Deleted member 82792
In Syndicalist countries, do people who aren't factory workers, such as scientists, actors or accountants make their own unions?
Kaiserreich: Legacy of the Weltkrieg
- Thread starter RiverDelta
- Start date
Yeah, in theory. The idea is to have everybody who produces something valuable or does something useful represented.
Writers would probably have amateur press associations (there was a pretty bustling scene in the US after World War I that collected dues and contributed articles and fiction to specific journals and literary magazines, for example) while private detectives would probably have some sort of professional organization to handle licensing and such
Deleted member 82792
Makes sense. I wish the wiki would explain it better.
I had two campaigns on the same day as the Qing, on the vanilla and in KR
Vanilla
KR
To say that the difference is night and day is a understatement.
On Vanilla you have four officers, with one being Yoshiko Kawashima who was not a real army officer. You have four possible ministers, three are useless (fortification engineer, armaments minister and the third is a capitain of industry you can only get if you don't challenge Japan) and a illusive gentlemen, who is not needed in KR since you can pay 150 PP to get one there. I got von Falkenhausen through a focus, but everyone in China can get him so he doesn't count.
There is only two events in the whole vanilla campaign, one about your independence war and a second for when you unify China.
The only positive thing I think I can mention about vanilla is that you can get achievements.
Vanilla
KR
To say that the difference is night and day is a understatement.
On Vanilla you have four officers, with one being Yoshiko Kawashima who was not a real army officer. You have four possible ministers, three are useless (fortification engineer, armaments minister and the third is a capitain of industry you can only get if you don't challenge Japan) and a illusive gentlemen, who is not needed in KR since you can pay 150 PP to get one there. I got von Falkenhausen through a focus, but everyone in China can get him so he doesn't count.
There is only two events in the whole vanilla campaign, one about your independence war and a second for when you unify China.
The only positive thing I think I can mention about vanilla is that you can get achievements.
Last edited:
jparker77
Banned
I’m doing a Japan game. I really like the four dynamic army doctrine trees, one of the coolest things I’ve seen in Kaiserreich and something which really helps emphasize the difference between the doctrine options you can choose, which tbh I don’t think HOI4 does very well.
I decided to go down the “Supremacy of Will” path, which I think is probably the closest to Japan’s OTL doctrine.
I decided to go down the “Supremacy of Will” path, which I think is probably the closest to Japan’s OTL doctrine.
is government positions included in this, specifically thinking bureaucrat and the military
Almost certainly not. Plenty of the administration are assholes, but they won't be crazy people like the Nazis.
Chainbreaker
John Brown’s Body
Hard Work Or Hardly Working
Keep On Truckin’
Thank God It’s Friday
Weydemeyer
Shakers
Warren
Fourier
Debs
Haymarket
New New Harmony
Oneida
Amana
Icarian
Bishop Hill
Aurora
Bethel
Cabet
Appeal to Reason
Last edited:
Chainbreaker and Appeal to Reason sound pretty goods actually. There was a few I had as well. I didn’t want to give them state names, since I thought that would be too easy. These were all names I wanted to give to battleships.
Some were:
CNS Miracle of May
CNS Red Summer
CNS March Revolution
CNS Bread and Roses
CNS Tyrannicide
CNS Defender
CNS Guardian
CNS Crimson Storm
CNS Peace of August
CNS Vanguard
CNS Syndicate
CNS Peoples’ Will
CNS Insurgent
CNS Continental Congress
CNS Union
CNS Solidarity
CNS Hammer of Industry
CNS Liberator
CNS Revolutionary
* - I edited in some more.
Last edited:
I don't think it'd be too different from the Japan we know. In the 1900s, Japan was trying to keep a lid on a growing leftist movement. In TTL, with syndicalism sweeping across Europe, I can definitely see a version of the Public Safety Preservation Law of 1925 (which effectively banned socialist organizations in Japan) being implemented. You could still have the Thought Police, or God forbid, the Kempeitai cracking down on public and colonial dissent.