I can no longer seem to get the Progressives in power as the Feds
Yeah, that one's kinda weird. Any idea why it was removed? Maybe just let them be electable if Olson was president, but still.
I can no longer seem to get the Progressives in power as the Feds
If you don’t mind me asking, why exactly would Henry Wallace make for a better President than Quentin? Correct me if I’m wrong here, but doesn’t Quentin’s portrait description state that he’s been involved in Republican politics for quite a while? Before he became Secretary of Agriculture IOTL, Wallace had no political experience whatsoever, and that appears to still be the case in KR, as I recall the event describing Wallace being nominated by the Progressive Party saying that he was Olson’s Secretary of Agriculture.Maybe I'm just biased in thinking that Henry Wallace would make a better President than Quentin Roosevelt given the circumstances
This is coming from someone who doesn't have Kaiserreich installed, but I never really understood the obsession with the United States avoiding the 2nd ACW. I get the idea of trying to avoid it for the sake of a challenge in-game, but what I don't get is why people seem to be keen on preventing the 2nd ACW in their own scenarios, like in KR TLs on this site. In my opinion, the 2nd ACW and its factions are much more interesting, especially from a world-building perspective, than the United States avoiding the conflict, which, as far as I can tell, had much less lore in-game anyway. And the 2nd ACW has always felt like a defining feature of the Kaiserreich world to me (the modders seem to think so too if their YouTube channel is anything to go off of), which just makes it even more odd to me that there's a small trend in KR TLs to replace a core component of the scenario with a relatively bland United States that isn't extremely different from OTL aside from being in the Kaiserreich world.
But by the start date of Kaiserreich, all of the factions for the 2nd ACW already exist. There’s still widespread support for the SPA, there’s still a Minuteman militia, and there’s still Douglas MacArthur prepared to overthrow the government. So the implausible stuff that leads to the 2nd ACW still exists, regardless of what happens next.Plausibility, mostly. If you're getting rid of the Mongolian Khan, why is America fated to go into a civil war when none of these factions existed in OTL?
But by the start date of Kaiserreich, all of the factions for the 2nd ACW already exist. There’s still widespread support for the SPA, there’s still a Minuteman militia, and there’s still Douglas MacArthur prepared to overthrow the government. So the implausible stuff that leads to the 2nd ACW still exists, regardless of what happens next.
I disagree. With a 10-year Depression even worse than OTL, no WW1 debt repayments, no New Deal (which happened after only THREE years of Depression OTL), significant changes in European politics from OTL, an implied-to-be-terrible McAdoo/Palmer administration that probably undid a lot of progressive legislation, and a reunified, radicalizing labor movement, it's IMO plausible that, with the double-dip of Black Monday AND Huey's Senagovernator antics casting further doubt on the stability of the political system, a civil war might break out after further failures by the government to solve anything.I agree that the leadup to the ACW is implausible.
Look, it's their game, if they don't like that America is too powerful (a problem that doesn't bother most people who play WW2 games) they can make up whatever reason they want for it. But let's not pretend it's realistic to have millions of Americans take up arms to defend a radical workers movement that never came close to success in OTL, with a POD 16 years in the past.
It might be implausible, but what I’m saying is that the implausible aspects of the 2nd ACW have already happened. The political parties of the US don’t just spontaneously decide to rise up, this has been building up for years prior to the start date. This means that even if the 2nd ACW is avoided, the implausible instability and internal factionalism in the United States has already happened.I agree that the leadup to the ACW is implausible.
Look, it's their game, if they don't like that America is too powerful (a problem that doesn't bother most people who play WW2 games) they can make up whatever reason they want for it. But let's not pretend it's realistic to have millions of Americans take up arms to defend a radical workers movement that never came close to success in OTL, with a POD 16 years in the past.
I disagree. With a 10-year Depression even worse than OTL, no WW1 debt repayments, no New Deal (which happened after only THREE years of Depression OTL), significant changes in European politics from OTL, an implied-to-be-terrible McAdoo/Palmer administration that probably undid a lot of progressive legislation, and a reunified, radicalizing labor movement, it's IMO plausible that, with the double-dip of Black Monday AND Huey's Senagovernator antics casting further doubt on the stability of the political system, a civil war might break out after further failures by the government to solve anything.
At the same time, though, there would be limited British royalist financial assets still in the country after the mess of the Weltkrieg, that hadn't already been claimed as collateral for loan defaults anyway. Even then, the US in the '20s and '30s was an unstable and unregulated financial Wild West in dire need of Keynesian economics, and that holds true here; simply closing the stock exchange isn't going to do much to ameliorate the collapse of a house of cards, and a still-demilitarized United States with no WW1 buildup is going to have to deal with an angry, hypermilitarized Canada that will not respond favorably to a seizure of British assets thanks to the new royalist regime in Ottawa.Except McAdoo was In OTL a very efficient treasury secretary who probably would've done much to mitigate the effects of a Stock Market crash in wake of the British collapse up to and including closing the NYSE and likely beginning a mass seizure of British financial assets. Nor does KR make much sense with Black Monday affecting the US so seriously considering if the Wall Street Crash is basically rerunning 1929 than the United States would have likely insulated itself from much of the global economy and the most especially the German Sphere thus limiting the effect of BM.
So... for whatever reason, someone just sent me this on reddit: https://imgur.com/a/pbqL02N.
It's an album of supposed leaks of a future Spain rework. No idea how true it is, I just scrolled through, but there seems be a lot of information. So even if it's not true, it might be a look at someone's in-depth wishlist.
At the same time, though, there would be limited British royalist financial assets still in the country after the mess of the Weltkrieg, that hadn't already been claimed as collateral for loan defaults anyway. Even then, the US in the '20s and '30s was an unstable and unregulated financial Wild West in dire need of Keynesian economics, and that holds true here; simply closing the stock exchange isn't going to do much to ameliorate the collapse of a house of cards, and a still-demilitarized United States with no WW1 buildup is going to have to deal with an angry, hypermilitarized Canada that will not respond favorably to a seizure of British assets thanks to the new royalist regime in Ottawa.
I was under the impression (please correct me if I'm wrong) that the '25 KR Canadian military was massively expanded by British loyalists in the Army and Navy who came over with the King and His Fecklessness. That might give the royalist leaders the confidence to take a stab at seizing NYC in an attempt to repeat 1812 and force the US to comply with their demands. Might. Especially since the US hasn't TTL undergone the naval and army buildups and reforms of OTL's late '10s and early '20s.Also Worffan you are the last person I would think to suggest a Canadian military response to the US seizure of British assets. The Canadian Army even it followed the recommendations of the Otter Commission would be ill-suited to conduct a campaign across the vastness of the United States let alone when the nation is taking in British refugees and trying to hold together what's left of the empire.
Seems in line with what the Spanish dev team has planned and what we know of the reworked SCW, however, Unless the leaker did this with the approval of the KR team it seems rather unethical
I was under the impression (please correct me if I'm wrong) that the '25 KR Canadian military was massively expanded by British loyalists in the Army and Navy who came over with the King and His Fecklessness. That might give the royalist leaders the confidence to take a stab at seizing NYC in an attempt to repeat 1812 and force the US to comply with their demands. Might. Especially since the US hasn't TTL undergone the naval and army buildups and reforms of OTL's late '10s and early '20s.
Fair enough. Still, I question the ability of McAdoo and his thuggish VP to bring relief to the ordinary American, and am willing to suspend disbelief for KR's timeline given (a) that KR is simply the best story at present ever told with HOI4 (especially compared to over-the-top memefests like that dumb The New Order mod, and the, um, mess, to use the politest possible term, of vanilla's AH options), and (b) crazier things have happened IRL.I mean it might be expanded on paper but to put some things in perspective Canada in 1925 has no Naval base capable of sustaining all the RN elements that go into exile. That probably would have changed within a few years but as off 1925 just after the British revolution? Canada is gonna need some crash programs just to be able to maintain the forces they have as well as integrating the million - 2 million British refugees that flee across the Atlantic let alone trying to pick a fight with the continental hegemon.
Also the USN as of 1925 would be massive considering KRs naval lore the USN in 1925 has something to the tune of 13 Standard BB, 6 SoDak (1920) BB, Three Tillman IV-1s, a Tillman IV-2, Six Lexington CC (apparently modified to compensate for shitty armour), and another Six Yorktown (Lexington derivatives closer to a fast BB than a CC). The RN has something like 6 G3, 3 N3, an Admiral Class, and a smattering of older DNs with no operating base and no hope of resupply for a while.