Huh, if "the war" is some time after the revolution of the 1920s and as implied truly international in scope, then this is the big one. Now maybe history has so changed around that WW2 is relatively conventional powers duking it out just for material resources, perhaps 'just' a reactionary military junta Germany brawling with fascist Italy and nationalist Poland and France going through a full Spanish style meltdown and civil war or something, in which case the Americans not giving a shit as the dumb capitalists set all their assets on fire to shoot at other capitalists and just reaping the rewards a la Switzerland or Spain in ww1 makes complete sense. But crucially even in a scenario with off brand notzis and diet fascists or even without nazis at all would still have a lot of vehemently anti-Communist chaps very interested in restoring the glory of Germany/Poland/Spain/Romania/etc..., etc... and crushing Wilson's pet abominations and the disease of socialism once and for all. Combined with the name drop of the Allied Nations means I don't really think this timeline's WW2 would be just an ideologically tepid soup of state conflict like the return of the 18th century cabinet wars or something. So this atl WW2 is still WW2.
Plus, even in the build up to revolutionary consciousness and politicization of the proletariat, the IWW was founded only in 1905, and would take years of bitter toil to successfully eat up the chunks of the AFL that would have turned to the CIO otl and survive the immense pressure placed on the organization by Pinkerton legbreakers and sheriffs' posses, labor-busting courts and legislatures, and the FBI and its predecessors, so even if the various union boys and labor socialists that would become the atl IWW attempted major protests and general strikes, it's quite likely that the then governing institutions of the old America could have easily powered through and still grabbed all those delicious Spanish colonies for America's new empire. And so within American socialism, even the more reformist right and center of the SLP itself, would come a lot of the same bullshit as afflicted the British Labor Party or the French Radical-Socialists and SFIO, where anti-imperialist mandates would be officially placed on the party manifesto, but a lot of the language of eugenic scientific racism and "white man's burden" civilizing rhetoric would bleed in from the right and be adapted by not explicitly anti-racists and Filipino revolutionaries just utterly dismissed and told to wait until the revolution has emancipated America's working classes before talking about maybe perhaps freeing America's colonies. Thus even with the burgeoning muscles of a large organized socialist movement in American politics I wouldn't expect the effect of the SLP's anti-imperialist to be that much more effective than that of the contemporary Democratic Party, maybe even less effective atl as a lot of the immigrant political machines and northern Democrats are captured by a different party and thus divide the anti-imperialists between two different organizations.
So as the confused nascent mess eventually turns into the Cooperative Commonwealth, the new America still largely has the same dynamic as the old in relation to promising eventual independence and sovereignty for the Philippines and waxing and waning on the exact timeline and generally playing hot and cold with the most misshapen half-formed colonial empire of the great powers. This means that the Commonwealth's interests are still thrust directly into the Pacific theater and are intimately intertwined with the similar and opposed interests of Japan and Britain, along with several new grudges formed by the probable shenaniganry of the various other powers supporting American governments-in-exile and hoping for a Blue counter-revolution and also trying to "police" Guam and Panama while the revolution was ongoing.
All this is a very very long winded way to say, it's super weird that America never got involved and at least officially declared war on the worst fascists trying to throw the rest of the Comintern into camps, even if this timeline has no Barbarossa invading the Soviet Union, or exploding into a hot conflict with Japan over the reign of terror over China and Japanese attacks on the colonies America had rightfully stolen. Even if the official war might not be much deeper than being the "arsenal of democracy" they already were, it would be absolutely crucial to projecting American strength over its sphere of influence so threatened by worldwide war and also a much more important tool to help comrades across the world decolonize their captive nations and build themselves into "People's Commonwealth" American clients than our otl America needed, being deprived of Marshall Plan and Bretton-Woods levels of intimacy inside the financial systems of the colonial powers and not having the ability to wave around their debts if they pull a Suez Crisis. It's a whole lot easier to train, arm, supply, and support cadres of anti-colonial pro-Commonwealth partisans under the banner of WW2 military mobilization, after all.
Plus, even in the build up to revolutionary consciousness and politicization of the proletariat, the IWW was founded only in 1905, and would take years of bitter toil to successfully eat up the chunks of the AFL that would have turned to the CIO otl and survive the immense pressure placed on the organization by Pinkerton legbreakers and sheriffs' posses, labor-busting courts and legislatures, and the FBI and its predecessors, so even if the various union boys and labor socialists that would become the atl IWW attempted major protests and general strikes, it's quite likely that the then governing institutions of the old America could have easily powered through and still grabbed all those delicious Spanish colonies for America's new empire. And so within American socialism, even the more reformist right and center of the SLP itself, would come a lot of the same bullshit as afflicted the British Labor Party or the French Radical-Socialists and SFIO, where anti-imperialist mandates would be officially placed on the party manifesto, but a lot of the language of eugenic scientific racism and "white man's burden" civilizing rhetoric would bleed in from the right and be adapted by not explicitly anti-racists and Filipino revolutionaries just utterly dismissed and told to wait until the revolution has emancipated America's working classes before talking about maybe perhaps freeing America's colonies. Thus even with the burgeoning muscles of a large organized socialist movement in American politics I wouldn't expect the effect of the SLP's anti-imperialist to be that much more effective than that of the contemporary Democratic Party, maybe even less effective atl as a lot of the immigrant political machines and northern Democrats are captured by a different party and thus divide the anti-imperialists between two different organizations.
So as the confused nascent mess eventually turns into the Cooperative Commonwealth, the new America still largely has the same dynamic as the old in relation to promising eventual independence and sovereignty for the Philippines and waxing and waning on the exact timeline and generally playing hot and cold with the most misshapen half-formed colonial empire of the great powers. This means that the Commonwealth's interests are still thrust directly into the Pacific theater and are intimately intertwined with the similar and opposed interests of Japan and Britain, along with several new grudges formed by the probable shenaniganry of the various other powers supporting American governments-in-exile and hoping for a Blue counter-revolution and also trying to "police" Guam and Panama while the revolution was ongoing.
All this is a very very long winded way to say, it's super weird that America never got involved and at least officially declared war on the worst fascists trying to throw the rest of the Comintern into camps, even if this timeline has no Barbarossa invading the Soviet Union, or exploding into a hot conflict with Japan over the reign of terror over China and Japanese attacks on the colonies America had rightfully stolen. Even if the official war might not be much deeper than being the "arsenal of democracy" they already were, it would be absolutely crucial to projecting American strength over its sphere of influence so threatened by worldwide war and also a much more important tool to help comrades across the world decolonize their captive nations and build themselves into "People's Commonwealth" American clients than our otl America needed, being deprived of Marshall Plan and Bretton-Woods levels of intimacy inside the financial systems of the colonial powers and not having the ability to wave around their debts if they pull a Suez Crisis. It's a whole lot easier to train, arm, supply, and support cadres of anti-colonial pro-Commonwealth partisans under the banner of WW2 military mobilization, after all.
Last edited:
