I think what got peoples backs up is that the title combined with bits like
Made people go "Oh look, its time for a well researched round of werhabingo." And yeah the language of that bit above basically goes "the 'clean' Nazi general is a god among men, the british were paint thinner sniffing morons.' And when something is usually praising the usual suspects of the German military (Manstein, Guduerian, Rommel etc) beyond what they were really like and to an unhealthy degree like above, it is a case of breaking out the bingo cards to see what gets checked off the list.
The problem with your de-rigure Nazi victory stuff is that really, it was damn damn damn hard, not just like 'well if this bridge was captured then...' or 'If only X piece of gucchi nazi kit came into service then....' but 'If this happens, then that happens, then America goes communist some time in the 1920s and the British and French general staff officers drink lead paint from the age of 2 and still get into position whilst Churchill gets struck by a car and everyone else in the UK govermnent after the fall of france goes 'that hitler fellow might be trustworthy this time' whilst Yellowstone erupts in America and the Norse Gods appear due to Himmler's pagan rituals and are bound to serve the Nazi's then yes. Sealion could work.' Levels of handwavium, and there's been LOTS of stories here like that, or ones where you get idealized super nazis who are clean and friendly because hitler gets better and they give the jews flowers instead of zyclon b. Or in one aggregious case where The Nazis did amazingly, and the Allies were beyond incompetent, and the author spent barely a sentence on the Final Solution, punctuating it with the words 'done humanely'....
So yeah, the title and Saint Rommel of the Panzer did result in
Getting brought out.
You've done a ton of research, but Rommel wasn't a god and Nazi logistics were hugely stretched getting as far as he did, and the UK literally cannot afford to lose the Suez, it literally cannot, i'll see where this goes but i'm sure you've telegraphed it in the title.