horseback (heck, the word "horde" itself probably comes from a Turkic language and was often applied to Mongol polities), which -- honestly -- owes a lot to popular culture depicting such warrior societies (whether Native Americans in old Western films or the much older antagonists of European drama) as merciless invaders. But while a steppe army may have seemed terrifying and invulnerable to some of their opponents, they were by no means limitless, in terms of manpower, in reality.

I did want to give a brief view into the doings of other countries -- so far most of the visible changes have been primarily in China and its immediate neighbors / geopolitical opponents -- and, of course, the most obvious way for the Ming to affect their neighbors would be through military force. But there's other things that I hope will happen. Just as long as I keep my thoughts in order and actually write stuff down.

As for Tibet -- maybe! It's probably in the cards for things to continue roughly analogous to OTL. It would be funny, though, to write a TL where Ligdan Khan / Ejei Khan end up restoring the Northern Yuan to a position of regional prominence and as a result the Nyingma school becomes dominant. But this isn't Restoration of the Northern Yuan. Oh well! Maybe someone else can write that one.
 
It had been a while since I last read this TL. I really like the drawloom picture at the opening of the last chapter, since it implies the Ming have at least some manufacturing going on.

And damn, I did not expect Yuan Chonghuan to die. Well, at least it was a better fate than execution by lingchi...
 
Thank you for commenting! I'll be honest, I was getting a little demoralized from the recent comment drought (and it's not on you, don't worry) although the fact that my posts were still getting liked was a good sign
Please dont be!
I love your work, this TL is amazing
Im just liking because Im out of things to say, but I still enjoy it a lot
 
It had been a while since I last read this TL. I really like the drawloom picture at the opening of the last chapter, since it implies the Ming have at least some manufacturing going on.

And damn, I did not expect Yuan Chonghuan to die. Well, at least it was a better fate than execution by lingchi...
Welcome back! Yes, I do hope to explore a little more of what's happening in the domains of the Ming besides military accomplishments.

Yuan Chonghuan deserved a better death than he got IOTL and -- well, he's a general on the northern frontier, and as far as killing off a named character went, I'm afraid he drew the short straw.

Please dont be!
I love your work, this TL is amazing
Im just liking because Im out of things to say, but I still enjoy it a lot
Why thank you kindly! I'm just plodding along as I do. As long as I get out around two updates a week, I'm content with my progress. I haven't run out of ideas yet!

Also, the next few posts are probably gonna be narrative ones. Not a Magistrate Di story, but some content following the Tianqi Emperor specifically. I've got an idea or two for him.
 
Not a Magistrate Di story
Aw we shall miss Magistrate Big Di
but some content following the Tianqi Emperor specifically.
YES! My favorite character!
I'm just plodding along as I do
Dont we all?
Why thank you kindly!
Im the one who must thank you for getting to read this novel quality work for free thanks to you and your generosity with us
I'm afraid he drew the short straw
And as usual I can blame the romans for everything
 
The Wandering Emperor [Chapter One]
Imperial Palace Complex, Beijing

She was worried about her husband, now more than ever. He would go for weeks at a time without speaking, and when he did speak, it was maybe one or two words. Several times, she’d seen him sitting at his workbench, his woodworking tools in front of them. Sitting perfectly still, not making a move toward any of the tools, not saying a word.

That worried her.

So it was almost a relief when he turned to her, one day, without preamble, and said: “I’ve got to get out.”

“I’m sorry?”

“Out of here. The walls are closing in.” He rubbed his face with his hands.

The emperor had done a good job in all the public rituals. He’d presided over the elaborate funerary arrangements for Yuan Chonghuan, who had died a hero’s death. He’d presided over a service of thanksgiving and repentance, intended to pacify Heaven, and signed a posthumous pardon for Madame Ke.[1] He’d presided over the presentation of war prisoners at the Meridian Gate and, like tradition demanded, had presided over their execution.

He had not enjoyed any of that, but she knew that her husband would have ordered the deaths of far more prisoners if it would bring back Yuan Chonghuan. But it wouldn’t. Nothing would.

The emperor staggered to his feet. “I’ll need to send for Minister Dong,” he said, mostly to himself. “He’ll know how to arrange things.” And he began pacing about the room.

It took some time to locate Minister Dong Kewei, and when he was apprised of the situation he frowned and stroked his beard, surprised but clearly giving the matter some thought. “If the divine emperor wishes to tour his domains, that is well within his purview,” he said slowly. “I will choose, from among my agents, a vast number of reliable guardsmen-”

“One.”

“I-I’m sorry?”

“One. Or as few as possible.” The emperor was quite firm about that. “I will be traveling anonymously. I want as little attention as possible.”

Minister Dong opened his mouth, but before he could say anything Master Jin, the Jesuit, burst through the door.[2]

“Excuse me, your majesty,” he said, breathing as if he’d just run a mile. “Let me...let me catch my breath for a moment.” He slumped over for a moment before speaking again. “Your majesty,” he said, “I overheard Minister Dong being summoned, and -- I would like to come with you.”

Everyone in the room seemed surprised at that, including the emperor. “Master Jin,” he said gently, “I need you to stay here and protect my family.”

Master Jin nodded. “I know, your majesty, but there are others who can do that. All of my compatriots are trustworthy and I would personally entrust my own life to the hands of Masters Luo and Tang.[3] But my place, your majesty, is by your side.” And he knelt on the ground.

The emperor sighed. “Get up, Jin. Very well. You can come with me. You and one guard that Minister Dong shall name. Minister Dong,” he said, “I entrust you with the safety of my realm. While I am traveling, you are to hide the fact that I am gone. Tell people that I have entered a meditative state or something like that. You can trust Master Jin’s people on household matters. If anything goes wrong -- if I am confirmed dead, or if there are rumblings of discontent in the region -- send for Admiral Zheng and bid him make haste from Dongshan. He probably won’t be able to get here in time, but his men will be able to wreak bloody vengeance. That probably won’t be necessary, though. I’ll be back.”

Turning to his wife, the emperor embraced her. “I’m sorry,” he whispered into her hair. “I just need to get out of here for a while. I keep having bad dreams. But even if I didn’t, if I were sound of mind, I would someday need to go and see the people. As they are, not stuffed into an audience hall. I need to. I don’t want to be like my grandfather. I want to feel human.”

She hugged him back. Kissed him. “It’s okay,” she said. “Go, with my blessing. And hurry home to me. Please.”

He rested his head against hers. “I shall.” Half-turning to Minister Dong. “One other thing,” he said. “My empress speaks in my name when I am gone. If she makes any request of you, I hope you carry it out as if you would for me.” Minister Dong murmured assent.

“Very well,” said the emperor, and he and the empress reluctantly parted. “Now,” he said. “Let’s meet our escort.”

The guard that Minister Dong selected to accompany the emperor was a serious-faced man who looked, at least superficially, a little bit like a Shaolin wushu expert. He brought with him very ordinary-looking robes, which he offered to Master Jin and to the emperor.

“Good idea,” the emperor said. “Keep us nondescript. You know, Master Jin, you could be our teacher and us your loyal students.” For indeed, Master Jin was visibly older than the other two.

The emperor turned to the guard. “What is your name?”

“Shi Chunjing, your majesty.”[4]

“Good man. When we are out there, remember: do not reveal to anyone that I am your emperor. That goes for you too, Master Jin. Not a word. Nothing.”

“But-”

“Glad I could count on you.” The emperor clapped them on their backs. “C’mon. Let’s get out of here.”

They exited the palace under cover of night. Shi Chunjing knew of a decent place in Beijing to hide out; it would be up to them to decide how much time to spend in the city versus traveling the countryside.

The emperor breathed the free air. It was dark, so nobody could see him smile.



Footnotes
[1] Believe it or not, IOTL the Chongzhen Emperor was persuaded to posthumously honor Wei Zhongxian as a sort of last-ditch attempt to restore the dynasty’s fortunes -- this despite his deep distaste and fear for the eunuch while he was still alive. ITTL the Tianqi Emperor is not facing quite so severe misfortunes as his brother did IOTL, but he feels he has to do something, and he appears to have genuinely loved his old nursemaid, even if she was a notorious schemer who, ITTL, was put to death for her crimes. Hence, no posthumous ennoblement, but a pardon would be appropriate.
[2] In case you’ve forgotten, this is Nicolas Trigault.
[3] He is referring to Giacomo Rho and Johann Adam Schall von Bell, two Jesuits who were active in Beijing at this time.
[4] 石纯竞. This is a fictional character whom I have invented, just like Magistrate Di’s assistants.
 
Another POV, this time from the emperor himself! I'm really excited to see where this goes and what Tianqi perceives of his realm. In this age of overwhelming information it is easy to criticize others in past for their performance whilst forgetting that they didn’t have vast, animated archives of information at their disposal.
 
It's touring time!

The Emperor is making yet another move that will make christians all fangirl for the ages

If he lives, this will become a legend

"Do you need help with your carpentry, sir? Then here's the Emperor!"

Besides if he really is having "bad dreams"(aka his mind unconsciously detecting bullshit plots against his life) then this is the right move

Also

Lowkey hoping he gets to meet our favorite Magistrate~

And what a great chapter this was!
 
I adore the relationship between the emperor and his wife, it's so genuine. And then there's Trigault as a teacher/father figure, which is awesome too.
 

kholieken

Banned
Interesting- kings in disguise, a classic storytelling motif for a reason.
But an unrealistic plot. Not sure its really possible. And what about numerous ceremony that Emperor must do ?? Emperor is primarily symbol, not ruler. Disappearing Emperor would bring plot and disaster.
 
But an unrealistic plot. Not sure its really possible. And what about numerous ceremony that Emperor must do ?? Emperor is primarily symbol, not ruler. Disappearing Emperor would bring plot and disaster.
While its true the Emperor has ceremonies to attend to this is far from unrealistic, China had Emperors who rarely showed up before and this case pales in comparison to another real life case also from the Ming Dynasty
The Zhengde Emperor took up a luxurious and prodigal lifestyle and indulged himself in women. It was said that he liked to frequent brothels and even created palaces called "Bao Fang" (豹房; literally "The Leopards' Chamber") outside the Forbidden City in Beijing initially to house exotic animals such as tigers and leopards for his amusement and then later used to house beautiful women for his personal enjoyment.[3] He also met Wang Mantang, one of his favorite consorts at a Bao Fang. On one occasion he was badly mauled while hunting tigers, and could not appear in court audiences for a month.[2] On another occasion he burned down his palace by storing gunpowder in the courtyards during the lantern festival.[2] His harem was so overfilled that many women starved to death due to lack of supplies.[4]
For months at a time he would live outside the Forbidden City or travel around the country with heavy expenditures being paid from the Ming government's coffers. While being urged to return to the palace and attend to governmental matters, the Zhengde Emperor would refuse to receive all his ministers and ignored all their petitions. He also sanctioned the rise of eunuchs around him. One particular Liu Jin, leader of the Eight Tigers, was notorious for taking advantage of the young emperor and squandered immense amount of silver and valuables. The diverted funds were about 36 million pounds of gold and silver.[5] There was even rumor of a plot that Liu Jin had intended to murder the emperor and place his own grandnephew on the throne. Liu Jin's plot was ultimately discovered, and he was executed in 1510. However, the rise of corrupt eununchs continued throughout the Zhengde Emperor's reign. There was also an uprising led by the Prince of Anhua and another uprising led by the Prince of Ning. The Prince of Anhua was the Zhengde Emperor's great-granduncle, while the Prince of Ning was his granduncle.[6]

In time, the Zhengde Emperor became notorious for his childish behaviour as well as abusing his power as emperor. For instance, he set up a staged commercial district inside his palace and ordered all his ministers, eunuchs, soldiers and servants of the palace to dress up and act as merchants or street vendors while he walked through the scene pretending to be a commoner. Any unwilling participants, especially the ministers (who viewed it as degrading and an insult), would be punished or removed from their post.

Then in 1517, the Zhengde Emperor gave himself an alter ego named Zhu Shou (朱壽) so he could relinquish his imperial duties and send himself off on an expedition to the north to repel raiding expeditions several tens of thousands strong led by Dayan Khan.[7] He met the enemy outside the city of Yingzhou and defeated them in a major battle by surrounding them.
What Tianqi is doing here is incredibly tame by comparison
 
While its true the Emperor has ceremonies to attend to this is far from unrealistic, China had Emperors who rarely showed up before and this case pales in comparison to another real life case also from the Ming Dynasty


What Tianqi is doing here is incredibly tame by comparison
Jesus, what a piece of work. It's amazing he even made it to 29.
 
And now, to reply to everyone's comments --

Another POV, this time from the emperor himself! I'm really excited to see where this goes and what Tianqi perceives of his realm. In this age of overwhelming information it is easy to criticize others in past for their performance whilst forgetting that they didn’t have vast, animated archives of information at their disposal.
Interesting- kings in disguise, a classic storytelling motif for a reason.
Heck yeah! Sometimes firsthand knowledge is best. And it does make for a good story -- which is part of why I'm doing this.

It's touring time!

The Emperor is making yet another move that will make christians all fangirl for the ages

If he lives, this will become a legend

"Do you need help with your carpentry, sir? Then here's the Emperor!"

Besides if he really is having "bad dreams"(aka his mind unconsciously detecting bullshit plots against his life) then this is the right move

Also

Lowkey hoping he gets to meet our favorite Magistrate~

And what a great chapter this was!
I can neither confirm nor deny that the Jesuits are getting their hopes up for this guy (even more so than they were for his brother IOTL). Actually, I can confirm it. Yep. They're definitely getting their hopes up for the emperor. Have been for quite some time.

I don't know if the emperor's party will get as far as Dongshan, where Magistrate Di is still administering the law! In any case, though, we can only hope that getting out into the country would be beneficial for the emperor's mental health. And I hope the chapters to come are just as good as this one.

Why am I getting Dong Zhuo flashbacks all of a sudden? 🤔
Ahh, our Dong is a different kind of guy. IOTL he has a brief mention on the English Wikipedia page for the Wanggongchang Explosion and a very short Chinese Wikipedia page; ITTL he is uninjured by the explosion and will likely be a lot more prominent in TTL's Wikipedia-equivalent, seeing as he retained his position as Minister of Works and has become de facto in charge of the emperor's secret police-

...hm. Well. Genuinely, though, our Dong is a decent fellow.

I adore the relationship between the emperor and his wife, it's so genuine. And then there's Trigault as a teacher/father figure, which is awesome too.
Thank you! I just realized that the way I've written it, the Tianqi Emperor (who has recently been having what was probably a depressive episode) and Nicolas Trigault (who IOTL very likely died by suicide) are becoming close for -- well, similar personalities, I think. And yeah, I was hoping to have the emperor / empress relationship come off as warm and genuine, so I'm glad it went well!

But an unrealistic plot. Not sure its really possible. And what about numerous ceremony that Emperor must do ?? Emperor is primarily symbol, not ruler. Disappearing Emperor would bring plot and disaster.
While its true the Emperor has ceremonies to attend to this is far from unrealistic, China had Emperors who rarely showed up before and this case pales in comparison to another real life case also from the Ming Dynasty


What Tianqi is doing here is incredibly tame by comparison
Jesus, what a piece of work. It's amazing he even made it to 29.
Right?
One of the cases where I genuinely see the average person(wheter SI or contemporary) doing better simply because you can hardly screw up as much
Absolutely. This conversation sums up the historical record pretty well. For even more context -- the Zhengde Emperor spent his time gallivanting around the countryside having fun (instead of staying home and gallivanting all over an empress), with the consequence being that he died without an heir and his cousin succeeded him as the Jiajing Emperor, who spent a lot of his time doing weird immortality rituals (likely not enhancing his lifespan) and who was succeeded by his son the Longqing Emperor, a political nonentity who reigned for a little while and was succeeded by his son the Wanli Emperor, who got some stuff done and then basically withdrew from the world until he died and was succeeded by his son the Taichang Emperor, who got sick and died after less than a month and was succeeded by our guy the Tianqi Emperor.

And then the Tianqi Emperor (IOTL and ITTL) spent a lot of his time secluded away doing woodworking and not much emperor stuff, just that ITTL things changed enough for him to get a bit of independence and maybe do some actual emperor-ing.

So the emperor pretending to be indisposed and using that time to travel incognito around his empire -- it's possible! Everyone will probably think he's just back to the usual (what's been the usual for...a century, at this point). Although I should note that my ultimate inspiration for this particular episode came from another part of Chinese history entirely. And I have no more to say about that!
 
I made that post and then I realized I completely forgot to mention an observation I've seen historians make: a lot of the later Ming emperors (from the Zhengde Emperor on down) withdrew from the world, neglected their imperial duties, and so on, which has historically been interpreted as poor statesmanship and moral failing but which revisionists have suggested was actually a sign of calculated protest -- emperors during this time were highly constrained in their day-to-day lives, required to live within extremely rigid frameworks and do all the right rituals at the right times and never really had any genuine friends because everyone was treating them like a living god (and like most god-kings, as time went on the restrictions on their behavior grew more and more onerous) -- to the point where most of the emperors starting going "you know what? fuck this, I'm running off to the country and you can't stop me."

This wasn't great long-term, of course, because eventually it produced emperors who genuinely did not know much about their empire (nor did they really care) and if China was unfortunate enough to get an evil or corrupt bureaucrat running things, this was not good for the empire.
 
Although I should note that my ultimate inspiration for this particular episode came from another part of Chinese history entirely. And I have no more to say about that!
"The emperor incognito among the commoners" and "another part of Chinese history entirely" steers the mind towards a particularly sad/heartwarming/melancholic footnote in Chinese history, but I'll avoid specifics because there's a very generous chance what I'm thinking of is wrong.

Looking forward to the Tianqi Emperor's adventures all the same. A bit of unstructured exposure to the normal lives of the commoners could do the emperor (and all of China) some good.
 
Top