15 Wilted Roses: The Lives and Deaths of the Wives of King Henry VIII

Chapter One: A Birth at Placentia
Prelude
King Henry the 8th is one of history's most well-known and infamous characters, being described as 'the truth behind Bluebeard', or even 'England's first serial killer'.

This is, as every British schoolchild comes to learn, due to the… oftentimes questionable fates of his many, many wives.

Chapter One: A Birth at Placentia

The date is June 28th, 1491, and Elizabeth of York - the current Queen of England - has just gone into labour. The King, while crossing his fingers for another boy, needn't be too worried. He already has a male heir and so this would simply be a spare, as the old adage says.

Much to his delight the child is indeed a boy, and the birth goes along without much complication; He is christened Henry Tudor. In spite of the risks of the time, the child makes it through infancy with ease and health. Despite being second born, it is still seen to that he gets a good education, being taught multiple languages and the histories of not only his own land, but also those around him.

Within just the first few years of his life, young Henry is assigned all manner of roles and titles for which he has no use or understanding of, in his fathers attempts to retain personal control of lucrative positions and not share them with established families. This takes on another face in 1495, when Henry is but 4 years old, as the King arranges his future marriage to the newborn Eleanor of Austria to secure, albeit some years in the future, a very valuable alliance.

Little did he know, she would be far from his son's only wife.

YoungPrinceHenry.png

Prince Henry in his adolescence
 
Last edited:
Chapter Two: Habsburg Precociousness
Chapter Two: Habsburg Precociousness

The rise of the House of Habsburg had been no small feat. In just a few generations, they now had control over the HRE and through a lucky marraige and inheritance, the Burgundian Netherlands.

All wasn't exactly smooth sailing however, and the Netherlands proved to be a thorn in Emperor Maximilian's back as he attempted to exert far more control over the region than the locals were willing to allow.

Cue a number of wars and the assignment of Albert of Saxony to control the area in the Emperor's name, as he was now very keen to just leave the region to it's own devices - it was more trouble than it was worth, and he still legally controlled it after all.

As a result, he and his family continued to spend much of their time in Austria and Germany. His son Philip was born at Wiener Neustadt in 1478, just South of Vienna, as was his granddaughter Eleanor in 1495.

Philip quickly began growing bored of the day to day of the court, and had pushed his father to allow him more freedom - one of the major points of contention being a potential marraige. As a result, Philip was able to coax his father into arranging a marraige for him with Joanna of Castille, and the two married in 1494 at 16 and 15 years old. Within a year, they would have their first child, Eleanor.

And thus, Philip layed out a similar progression for his offspring, being quick to marry them off for political favours. Within weeks of his daughter's birth, she was alreay engaged to the toddler Prince of England.

Eleanor and Henry would write one another throughout their childhoods, and seemingly developed quite a real interest in one another. Thus, when Henry was just 14 and his bride-to-be only 10, he took a leaf out of his father-in-law's book and nagged his father into pushing the marraige along. The two would officialy wed on Christmas Eve, 1505.

The marraige was not to last, however. Eleanor would fall pregnant in mid-1506, giving birth to a baby girl, Mary, on the 18th of February, 1507. Complications during the birth led to Eleanor developing childbed fever, and passing not long after. This is most commonly attributed to her extremely young age at the time of the pregnancy.

Eleanor's death would hit Henry incredibly hard, and he has been described as becoming increasingly jaded as time went on. In his adulthood he still possessed a certain charisma when necessary, however was prone to occasional fits of rage over oftentimes seemingly innocuous things. Throughout her life, the Princess Mary would receive special treatment from Henry that his other children did not, likely due to his affinity for Eleanor.

Despite Henry's protests, following his wife's passing the King would insist on another marraige to cash in on having a single son again.

YoungElearor.png

The forever-young Eleanor of Austria, born 1495, married 1505, died 1507

Issue:

With Eleanor of Austria

1. Mary, born 1507
 
Last edited:
This takes on another face in 1495, when Henry is but 4 years old, as the King arranges his future marriage to the newborn Eleanor of Austria to secure, albeit some years in the future, a very valuable alliance.
Henry is still the second son, right? In that case NO WAY will he be betrothed to an archduchess of Austria ESPECIALLY not the oldest one
The two would officialy wed on Christmas Eve, 1505.​
She CANNOT marry legally before she turns 12
This is most commonly attributed to her extremely young age at the time of the pregnancy.​
As the grandson of Margaret Beaufort I would think he learned better...

Also what did you use to create these pictures?
 
Last edited:
As the grandson of Margaret Beaufort I would think he learned better...
She's still alive and can tell her, personally. Of course, about the only scene that worked in the Red Queen series was Beaufort explaining how to understand the will of god to her grandson.
 
There’s no way that Eleanor is having a kid that early.
I have to agree. Plus there is already a disturbing amount of posts on this board with a thing for early teenage pregnancy. Please stop having girls under the age of seventeen having children in TLs and stop bringing up Margaret Beaufort to justify it.
 
I have to agree. Plus there is already a disturbing amount of posts on this board with a thing for early teenage pregnancy. Please stop having girls under the age of seventeen having children in TLs and stop bringing up Margaret Beaufort to justify it.
a Pregnancy at 16 was not unheard in the time period.
 
I have to agree. Plus there is already a disturbing amount of posts on this board with a thing for early teenage pregnancy. Please stop having girls under the age of seventeen having children in TLs and stop bringing up Margaret Beaufort to justify it.
TBF, Margret Beaufort isn’t even that good of an justification given she couldn’t have children afterwards. It’s literally a case study in why this shouldn’t be a thing in TLs. Maybe the girl might be lucky and survive, maybe she’ll even have a few more kids, but far more likely is that she ends up dead.
 
I have to agree. Plus there is already a disturbing amount of posts on this board with a thing for early teenage pregnancy. Please stop having girls under the age of seventeen having children in TLs and stop bringing up Margaret Beaufort to justify it.
She's literally 11 years old...it's likely she isn't even menstruating yet!
 
Unless Arthur dies in infancy and Henry is heir to the throne he won't be betrothed to Eleanor of Austria because she's too good a match to waste on a second son. Moreover canon age for marriage is 12 for girls so they wouldn't marry in 1505, nor would they be allowed to cohabit until she's at least 14 years old.

I would suggest choosing a different first wife for Henry, if the Austrians are really so interested in an English marriage then Maximilian will surely offer his Bavarian nieces, the daughters of his sister Kunigunde—Sidonie (b. 1488); Sybille (b. 1489) and Sabina (b. 1492), all three of them are much likelier options.
 
Eleanor would fall pregnant in mid-1506, giving birth to a baby girl, Mary, on the 18th of February, 1507.​
Dude, no way would Philip and Juana would consent to sending their eleven-year-old daughter to England to get knocked up and die in birthing bed. No way. Henry and England are not that important nor so prominent in Habsburg and European politics at this point.
 
Also, why the Hell does Max just decide to "withdraw" from Burgundy? It's literally the richest part of his realm, and if anything, if his son is born in Vienna (and apparently not heir to Burgundy) the boy's not getting named Philippe. My money would be on either Ernst or Karl.
 
A lot of very valid points said, however I think a number of them are putting far too much of our modern sensibilities onto the past.

In our world (albeit after Henry's older brothers death, though I plan to tackle his life in either the next chapter or one after) in 1508, Henry VII was in serious talks with Maximilian to wed Eleanor to Henry. At that time Eleanor was 9 and Henry was 17, even more eyebrow raising than what I propose here. Ultimately Henry VII would die within a year and the 8th would decide against Eleanor in favour of her aunt, but it was a very likely scenario for a time. And as for the 'no marraige before 12' business, there are countless examples where this was conveniently ignored throughout history.

Now, is it a particularly pleasant scenario to have people of their ages wed and impregnate? Of course not, I would never try to insinuate that this is normal, good, or somehow better than real life. It is simply a scenario I am playing out, and one I needn't focus on for too long given it's nature.

Also the comments about England not being worth such a prestigious marraige at this time I simply have to disagree with. The Habsburgs and England both have long standing feuds with France, Henry VIII even launching his own campaign there to retake land lost in the 100 years war due to their still living claims. Austria at this time has no other potential allies with that amount of just cause to back them in conflicts with their main rival.
 
Also, why the Hell does Max just decide to "withdraw" from Burgundy? It's literally the richest part of his realm, and if anything, if his son is born in Vienna (and apparently not heir to Burgundy) the boy's not getting named Philippe. My money would be on either Ernst or Karl.
He doesn't withdraw in the sense that he just abandons it, he is just less hands on, focusing more on the germanic territories. Far better (in his mind, in this world) to let someone else do the governing if he can still reap the riches and hold the titles, rather than risk harming himself and his families name in the region further?
 
Chapter Three: Gallic Failures
Chapter Three: Gallic Failures

It is the year 1507, and Johann Wilhelm of Jülich-Cleves-Berg is dead with no heirs to succeed him. Emperor Rudolf II has claims to the duchies stemming from intermarriage, however he is unable to declare his intentions openly without compromising his perceived neutrality. A total of six other claimants appear, with the rulers of the Margraviate of Brandenburg and the Duchy of Palatinate-Neuburg having the only credible claims through their marriage to Johann Wilhelm's aunts. Within a week a regency is established, including the duke's wife, Antoinette of Lorraine; the privy councillors; and an imperial commissioner. Later that month, Rudolf II announces that the Aulic Council was to provide a definite verdict within four weeks.

Brandenburg and Neuburg, however, view the regency as a direct attempt at annexing the duchy. Upon hearing the Imperial declaration, they sign a treaty of their own, rejecting all other claimants and establishing a provisional government together with the local estates. Their troops enter the duchy in defiance to the acting regency and the Emperor. War has begun.

The war quickly spreads, and more nations and leaders begin tossing their hats in the ring. France and the Netherlands field troops to their borders in shows of strength in favour of Brandenburg and Neuburg, and Austria opens talks with England on their potential involvement. Despite Eleanor's very fresh death, they are especially keen to keep the alliance alive now that it could prove helpful.

Henry VII, eager to overshadow his defeat to France in 1492 when he had failed to maintain Breton independence, agrees to join the war. Plans are drawn up to 'retake' Aquitaine in the summer (the 100 years war, while in the past, still had its embers burning…).

Emboldened by this fresh possibility, Henry begins searching for a marriage for his son that could potentially aid him. It doesn't take long for him to remember a proposal made by Louise of Savoy, wife of Charles the Count of Angoulême, in 1502 offering her daughter up for marriage to Prince Henry. Of course, she was courteously rebuffed as there was a much loftier union in the works, but now, well now it didn't seem like a bad idea at all.

The invasion fleet sets sail, with both the King and the Prince of Wales on board. Within weeks of landing, just months after his first wife's death, Henry has a second spouse in Margaret of Angoulême.

MargaretAngeloume.png

Margaret of Angoulême, born 1492, married 1507, died 1509
The festivities wouldn't last long, however, as the war turns out to be… less than successful. The war in Germany is a failure for the Emperor, the English distraction in the West not being enough to pull attention from Jülich, and after 2 years and an eerily reminiscent last stand at Castillon, the remaining English forces are pushed out to sea with their tails between their legs.

The losses of the war are great, and changes on the map are slight. France annexes the last English holdout in Calais, and Margaret of Angoulême is captured and tried for treason. She is decapitated by sword, as opposed to hanging, given her noble status. A comfort in her last moments, for sure.

The war, however, was not satisfied, and would vow to take one last victim.

A few months after returning from campaign, Henry VII would die from tuberculosis despite relatively good health prior to contraction. Some have since somewhat poetically theorised that he simply let himself be taken by the disease due to his shame at failing in France, though realistically it is far more likely that he simply couldn't be adequately cared for with the medicine of the time.

And so, now King Henry VIII sits on the throne. Twice widowed with only a single female heir and no other close successors, he resigns himself to finding yet another spouse.
 
Last edited:
Top